3 ms·
What's the difference between a narc and a whistleblower again?
by pessimizer 14y ago
What's the difference between a narc and a whistleblower again?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 14y agoWhat does that mean?
- BCM43 14y agoA whistleblower informs on the powers-that-be to the public, a narc informs on members of the public to the powers that be. One lets the public or their community decide, the other appeals to an authority to come into the community and take care of the problem.
- scott_s 14y agoPeople who report illegal actions inside private companies to law enforcement or regulatory authorities are still called "whistleblowers."
- pessimizer 14y agoSeriously: are you a whistleblower if you report your neighbor to the cops for burning leaves? My conception of a whistleblower is someone who reports the behavior of closed institutions to the public. Other institutions might then take actions on behalf of the public, but isn't what makes the whistleblower a whistleblower. If you work as an accountant for a major company that is avoiding paying taxes through obscure and morally questionable, yet legal loopholes, you're still a whistleblower. If you report your neighbor for burning leaves in his yard, you've got to be a narc. Describing people who make anonymous reports to police as whistleblowers seems at least editorial, and at most simply deceptive. edit: a better counter-example might be a defector from the Mafia who reports their illegal activities to the police. Is he/she a whistleblower, or a narc?