3 ms·
I would also like to see a clause that specifies that, when a third party assigns a patent to Twitter, they get to use any of Twitter's patents for defensive pu
by btilly 14y ago
I would also like to see a clause that specifies that, when a third party assigns a patent to Twitter, they get to use any of Twitter's patents for defensive purposes.
How do you use patents defensively against a patent troll with no products? The only method that I see is to offer the troll the option to purchase another patent in return for an agreement to not pursue their existing one.
Reading the fine print of http://www.rpxcorp.com/index.cfm?pageid=23 http://www.rpxcorp.com/index.cfm?pageid=23 some time ago lead me to think that they do exactly this. They've taken out the text that lead me to think that they do so, but how else could their central market position help after patent litigation has begun?
- StavrosK 14y agoHow do you use patents offensively against a patent troll with no products? There's no drawback in that situation. The only problem is the fear of creating such a monster while trying to do good.
- btilly 14y agoI agree that for the company being sued, there is no downside to feeding the patent troll monster by selling a desirable patent to a known patent troll, and there is no cheaper way out if you've got a large portfolio of patents. But for the tech ecosystem as a whole, there are huge downsides. I feel this personally because a former employer got three patents from my work, then assigned them to that particular pool. Despite my personal belief that those patents should not be patents, they could potentially be asserted against some popular technologies and big companies, and if they did then I'd be legally obliged to testify. (This is not a mistake that I feel inclined to repeat, but a decade ago I was not as informed as I now am...)
- StavrosK 14y agoI mean there's no drawback in having your patents unusable for offense, since you wouldn't have a product to use them against, even if you could. Selling a patent to a troll obviously has huge downsides, as you said.
- btilly 14y agoWhen sued by a patent troll, I agree. But, for instance, if you're part of the whole mobile patent lawsuit mess, then it is darned hard to tell the difference between a defensive lawsuit and an offensive one.