4 ms·
"It's important to acknowledge that most commenters on HN do not behave that way, but some do and they are very loud." I think part of this is just the dynamic
by smacktoward 14y ago
"It's important to acknowledge that most commenters on HN do not behave that way, but some do and they are very loud."
I think part of this is just the dynamics of community-moderated comments. In my experience, the way to get upvotes in any such forum (not just HN) is to express an opinion in the strongest terms you possibly can. "X is dead" gets upvotes. "X has some challenges to overcome, and it might" doesn't. People like and respond to simple, clear arguments that don't admit weakness or uncertainty.
This dynamic then feeds on itself, as the people who are the best at forcefully stating their opinions become top commenters, crowding out more cautious voices and providing a bad role model that the next generation of would-be top commenters follows.
How do you fix this? It's poisoned so many great communities I've belonged to, so I wish I knew. But I don't.
EDIT: I have seen one mechanism that helps mitigate this: hide the users' actual karma scores.
Karma is a scoring mechanism. That turns forums that use it into a video game (of the type very well parodied by http://www.forumwarz.com/about http://www.forumwarz.com/about). Participants compete with each other to see who can get the highest score. Hiding the actual numbers from users takes some of the fun out of this, which cuts down on trolling.
Slashdot used to show your exact karma score, and they had these exact same problems. Eventually they switched to just a text label ("Excellent", say, for high-karma users) that indicated your general karmic position, and the comments got a lot better very fast. Nobody's going to put as much time in to go from "Excellent" to "Excellent" as they might to go from, say, 2,500 to 5,000.
- npsimons 14y agoIn my experience, the way to get upvotes in any such forum (not just HN) is to express an opinion in the strongest terms you possibly can. "X is dead" gets upvotes. "X has some challenges to overcome, and it might" doesn't. Of the most satisfying outcomes on HN, mine have been when I've posted a reasoned, moderate comment and been upvoted. Sure, I try and avoid flamefests, and I've noticed a bit of trolling being upvoted, but overall, I think HN has risen above. Maybe I'm wrong, maybe I'm lucky, but it doesn't seem that bad, yet. Of course, there's always room for improvement . . .
- ionforce 14y agoYou fix it with heavy-handed moderation that actively punishes curtly written content.
- redblacktree 14y agoThis is true. It works very well for reddit.com/r/AskHistorians. This is, by far, one of the highest-quality sub-reddits on the site, and it's because of active, heavy-handed moderation that enforces a strict rule set. (e.g. no speculation)
- archagon 14y agoSame for Metafilter (though the rule set is much less strict).
- roguecoder 14y agoThere's an interesting observation in the field of mechanism design that says when any ordering of preferences if possible (that is, it is possible for something like agent X thinks A>B>C and agent Y thinks A>C>B and agent Z thinks C>B>A to happen) the only "truthful" mechanism is dictatorial. Otherwise it is always possible to game the system by voting for outcomes you don't really like as much but you think more other people will like.