3 ms·
Define "advertising to children". Does that mean that TV shows targeted to children can't have advertising? Goodbye kids TV (not all of it is bad). Venue aside
by andrewflnr 14y ago
Define "advertising to children".
Does that mean that TV shows targeted to children can't have advertising? Goodbye kids TV (not all of it is bad). Venue aside, what are the signs of being targeted to children? Show too many kids in the frame, the wrong color scheme, the wrong narration style or fonts? How close can you get?
We talked about "airtightness" in the taxation thread, but I'm realizing there's another issue. If the law isn't carefully defined, it could be possible to interpret nearly any advertising as being targeted, in part at least, to children. This is the kind of thing that will slide toward more restriction under the pressure of various kinds of activists, once we get the idea that we can ban advertising based on its audience.
- satori99 14y agoYou raise good points, but I still think there are legitimate concerns. http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/features/fastfood-logos-are-branded-on-young-brains-study/article3932055.ece http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/features/fastfood-logos-...
- andrewflnr 14y agoThe conclusions of that article that are nonsensical, at least those that weren't already established. In particular, the evidence cited doesn't support drawing the causality arrow in that direction. Why on earth would a logo for a car company or something stimulate the same areas as one for food? That's not how people work, and it's not specific to children.
- alanfalcon 14y agoThe (live) children's TV my daughter watches is on PBS. The extent of the advertising she is exposed to while watching it is the idea that giving money to PBS allows them to continue to show the TV programs. The other children's TV she watches is on Netflix, with no advertising. While some of those shows exist because of advertising during their first run, if that option weren't present then something would fill the void. Anyway, "advertising to children" is already specifically defined and regulated in many countries. The question is simply how far to take those regulations under existing definitions.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoDoes that mean that TV shows targeted to children can't have advertising? Goodbye kids TV (not all of it is bad). Plenty of kids' TV is decent stuff, but almost all of it is still obnoxiously commercial. I remember thinking so as a child (the tendency of plastic toys to break into shitty little useless pieces probably helped make me an anti-capitalist, down the line). So I see very little wrong with just outright banning advertising to children and shifting the creative effort over into "whole family" genres that don't just make up a new way to babysit your kids without paying a babysitter.