4 ms·
The sarcasm isn't warranted. This is appropriate. The actual engines on these planes have non-zero failure rates. Every year or so (someone will have to look
by ajross 14y ago
The sarcasm isn't warranted. This is appropriate. The actual engines on these planes have non-zero failure rates. Every year or so (someone will have to look up stats because I'm too lazy) a jet lands with the smoking remains of one under its wings.
Stuff breaks. The goal of safety engineering is as much to reduce the impact of failures as it is to reduce their frequency. Everything is about tradeoffs.
- jerrya 14y agoThe original design, years in the making, was based on batteries that would never catch fire. They have moved from never catch fire, in a period of a few months, to batteries they hope will not catch fire, with features to enable survivability should a battery catch fire. If this new design is appropriate, that earlier design was engineering malpractice. I doubt this design would be the outcome of the same Boeing design engineering effort without the get it to market time constraint. Just like when a web service goes down mysteriously and the engineers desire is to take it down and debug it and the required response is to patch it, and get her flying again. But I wouldn't term that "design" or "engineered".
- ajross 14y ago"Malpractice" seems like a loaded word chosen more for debate impact than suitability. We can certainly agree that the original design was wrong (or "mistaken" if you want to load it on the other side). Isn't that enough?
- jerrya 14y agoI honestly don't know. I am hard put to explain what malpractice might be for a lawyer or doctor that wouldn't be the same for the largest US manufacturer of aircraft and her engineers. This was a huge mistake, and it seemed as though they should've known.
- CaptainZapp 14y agoWhile the failure rate is certainly not zero (Hudson miracle, Qantas A380 engine explosion) jet engines are so extremely reliable that I doubt such statistics can even be found. There are additional safeguards when it comes to a jetliners powerplants. For example: The oil is never exchanged at the same time in all engines on a plane. I fail to see, however, what this has to do with burning batteries on a plane. A fire on a plane in flight is one of the worst imaginable scenarios, while the chances to land a plane without engine power are actually quite good. Unless you're in the middle of an ocean, that is.
- mikeash 14y agoJet engines fail with decent regularity. It's not exactly common, but nor is it too rare to measure. For example, this claims a failure rate of about once per thirty years: http://www.airbus.com/fileadmin/media_gallery/files/safety_library_items/AirbusSafetyLib_-FLT_OPS-SUPP_TECH-SEQ07.pdf http://www.airbus.com/fileadmin/media_gallery/files/safety_l... Which, based on the number flying regularly, means there's an in-flight failure happening somewhere in the world every few days or so. There is a reason that every airliner of appreciable size has two engines or more. The 787 is rated to fly up to three hours away from the nearest airport. A gliding airliner will be lucky to make a tenth of that distance.
- icegreentea 14y agoThis Airbus documents suggests a failure rate of of <1 per 100,000 flight hours [1]. (just an FYI, pretty increasing. 40 fold decrease since start of the jet liner era). I think the point he was trying to make is that while Boeing's actions clearly do not reduce the risk dangerous battery fire to zero, Boeing not only does not have to reduce it to zero, but really there should be no expectation that it be reduced to zero, given that we already fly accepting some sort of failure rate on the engine. This stems from the original posters implication that Boeing just used some sort of cheap hack fix so they could stem the deluge of bad PR and start making money again - with the further implication that the actions taken are a cheap hack fix since they clearly do not reduce risk to zero. [1] http://www.airbus.com/fileadmin/media_gallery/files/safety_library_items/AirbusSafetyLib_-FLT_OPS-SUPP_TECH-SEQ07.pdf http://www.airbus.com/fileadmin/media_gallery/files/safety_l...