3 ms·
There is however a duty not to lie to HMRC about where taxable activities are taking place. If Google has many employees in the UK booking sales, generating rev
by grey-area 14y ago
There is however a duty not to lie to HMRC about where taxable activities are taking place. If Google has many employees in the UK booking sales, generating revenue paid into a UK bank account, but classified as going through Ireland purely as a tax dodge, as the whistleblower alleges, that's illegal evasion, not avoidance. It's morally wrong, but it's also illegal, and the complexity and long-term planning in this scheme shows that Google the corporation is not as innocent and naive about taxes as they'd like to appear. There's an interesting post hellbanned on this discussion from emmelie pointing out just how complicated the schemes are - does Google still use Google Ireland Holdings, Bermuda?
For governments like the UK or US, this has become an important issue, as if they don't tackle this now, revenue from corporations and rich individuals (who often structure their accounts to receive revenue through corporations) will eventually dry up completely as everyone could choose the lowest tax jurisdiction and simply pretend to conduct all business there with loss-making subsidiaries in every other market. This is not limited to Google as all major corporations have started doing this (even the leading left-wing newspaper, the Guardian), and HMRC has just started clamping down on it.
A world where corporations avoid tax completely is not a world I want to live in, and it's not one Google (if they truly believe their mantra 'Don't be evil') should aspire to either. They should simply shut down schemes to move their revenue to other countries solely for the benefits of tax evasion and instead book revenue in the country it is generated in.