3 ms·
Children can't consent. So the state has to protect them. Or, ya know, their parents.
by mindcrime 14y ago
Children can't consent. So the state has to protect them.
Or, ya know, their parents.
- doctorpangloss 14y agoOf course! I'm sure 99.9% of parents, if properly educated, would agree that an overweight or obese child is a bad thing. They might not know what to do about it, and TV ads might turn out to be more powerful than parent's routine meal planning. It might turn out that asking them to turn off the TV is impractical. Maybe telling them what to feed their kids is even worse. In terms of practical means to reduce obesity, most parents would not oppose limiting TV advertising to children. Besides, the state is parents. No big deal.
- harryh 14y agoNot Or. Also. We don't have to choose between the two.
- vidarh 14y agoA lot of the time, the measures the state needs to take to protect children includes protecting them from actions of parents that might very well be well-meaning, but just as clueless and easily manipulated by advertising as their children, but all to often even don't care. While I'm for reducing the power of the state, protection of children is not something society can abdicate from without severe negative effects.
- mindcrime 14y agoI will admit that this is a tricky area. Children are people and people certainly can choose to come to the aid of someone else who is being abused or harmed. But dealing with children is somewhat special, since it is generally considered the parent's responsibility and prerogative to decide how to raise their children. Sadly I don't think there is any way to come to any real, objective answer on this issue. It is one, IMO, that will cause conflict as long as there are people.