3 ms·
There is a quote I have no attribution for, but I recall seeing it a long time ago, long before 2650x1440 displays were economical: "The desktop metaphor works
by Zigurd 14y ago
There is a quote I have no attribution for, but I recall seeing it a long time ago, long before 2650x1440 displays were economical: "The desktop metaphor works better when your screen is the size of a desk."
Handsets don't need a desktop metaphor. Tablets don't need a desktop metaphor. So the question is, do you make an operating system for devices that do not need and should not have a desktop metaphor, or do you try to stuff a mature operating system imbued with the desktop metaphor into a tablet?
The inappropriateness of the Modern/Metro UI in Windows 8 goes deeper than the user experience. Modern/Metro UI apps are severely limited in their ability to communicate with other apps. They are over-sandboxed and crippled compared to both Windows desktop apps and Android apps. And yet, Modern/Metro UI is the only way to implement a satisfactory touch UI in Windows 8.
The result is a mess of hardware that enables touch, with dubious ergonomics and software that is limited but touch-appropriate or powerful but bad at touch.
- aerique 14y agoI think Jeff Brooks compared the desktop metaphor to be more like a "flightseat"[1] metaphor. Let me look it up. Found it, and I meant Fred Brooks ofcourse: http://www.anvari.org/fortune/Miscellaneous_Collections/273415_the-so-called-desktop-metaphor-of-todays-workstations-is-instead-an-airplane-seat-metaphor.html http://www.anvari.org/fortune/Miscellaneous_Collections/2734... [1] like in an airplane.
- sixothree 14y agoI have two 24" monitors and two 17" laptops on my desk right now. Windows 8 is definitely not for me.