6 ms·
I've lived in NYC for over 15 years, and as a resident, AirBnB is definitely a net negative for me and others in my cohort--full time residents. 1. Who wants
by jgalt212 13y ago
I've lived in NYC for over 15 years, and as a resident, AirBnB is definitely a net negative for me and others in my cohort--full time residents.
1. Who wants transients moving about your building? I'm sure most of them are nice, but they are certainly not as invested in exhibiting neighborly behavior as full time residents.
2. If AirBnB became a serious economic force in NYC, it would only make my outrageously expensive city more expensive as apartment rents converged upwards towards hotel rates.
3. If I knew a neighbor was doing very short term sublets via AirBnB, or a similar service, I would definitely report them to the building management company or Police.
4. People need to think carefully about the "sharing economy." Not all applications of this paradigm are a net positive, and despite the hacker ethos not all laws are meant to broken. Many laws that have the effect of protecting entrenched players (hotels in this case), also serve valuable consumer protection functions.
- jvm 13y agoI completely agree that there are negative externalities to AirBNB, so I'm not disagreeing with your conclusion. But point #2, the rising rents thing, seems unlikely to me. AirBNB increases the supply of housing. It does nothing to demand. Prices should drop. I imagine it would either have no perceptible effect on rents, or in an extreme scenario would cause hotels to close and convert to apartments which would lower rents. Finally, this is a common misconception, rents for hotels are identical to rents for residential housing. Otherwise why wouldn't ever landlord switch to running a hotel? It costs more per night to stay at one because (a) you're paying for excessive housekeeping and (b) you're paying for the high vacancy in downtimes caused by ultra-high turnover in tenants. Basically, a high proportion of the hotel fee is paying for actual services, not the building's rent.
- msrpotus 13y agoMight be true in theory but not in NYC. There are constantly cases of illegal hotel conversions where landlords try to run their own hotels. That might be partially to avoid licensing (I know hotels in NYC need special permits) and taxes, but it's not the case that residential landlords don't want to run hotels.
- gav 13y agoThis isn't true in NYC, we're at 98-99% utilization. If anything AirBNB makes this worse, it's encouraging people to rent an apartment to visitors instead of releasing it into the rental market. If you look at a $169/night AirBNB rate, that translates into about $5000/month if it's fully rented. Even at a 90% you are making more money than a 12-month lease. This will encourage landlords to not lease vacant apartments, thus decreasing supply and raising prices. I know of building owners that have been experimenting with AirBNB as it's more profitable for them.
- jvm 13y agoI've said elsewhere, but this is only true if short-term and long-term housing aren't fungible, which could only result from a messed up regulatory structure in need of some serious overhaul.
- fnl 13y agoI think your estimate might possibly be to high: According to what I've been explained by friends who let rooms via AirBnB, you don't fill your rooms or apartment with "average" city rates. You will have to be on the lower end to do that and have a "clean" rating, too. That seems to be about $ 50 for rooms and about double for flats in NYC, therefore I would assume the actual income is more likely to be about half your estimate. On top of that, there is an administrative overhead to normal renting of a flat. And, to be top-ranked, you have to be extra-nice to maintain an excellent rating on the site, too. Not so sure that beats the comforts renting with well-defined contracts... I think AirBnB is for you or your family & friends if you want to use that apartment yourself at times, too, or if you are sharing a room in your flat to pay the mortgage, and similar such cases. It probably does not beat renting, otherwise I assume this service would have gone even more "viral" long ago...
- mapleoin 13y ago> AirBNB increases the supply of housing. It does nothing to demand. That's your error, see also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand
- jvm 13y agoThe mechanism for the induced demand is lower prices. That was my point.
- saalweachter 13y agoAnother factor: AirBNB increases the supply of temporary housing. It can only decrease the supply of 12-month leases. And since 12-month leases are in short supply...
- jvm 13y ago> can only decrease the supply of 12-month leases Temporary and long-term housing should be fungible. I've learned from other commenters that maybe they're not due to the NYC regulatory structure. If so then that's creating horrible distortions, and maybe that's also the reason why AirBNB is so popular.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- saalweachter 13y agoYou can really only convert long-term housing into temporary housing. While technically the Holiday Inn is cool with me staying there as long as I want, they won't cut me a deal and charge me $400 / month instead of $100 / night. The cheapest, sleeziest roadside motel I have ever seen anywhere in the country was $30 / night. For a month that would be $900 with no discount, but I have a hard time imagining that an apartment comparable to that motel was even $300.
- mikegioia 13y agoI've been here for 6 years, and: 1. It is impossible to stop transients from entering your building. Delivery guys, doors left open, friends coming over, etc. You cannot possibly control this and AirBNB at least vets the people coming to stay. 2. I don't understand this, it's already pervasive in NYC and rent has not moved. Why do you think all apartment units in the city will become hotel rooms?
- grimtrigger 13y ago> 1. Who wants transients moving about your building? I'm sure most of them are nice, but they are certainly not as invested in exhibiting neighborly behavior as full time residents. I wouldn't mind new people in the apartment next to mine. There are already plenty of laws to keep them from making too much noise. In fact, most tourists are probably better behaved than residents. > 2. If AirBnB became a serious economic force in NYC, it would only make my outrageously expensive city more expensive as apartment rents converged upwards towards hotel rates. Or hotels (with lower demand) will convert into residential housing, lowering rents and the price of living. I don't think its easy to say which way it would go.
- localhost3000 13y agoit is far far easier and cheaper for a landlord to raise rents than it is for an established hotel to convert into residential housing.
- DoubleMalt 13y agoYou don't honour your choice of nickname very well. In the case of AirBnB, you want to restrict a system that reduces inefficiencies in the allocation of living space on the base of nebulous fears, giving authority to prosecute victimless crimes to the government? I disagree.
- bcgraham 13y agoHe just got done explaining that there are, in fact, victims. There are negative externalities that are getting pushed onto neighbors.
- mikeash 13y agoThe only negative externality he mentions is some vague handwaving about "neighborly behavior". With no evidence to back it up, for all we know, the transients make better neighbors than long-term residents.
- benblodgett 13y agoSpoken like someone who has never lived in NYC. We live in such proximity to our neighbors that their behavior has a larger impact than in most places. I had problems with an airbnber just two weeks ago when they had 50+ people partying in the loft above mine. Friends have reported similar experiences.
- jgalt212 13y agoIt was purposely vague to avoid an example/counter-example flame war. It's better to think of this in the aggregate. As a full time resident would you rather live in a building of full time residents who keep similar schedules and are invested in keeping the building nice, or would you rather live in a building of transients who have no vested interest in the long-term upkeep of your building. Another way to look at it: Do you take better care of the car that you own, or the car that you rent?
- leviathant 13y ago
- smalter 13y agoVenkat Rao has an interesting piece on this topic which he calls The Locust Economy: http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2013/04/03/the-locust-economy/ http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2013/04/03/the-locust-economy/ The question he asks is: We're feeding on this excess supply until it's all gone--then what? For instance, regarding your point (2), to live in NYC will it become necessary for everyone to become a part-time landlord to make rent as rents escalate?
- tixocloud 13y agoI haven't read the article but I thought you pointed out something really interesting about everyone needing to become a part-time landlord to make rent as rents escalate. Would it be possible that as people are becoming part-time landlords, rents will escalate anyway as a result of additional income disposal and cash inflows to the city?
- feralmoan 13y agoAirBnB saved my bacon trying to find a permanent place to stay in NYC. It was literally the leg-up I needed to deal with the brokerage mafia in NY. For example, 3 months of temporary housing until finding a permanent abode through the 'usual channels' still incurs the entire years brokerage fee. Absolutely ridiculous. Sure, there's transients, but everyone's needs are different and people need to be cognizant of the overall fluidity of the market and its many moving parts. Thanks AirBnb! :)
- forkandwait 13y agoThis argument, while plausible, seems completely untested. It should lead "AirBnB scares me..." not "AirBnB is definitely [anything -- good, bad, indifferent]". Until there are data and real experiences, you don't really know.
- darkarmani 13y ago> 2. If AirBnB became a serious economic force in NYC, it would only make my outrageously expensive city more expensive as apartment rents converged upwards towards hotel rates. Just do ridiculous rent control on more apartments. Doesn't everyone squat in rent-controlled apartments anyway? Remove the rent control and you'll see the real price.
- supergirl 13y ago1. so you want to limit the freedom of others to protect your comfort? what if someone moves in for the long term, but he's not "exhibiting neighbourly behavior"? is that acceptable to you? 2. you don't like a free market?