2 ms·
Corporations can still distribute revenue and equity as they please. It's a legal structure for taxation and liability. The state forcing corporations to distr
by dmix 14y ago
Corporations can still distribute revenue and equity as they please. It's a legal structure for taxation and liability.
The state forcing corporations to distribute their earnings or equity a certain way is a massively more intrusive structure.
If that was done, it would likely be single handily the greatest manipulation of markets and private assets ever done by a government in modern history.
If an egalitarian equity structure legitimately benefits the companies, they will adopt that structure. If they don't then their competitors would do it as a competitive advantage. Unless it really doesn't benefit the companies and therefore requires the state to involuntary make them do it?
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoIf an egalitarian equity structure legitimately benefits the companies, they will adopt that structure. Interestingly wrong. The problem here is the definition of "benefits the company". The interest of the company is defined as the interest of its shareholders, with the interest of different shareholders counting in proportion to their ownership stake. The equity structure is itself the terminal teleological value of the company, and consumer markets make zero evaluation of that structure except in very specialized sub-cases (like when I deliberately purchase King Arthur Flour for being a worker cooperative, for instance). This is one of those "companies do not evolve" things; state action is the only thing that will ever change company structures away from what the incumbent shareholders want, and even a fresh-founded start-up has incumbent owners in the form of its founders and seed investors.