3 ms·
But those "technicalities" are the law, as it was written. The rules say "if you meet these conditions, then use this algorithm to calculate your tax bill". The
by kstrauser 14y ago
But those "technicalities" are the law, as it was written. The rules say "if you meet these conditions, then use this algorithm to calculate your tax bill". The inevitable result is that every company with a halfway competent accounting department pores over the tax code to find the algorithm that results in the lowest tax bill, then figures out how to meet the necessary requirements to use it.
Please note that in no way do I think this is a good thing to do, or that I'm remotely in favor of the current situation. It sucks and I'm not. But Congress made that game, and they completely lack the moral authority to complain about others playing it.
Put this in coding terms, where each tax code requirement is a conditional branch in a `calculateTax()` function. If you write a function with 50,000 conditionals, you simply can't be surprised that someone figures out a way to call the function with arguments that give the best possible output for them. Even worse, you can't close those loopholes by adding more conditionals. By definition, you're only creating more optimization paths for them to choose from.
- daniel-cussen 14y ago> Even worse, you can't close those loopholes by adding more conditionals. By definition, you're only creating more optimization paths for them to choose from. One thing they try are schemes like alternative minimum taxes: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_minimum_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_minimum_tax Computationally, they solve this problem. But, as far as tax terms, who knows.
- brisance 14y agoWould like to add that the senior management in charge of running the company are expected to perform their fiduciary duties i.e. optimize for minimizing taxes for the benefit of the company.
- colechristensen 14y agoI'm not sure what point you're trying to make. Should Congress not try to fix structural problems in the tax code which allow plenty of corporations avoid tax obligations?
- kstrauser 14y agoYes, and that's only possible by removing many exemptions, deductions, special cases, etc. Congress should absolutely reform the tax code, and it must be by reducing the number of ways it can be worked around.