5 ms·
Store files in your Flickr account
- DigitalSea 14y agoIt was only a matter of time before someone did this, wasn't expecting something so fast though. I bet Yahoo! aren't anticipating people using that whole 1TB, but with something like this I could easily fill 1TB in music/videos very quickly. Now if someone takes it one step further and creates a Site44 for Flickr: http://www.site44.com/ http://www.site44.com/ — we'll truly have it all.
- belorn 14y agoIsn't videos is perfectly allowed so long its self-produced?
- kmfrk 14y agoAs someone stated in the other HN thread, this is a bit of a dick move. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5741905 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5741905
- logn 14y agoI read the flickr TOS. I don't think this violates it. How is this a dick move? Get over yourself. They're valuing the company at $1.1 Billion. If you can actually drain any significant amount of their resources then sure it's a dick move, but crazy impressive. Besides, you really think Yahoo! would be so upset that hackers are using their site for a public CDN? Sure they might make a big fuss, but they probably would think it's cool too. Afterall, flickr started as an online game. Who's to say they won't pivot again? Further, as much as anyone wants to complain about the downfall of hacker news quality, this has made me more cynical than anyone's nit or snark or trolling.
- sjs382 14y ago>They're valuing the company at $1.1 Billion. Flickr != Tumblr
- macspoofing 14y ago>I read the flickr TOS. I don't think this violates it Doesn't mean your account won't get suspended. I'm sure the TOS has a "we can do whatever we want to your account" clause somewhere in there.
- greggman 14y agoYou can't use Flickr as a public CDN AFAIK. Their terms require if you use flickr to host an image displayed in another page that page must provide a link to the photo's page on flickr. Flickr also only allows photos, illustrations and screenshots. (and video). Nothing else. These terms are not spelled out in the ToS but in their community guidelines and faq There are plenty of examples of people having their accounts closed for not following these rules.
- ricardobeat 14y agoI must have missed that thread. It's almost the same implementation. It's just a fun POC. It's not reliable, efficient or fast enough to be something you'd use daily. I imagine it would be quite easy to filter out (and revoke API keys) if something like this started becoming popular.
- shocks 14y agoThe act of abusing this script to store large files at Yahoo's expense is a dick move, but writing this script is not a dick move.
- sillysaurus 14y agoThe act of abusing this script to store large files at Yahoo's expense is a dick move Why?
- VikingCoder 14y ago...is it mutually beneficial, if you store legitimate images? Yes. ...does it benefit Yahoo in any way, if you exploit a currently open loophole to store data that is not an image? No.
- msellout 14y agoHow are you defining "a dick move"?
- shocks 14y agoOh please. You know exactly why.
- sillysaurus 14y agoActually, I don't, otherwise I wouldn't have asked. Why are you so mean?
- shocks 14y agoHeh, sorry. Perhaps I should have used a ':P' emoticon. I didn't intend on being mean. It's a dick move because it takes advantage of their systems to do things they clearly don't want you doing.
- macspoofing 14y agoIt isn't a dick move. It doesn't hurt Yahoo, and most likely will hurt the 'abuser' since Yahoo will just suspend such accounts whenever they feel like it, and the stored data will just be gone.
- VikingCoder 14y agoIf you say you'll store images, and I make you store things that are not images - taking up hard drive space you didn't intend to let me use - that hurts you financially. Any other reading of the situation is based on fantasy.
- macspoofing 14y agoThe "financial hurt" is mitigated by the fact that they can just ban your account and your access to your terabyte of stored data and possibly other yahoo services, anytime they want. >Any other reading of the situation is based on fantasy. Not necessarily. It is possible that Yahoo engineers may actually be amused and supportive of the way their service was remixed.
- VikingCoder 14y agoHow is that "mitigated"? You're saying there's a natural defense to this first attack, so therefore the attack doesn't hurt. Except it costs engineering time to fight back against this attack. Then, someone starts putting the file into the RGB channels. Then, it costs engineering time to fight back. Then, someone starts putting the file into the low-order bits... which happens to make the file compress terribly, compared to a normal PNG. Then, it costs engineering time to fight back.
- macspoofing 14y agoTalk about cynicism. As I wrote, it is possible that Yahoo could be amused and supportive of this project, no? Corps react in various ways, and Yahoo could go either way. So unless you're representing Yahoo, why go about bitching at people for a clever remix that technically doesn't violate the TOS and doesn't exploit any vulnerabilities, when Yahoo hasn't even made an official statement. Second ... you're characterizing it as an "attack"... really? The people who'll try to use it would be people who just want some cheap cloud-storage. And as I said before, they should use at their own risk, else they may wake-up one day and find their account is banned, and the terabyte of data they uploaded (which takes a non-trivial amount of time) will be gone, along with their yahoo mail and anything else yahoo was hosting for them. Seriously, why the stick up your ass?
- Tloewald 14y agoWhat I would like is a program for uploading RAW files to Flickr, but clearly Flickr is opposed to this.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ma2rten 14y agoThis starts to get my imagination going. What if you would use all kinds of websites, which allow user-submitted data, and encrypt and distribute the content. You could create an underground internet hosted unknowingly by other people. You could even encode your data so it looks like real image or natural language data.
- Amadou 14y agoI've been thinking about such a thing for a while now. Imagine a tool that uses DHT (distributed hash tables) for indexing and search plus a set of plugins that speak the protocol for each individual datastor be it dropbox, regular http, flickr, etc. It could include redundancy and maybe even bittorrent as one of the datastors.
- pfortuny 14y agoWell, yes. The fact is you would be at the mercy of minor changes in that data which would make your 'data' worthless. As simple as, for example: 'Next month we are going to transform all our utf-8 fields into utf-32 and we are going to add some padding to your data, for analytics'. You would have to cope with that. Which, honestly, would be a lot of a mess. Distributed mess, also. Something like the proverbial fan & sh*t thing.
- mike-cardwell 14y agoNot really. As long as you build in redundancy. Ie, automatically distribute multiple copies of the same files or blocks over multiple different sites. Yes, all of the sites could make breaking changes at the same time, but then all of the disks in your raid array could die at the same time too... Hence backups.
- jacquesm 14y agoDog-slow-array-of-free-websites. Definitely needs a sexier acronym.
- bambambazooka 14y agoThis could be done with git annex http://git-annex.branchable.com/ http://git-annex.branchable.com/
- darxius 14y agoI knew something like this was going to pop up. Now we just have to wait and see how long people can get away with it.
- Aardwolf 14y agoIf you're unable to use zTXt, you could store the bytes in the RGBA pixel values. Those are compressed, and you get some interesting images as a bonus :)
- macspoofing 14y agoIt was only a matter of time until someone came up with something like this. Use at your own risk, and make sure you don't have anything you wouldn't mind losing on the Flickr service since Yahoo can just arbitrarily close your account at any time.
- cllns 14y agoI definitely thought this was going to be storing data as the image. I'd be interesting in the (computational) detection for that. Of course, if you just encode/decode it, Yahoo could do the same. If you encrypt the data, they could just check to see how high the entropy is. If it's higher than what's plausible for a real photograph, they'd delete it. (using ent [1]) Else, you could use good ole stenography. In researching this response I came across the term Steganalysis[2]. Pretty interesting! [1] http://www.fourmilab.ch/random http://www.fourmilab.ch/random [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganalysis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganalysis
- vxNsr 14y agoWell that didn't take long. I figured this would happen eventually, obviously yahoo will spend a considerable amount of time trying to detect this and remove it...
- simonwistow 14y agoAlready done 7 years ago :) http://search.cpan.org/dist/Net-FS-Flickr/ http://search.cpan.org/dist/Net-FS-Flickr/ Stores versioned files by encoding them in the lower order bits of PNGs in a Flickr set. Example stored file: http://www.flickr.com/photos/simonwistow/sets/72057594097765821/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/simonwistow/sets/72057594097765...