4 ms·
> Google started by dropping XMPP invites under the questionable guise of spam protection. Shortly thereafter, we learned at 2013 Google IO that their real moti
by gwern 14y ago
> Google started by dropping XMPP invites under the questionable guise of spam protection. Shortly thereafter, we learned at 2013 Google IO that their real motive was to drop XMPP entirely and move to a closed platform. I’m sure that timeline is a coincidence. No really.
If this is true, it makes fools out of everyone on HN who defended Google and poo-pooed the reaction to the XMPP spam move as being merely geek hysteria and paranoia and a massively overblown fit being thrown by prima donnas, saying that it was merely an anti-spam move and surely not a prelude to scrapping XMPP entirely.
- aniket_ray 14y agoUmm ... XMPP is not being dropped only support for XMPP federation.
- claudius 14y agoAnd what’s the point of XMPP if you drop federation?
- nileshtrivedi 14y agoWell, you can continue using third-party XMPP clients like Pidgin. Federation has the inherent problem of spamming. I think whitelisting domains could have been a way out.
- claudius 14y agoI’ve been using XMPP for quite a while, first on jabber.ccc.de, then on my own server (and on a Google account in parallel), but have so far not received a single spam message. Is XMPP spamming really a thing?
- nileshtrivedi 14y agoThat's what Google claims: Chee Chew said that "we haven't seen significant uptake" in federation with Google Talk via server-to-server connections. The majority of the uptake Google did see was from organizations or individuals looking to bombard Google Talk users with chat spam, Chew said. http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/05/hands-on-with-hangouts-googles-new-text-and-video-chat-architecture/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/05/hands-... This is the original email thread with more details when Google disabled XMPP federation for a while in GTalk: http://mail.jabber.org/pipermail/operators/2013-February/001571.html http://mail.jabber.org/pipermail/operators/2013-February/001...
- gwern 14y agoThe quote is 'XMPP entirely'; what do you base your claim on?