13 ms·
My one talk with Marissa Mayer
- davewiner 14y agoI wrote a blog post based on my experiences with the trolls here yesterday. http://threads2.scripting.com/2013/may/hackerNewsIsDepressing http://threads2.scripting.com/2013/may/hackerNewsIsDepressin... I hope you upvote this enough so it's visible alongside the abusive stuff the trolls posted. Thanks.
- veidr 14y ago> I hope you upvote this enough so it's visible That's unlikely to happen, because there's nothing interesting or valuable in your follow-up post (unlike the original post, which had a salient and timely point that was buttressed by a somewhat interesting anecdote based on personal experience). It's basically just, "HN readers are 'trolls' and 'assholes' and 'they' are Wrong About Dave Winer." Well, buddy, welcome to the internet. HN may be one of the better internet discussion forums, but it is still an internet discussion forum. Frankly, I'm surprised that the grandfather of blogging can get this upset by the comments of strangers on the interweb tubes. If HN comments really make you "depressed", then I think you should take a step back and think about why you care so much. (Especially since other HN commenters pushed back against basically all of the really moronic "hurhurhur, Dave WHINE-er, get it" comments, and the bulk of the thread was either supporting your post or at least pointing out that the attacks on it were mostly stupid. But even if that hadn't happened, and every single HN user ridiculed your post: so what?) Finally, regarding the idea that HN should let you block your posts from being linked here: sorry man, other websites aren't about you. They're about the people who create and use them. And if your (original) post was of interest to the HN readership -- which I'm pretty sure it was, since it made the front page -- then who are you to say who gets to link to it? People can link to -- and say -- whatever they want. That's how this whole "web" fad works.
- Tomis02 14y ago> It's basically just, "HN readers are 'trolls' and 'assholes' and 'they' are Wrong About Dave Winer." Well to be fair it is mostly true, and it doesn't hurt to repeat it every once in a while.
- davewiner 14y agoThey are rebuttals to nasty stuff people in this thread said that were upvoted to the top of the list. I think response to accusations should be given equal attention, esp when one of the criticisms was that "I don't respond to critics."
- jagtesh 14y agoNow I maybe speaking out of my ass here, having never been in David's position. Shouldn't his future designation have been part of the contract? As an example, admittedly unrelated to this, when J.K.Rowling agreed for Harry Potter movie to be made, she negotiated and put a condition in the contract for the entire cast to be British or Irish.
- killjoymcfly 14y ago
- daniel-cussen 14y ago"All I remember of it was there came a point in the conversation when Mayer had had enough. She just got up and left." That's some selective memory Dave Winer has. I wonder what he said? Should I expect to find out on a blog post from Marissa Mayer on the subject, on her brand new Tumbler?
- voidlogic 14y ago>>He watched a couple of slides and thanked me for the input. I asked What about my chief architect role? He told me that was something they told me to get me to do the deal. I'm probably naive, but couldn't something like this be put into the acquisition contract, maybe even with monetary penalties if certain objective criteria (like reporting employee count or C-level meeting attendance) are not met? I realize that is not by any means bullet proof, but couldn't this kind of treatment at least be made harder?
- tantalor 14y agoThis kills the deal.
- voidlogic 14y agoReally? I would think at the table you could say, 1. here is my concern, 2. here are examples of it happening to people in the past, 3. here is one idea I have have for addressing my concern, please share your thoughts... If a reasonable concern kills a deal just by discussing it, the deal must be very fragile. Even if terms are not added to the deal, I think bringing up the issue could be beneficial.
- smacktoward 14y agoYou can propose anything you want, but if the other party in the negotiation is the one sitting with the big bag of money, the easiest answer is always "no." Because that puts the burden on you to decide if you really care about your proposal enough to leave the room without the big bag of money if you can't have it. A big bag of money is an incredibly magnetic thing. Once most people walk into the room and actually see one, it becomes really really hard to walk out of the room without it. So what seemed like a reasonable concern before you walked in starts looking more like something you can live without, if the alternative is living without the bag.
- wpietri 14y agoI think that's a very reasonable thing to bring up. But I wouldn't expect a lot. The actual deal is an understanding between people. The contract is the bundle of sticks you use to beat one another if the deal falls apart. Any contract term that tries to force a good relationship is basically nonsensical. If you're trying to enforce a contract, you're already in the situation where the relationship has gone bad.
- mratzloff 14y agoThe link is down for me. Here is the Google cached version: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:threads2.scripting.com/2013/may/myOneTalkWithMarissaMayer http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:threads...
- tonfa 14y ago> There was concern in the wider blogging community that Google might use its power in search to give people an incentive to use Blogger over other publishing platforms. They said this would never happen. > But a few weeks after the deal they broke the promise. They added a BlogThis! button to Google Toolbar. I don't really see how adding something to the toolbar would be using your "power in search".
- smacktoward 14y agoThe Google Toolbar was once a very widely used piece of software. The vast majority of those who used it did so to add a Google search box into their browser chrome. So integrating unrelated services into the toolbar was a way to use the popularity of their search product to boost the visibility of other, unrelated products.
- davewiner 14y agoThe promise wasn't specific to search.
- Uchikoma 14y ago"Back then Google cared a little about what I thought" A typical Dave.
- joyeuse6701 14y agoI like how one incident from 10 years ago, however topically relevant is used to sway opinion on someone. Where's the forgiveness, people can change! Anyway, even if tumblr was altered, the internet can always make another community as good if not better.
- davewiner 14y agoI didn't say that it's not possible that Yahoo means everything they said. But I don't think they begin to understand what they're promising. That doesn't bode well for them keeping the promises.
- smacktoward 14y agoPeople can definitely change. They just don't, usually.
- corresation 14y agoDave would be well served to knock the chip off his own shoulder, and it has been disheartening to see his bitterness increase. He does a disservice to other "older" developers and technology buffs, as not all of us want to regale you with tales of the old days, nor demand penance for having done something once.
- davewiner 14y agoBlah blah blah.
- radio4fan 14y agoI found it interesting and not at all bitter. The point was "Once they've bought it, promises don't matter", and there were two interesting stories that illustrate this point. /shrugs We all know yahoo are going to fuck up tumblr, and the promises that they've made won't matter.
- Terretta 14y ago> He does a disservice to other "older" developers and technology buffs, as not all of us want to regale you with tales of the old days... Once upon a time, we enjoyed exchanging stories as a way of sharing and building on the wisdom learned from hard knocks, bootstrapping one another. Pretty sure that's how civilization progresses.
- corresation 14y agoIt's also how civilization stagnates. Stories have value, but not to diminish someone else's achievement or to argue against progress.
- danilocampos 14y agoSo Dave Winer gets sanctimonious about a tiny change to a small side-product of Google's and he extrapolates many conclusions based on Mayer's entirely natural eye rolling. As a meta comment, Winer is a unfortunate last name for this gentleman given the overall tone and timbre of what he has to say. Google giving preferential treatment to Blogger content, by giving special SERP positioning, distinctive formatting, or other embellishment, would have been worth making a fuss about. That would have been a big deal. But this is a little button on a toolbar that many Google users never even used. And it's only for creating content, which is a side-show to Google's main purpose, which is finding content. This is how you squander your capital.
- treenyc 14y agoI am glad David pointed this out. It may seem like a small thing, however what he brought up can be seen as an Out-of-integrity behavior as a positive phenomenal. And I am not talking about morality, good vs. bad. Think for a moment about the Law of Gravity: there is no such thing as ‘good’ or ‘bad’ gravity; As economist Michael Jensen pointed out Integrity as “what it takes for a person to be whole and complete....And an individual is whole and complete when their word is whole and complete, and their word is whole and complete when they honour their word." And this law seems work just gravity for all human-beings (not just Google executive). Out-of-integrity behavior has been pervasive, both on an organizational and an individual basis, and that attributed to the unworkabilities in the world. More about Integrity a positive phenomenal can be read here: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1511274 http://ssrn.com/abstract=1511274
- jerrya 14y agoMaking fun of some guy's name? Pretending to not understand the importance of blogthis! in a world where Yahoo just bought Tumblr, or where the subscribe to rss buttons mostly work to allow the user to choose an rss feed reader of their own choice, or where Microsoft was told to make sure users could pick their favorite email apps, firewall apps, etc.? This danilo is how you squander your capital.
- davewiner 14y agoNever heard that one before about my last name. Genius. ;-)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- vishaldpatel 14y agoCome on, folks, time to relax with the name-calling: he was using his experience to convey a wider point: when you sell something, it belongs to the buyer. They can do what they want with it. Expecting some part is foolish - we can, at best, offer our services to help them make their newly acquired purchase even better.
- davewiner 14y agoThank you.
- k-mcgrady 14y agoWhy should Google add other blog services to the blog this button? They agreed not to give blogger preference in search. Google Toolbar was a separate product and they had no obligation to include competitors blog services in a feature of it.
- ChuckMcM 14y ago"He [Gordon Eubanks] left the room. What was I going to do? What could I do? Nothing, that's what. :-)" I like Dave and I respect what he has done for blogging and the community, I also understand his angst here. However I think it is misplaced. There are two things people do in commerce, one is to innovate/invent and the other is to capture (or extract if you are being cynical) value from that innovation. Tumblr, like GeoCities before it, have done well on the innovate/invent part and failed at the capture value part. Once at a meeting of west coast venture capital types I heard someone call a business 'making mud pies'. In developing that concept further, they described a business where the founders were having a great time building their technical vision and yet had failed to convince anyone outside of their small circle of friends that it was worth paying money for. Like kids making mud pies or finger painting, the act of creation was the only reward they were getting. In that sort of situation it's a matter of time before the entity ceases to be. By all reports Tumblr (like GeoCities before it) was running out of money. If that is true, then Yahoo! has simply saved them from dissolution and retained the traffic (and more importantly the habits of visiting) that folks on the net have built up. They think they extract value out of it, and perhaps they can do so with only a smaller increase in their total expenses than Tumblr existing burn rate. That is a bet they make with themselves. But let's return to Dave's angst for a minute. Dave saw the deal with Symantec as Symantec getting this great thing they had produced with him to lead it strategically, from Symantec's perspective apparently they saw other things in the deal. Aligning thoughts and visions requires the the guy (or gal) being acquired do three things; 1) They need to understand the real reason they were acquired (was it for people, tech, traffic, brand?) 2) They need to figure out what they want to achieve out of the joined entity (recognizing it may not be possible based on #1) 3) They have to communicate a plan and build a following to insure that what they are trying to do is understood by the organization rather than just one or two people. Its the strange thing that leaders are often as much controlled by their organizations as they are in control of them. There are few benevolent (or even malevolent) dictatorships, usually there is a group concensus about what is being done. And without that, not a whole lot gets done. Marissa has stated she doesn't want to 'screw up' this deal. And I am pretty sure she is sincere in that, but it is less up to her than she might like.
- wpietri 14y ago
- Isamu 14y agoI thought there were some very good tidbits in this post. I.e. if you are doing a deal, don't be surprised if only the immediate terms are honored. Don't bank on future promises. I like the example of Dave getting the "Architect" title as a result of a deal - but afterwards the meaning of the title was ignored. Nice bait and switch! Something to look out for in a deal, I would have fallen for that. Another example I hear about is: museum acquires a bequest of an art collection, but with some stipulation about how it is to be treated, kept intact, etc. Once the deal is done, the museum does what it likes. Now the museum may be squandering its capital in its reputation among potential patrons, but that's a calculation they make.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> I.e. if you are doing a deal, don't be surprised if only the immediate terms are honored. Don't bank on future promises. Dave himself admits that he felt like he had a disincentive to enforce the future promises due to what he had already received as a result of the more immediate terms -- a contract is, ultimately, not just a set of promises, but a set of promises that the parties feel need to be backed by the threat of legal action to ensure compliance. If, for any of those promises, you aren't going to be willing to act on that threat when they are violated, and the other party knows the incentive structure that makes you unwilling to act on the threat, well, then the threat is gone, and if you didn't need the threat to enforce the promises, you wouldn't have needed a contract in the first place. That doesn't really mean there is a difference between short-term and longer-term promises, it means that there is a difference between promises backed by the credible threat of legal action and promises not backed by the credible threat of legal action, which is rather the entire reason contracts exist in the first place.
- brackin 14y agoYou always have a boss. Before David Karp was responsible to his investors, now he's responsible to Mayer and the Yahoo shareholders. It's not that different other than the fact that Yahoo (at least for now) has enough money to let them live on.
- Zigurd 14y agoThis is an odd and unintentionally revealing rant. Does anyone remember the "Blog this!" button? Any material effect on anything? And who was embarrassed about what?
- conductr 14y ago>> On the acquisition, they said they wouldn't do anything to tilt the table in favor of Blogger. I believe they meant that Blogger blogs would not be given an advantage in the SE algo. Eg. given top search results just because of the blogging platform. I think you took it wrong. Why would they buy Blogger and promise to never promote it? Doesn't make sense.
- ryanglasgow 14y ago"I negotiated for myself a role as the "Chief architect of Symantec's Mac strategy." If you have to negotiate a made-up role for yourself during the acquisition of your own company, it's clear the company sees no value in your input and only wants your product and customers. I doubt David Karp had to negotiate a role for himself because his expertise, just as much as his company, was sought after.
- mindcrime 14y agoI think Dave's final point is spot on. That's why, IF we ever get to the point where Fogbeam becomes an acquisition target, and IF we sell, my mindset is going to be very much "take it, it's yours, do what you want with it." I wouldn't even ask for a fancy title or any kind of executive position in the combined company. I'd just want the shortest possible "golden handcuff" period, and a place to sit and surf Hacker News while waiting for the period to end. The flip-side is, of course, that this is why it would be hard to decide to sell. sigh
- kjackson2012 14y agoCongrats, you singlehandedly killed any desire for anyone to ever want to acquire your business. Who would possibly want to buy a business where the founder is ready to abandon ship as quickly as possible?
- mindcrime 14y agoPretty much every big company who acquires a smaller company, slaps a pair of golden handcuffs on the founders, and then proceeds to strip them of any power or responsibility. And that seems to be a fairly prevalent theme, especially with companies like Yahoo.
- prawn 14y agoIf they thought the founder would just get in the way otherwise, and they had grander plans for an established user/code-base?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gregors 14y agoCompanies buy other companies to make money. That's it. Once you sell a company, house, car whatever that's it. You've sold it. The new owner can do whatever they want. People don't really seem to get that.
- neurotech1 14y agoThe problem with the OP is that he is combining two separate deals into one point in the story. It sounded like his company was acquired by Symantec, not Yahoo, not Google, and ultimately didn't get all he was promised from Symantec title wise. The Google interaction with Marissa Mayer was about a product integration partnership. That's completely different than an acquisition type discussion. I've only met Marissa Mayer once at a conference, and was impressed by her technical knowledge of Google services. I'd also believe she might come off a little aloof at times, as she was a high-level executive at Google and Now CEO at Yahoo. The fact is that Tumblr has limited cashflow to fund growth, and Yahoo has the cash.
- cmalpeli 14y agoI think Dave has done a good job of retelling a relevant and timely story from his perspective. It's a cautionary tale to any potentially naive sellers of their businesses out there. I don't see this as complaining, but simply providing an additional lens on a oft-repeated tale of big co acquiring hot tech of the moment....there's wisdom in these words!
- bgilroy26 14y agoI agree about the relevance of this story, and I'm a big fan of Dave's from his generosity to the Perl community, but his point would have been better served if he had been less personal and if he had taken his analysis a step further. I think any time you characterize somebody in a negative light, it's best to acknowledge the risk that you didn't have the whole story. In addition the fact that lawyers and the law aren't mentioned is a big gap in the point Dave makes. If you're working with strangers in America on something that is worth more than ten thousand dollars to you,the extent to which you can get a llawyer involved is the extent to which you can safeguard your interests. Now, at risk in the tumblr acquisition seems to be tumblr's handle on cool. The situation of how tough it is for suits to draw up an agreement that protects "cool" set against how important such a challenge is during an acquisition might have made for a more interesting discussion. As it stands, the takeaway for this story is basically "don't forget to bring a lawyer!"
- donpark 14y agoLesson here is even smart folks can't leave the messenger out of the message which is: Promises made during acquisition are meaningless. If you find value in the message, keep it. If not, ignore it. There is absolutely no sane reason to bite the messenger.
- mcguire 14y ago"All this is to say that the promises execs make on acquisitions are meaningless." This is news? [Upon reading the comments, apparently it is.]
- marcamillion 14y agoI think taking 1 data point of 1 experience from Mayer when she was an exec at Google to extrapolate it over her entire strategy at Yahoo! is an over-reach. I can't speak to why the meeting played out the way it did....but I could see myself doing the same thing. Google just spent $80M (or w/e the purchase price was) on an acquisition. They didn't block other blogs (or platforms) from the SERP results or anything like that. They just used their reach to improve the value of the asset they just acquired. To ask them to do otherwise is really selfish, imho. Then to take that one action and extrapolate it over her entire decision-making apparatus at a new company and entirely different type of acquisition.....
- ryanac 14y ago"All this is to say that the promises execs make on acquisitions are meaningless." Well yeah, all promises are meaningless. Were any of these promises in writing as part of the acquisition? I mean are they legally bound to comply? If not, why would you expect to have any control over operations and decisions, regardless of your title, after being acquired? It's not your company anymore... Also there's no detailed information about the meeting itself to show us how you came to that conclusion however true it is. I'm guessing they wouldn't listen to your advice, but again why would you expect them to?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- greggman 14y agoMy impression is there's often a lot of mis-communication. It could easily be that Google was 100% sincere. When they said they wouldn't give preferential treatment to Blogger they might have only been thinking about search results and nothing else. So in their mind they didn't break any agreement. Conversely the other side might have thought "If Google runs a TV ad for Blogger they have to run TV ads for all other competing blogging systems and give them equal time." Neither side is wrong, they just failed to convey what they were actually thinking when saying "no preferential treatment". I've been in a similar situation where I has a partner in a small game dev company. We got a contract from a publisher to implement a game they had mostly designed already. When signing the deal we were told we could have input into the design. What the publisher meant was "We'll consider your comments and tweak a few things if we agree with them." What some of my partners heard was "The design can be 100% thrown away and re-created from scratch by us". Needless to say there was lots of frustration on both sides.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]