3 ms·
There is a rudimentary troll block at HN. It just doesn't work very well. The troll block here is "hellbanning." http://toway1234.tumblr.com/post/16021243707/h
by smacktoward 14y ago
There is a rudimentary troll block at HN. It just doesn't work very well.
The troll block here is "hellbanning." http://toway1234.tumblr.com/post/16021243707/hacker-news-hellbanning-is-unacceptable http://toway1234.tumblr.com/post/16021243707/hacker-news-hel...
The problem is that since hellbanning is inherently passive-aggressive -- nobody in the community knows it's been applied, not even the person who's been banned -- it doesn't teach the community lessons on what behavior is beyond the pale. The banned person simply disappears. This makes life easier for the admins (since it lets them avoid both having to confront the person being banned and a time-consuming discussion of why that person was banned), but at the cost of not putting forward an example of How Not To Be for others to learn from and follow. So people make the same mistakes over and over again.
If people really do need to be thrown out of the community, it'd be healthier to have at least some of that happen via public executions rather than silent disappearances. At least when you see someone up on a gibbet, you get the message not to be like that person if you don't want to end up there yourself.
Full disclosure: I was partially hellbanned myself (submissions only, not comments) for a period, despite having 4,000+ karma at the time. I still don't understand what I did wrong, really. The experience knocked my opinion of HN down a few notches.