3 ms·
It's odd to me that we don't study creative thinking more. When it comes to technical details, we've got it covered; you can find hundreds of textbooks on any g
by archagon 13y ago
It's odd to me that we don't study creative thinking more. When it comes to technical details, we've got it covered; you can find hundreds of textbooks on any given field, from the arts to the sciences. But the mysterious step that actually lets you recombine that knowledge into new ideas is usually shrugged off as "hard work" or "inspiration".
On the other hand, I suppose it's a pretty difficult question to answer. If you were to ask a musician how they compose their music, they would probably talk about scales and chord progressions and improvisation. But the true answer involves a whole lifetime of experiences and memories, filtered in a specific way through the musician's brain to create certain musical effects, themselves based on years of training. To even talk about that would require a lot of introspection.
What if we could train ourselves to think like Einstein? What would this do for science? What about Mozart and music?
- tachyonbeam 13y agoThis is true. I got interested in music, wanted to compose electronic music of my own. I went on to read several books about music theory and composition. I then realized that composing good music is extremely difficult, and has very little to do with the study of music theory. I believe most musicians sort of have a recipe book of tricks and patterns they discovered, which they combine with some improvisation. These "known recipes" take a long time, lots of practice and experimentation to acquire, and they are what makes an artist's musical style, or flavor, so to speak. No amount of reading about music theory will give you this. Interestingly, programming might be similar in many ways. People complain when an artist releases an album, and there's only 2 good tunes, the rest are just "filler". People might assume the artist was just lazy or something, couldn't be bothered to put enough work into the album. I think the reason that's so common is that well, it's just that hard to create good music: 2 songs is all the really good music they managed to create in that time. Also makes you appreciate artists who can produce an album full of good tunes, these people are exceptionally gifted.
- samatman 13y agocreative thinking is like all creativity: improvisational shift-reduce combinations on memorized patterns. You combine this analytical intelligence with non-trivial amounts of categorical intelligence and a lot of hard work, you get creative thought in a technical field. It's rare because categorical and analytical intelligence are practically independent variables and you need a lot of both, otherwise you're an accountant or a musician/poet.
- c0riander 13y agoThere is some research starting to be done on this, e.g. this study on what goes on in improv jazz musicians' brains when they are playing: http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0001679 http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjourna...
- rickhanlonii 13y ago>What if we could train ourselves to think like Einstein? The answer is that we can, and the method is right in front of us: Mathematics. Though many people have either forgot or never understood it, there's a good reason that math is one of the core subjects we learn. It teaches us to think. Understanding and doing real, advanced, mathematics forces you to think creatively and critically, not to mention reasoning logically. Relentless practice and study of Math creates that creative and critical filter in your brain. In short, it forces you to think. That's why every time I hear of a teacher teaching math as rote memorization of steps or symbol manipulation with no regard to the structure and meaning of a question or concept, I get physically upset. They're completely taking the thinking out of it. It's like taking a reading class, but only making it a requirement to move your eyes over the words. It really works me up that the not-so-secret to healthy creative and critical thought is being locked away in the marginalization of students who can't or won't do pointless tasks like factoring polynomials for the sake of knowing the steps. As if that weren't enough, those students then turn into parents and teachers who push on to the next generation the broken concept of math that was fed to them. What were we talking about again? Oh yeah, math is awesome.