5 ms·
I frequent typophile.com, which is the online community of font designers, and the topic of online font distribution and "alternative licensing" surfaces every
by huhtenberg 18y ago
I frequent typophile.com, which is the online community of font designers, and the topic of online font distribution and "alternative licensing" surfaces every single month.
My takeaway from these conversations that the designers are (a) technically clueless (b) conservative (c) and, pardon my French, scared sh*tless of losing control over their fonts.
Latter is especially ironic, because they have no control to begin with. So the general sentiments are exactly what is described in that quoted interview - they expect someone to develop a magic bit and a DRM to enforce it and then suddenly things will get much better.
Also just to illustrate the level of conservatism - someone who decides to offer 1 font from a family of 10 for free is viewed as a revolutionary dude with the balls of steel. Everyone enthusiastically cheers for him, but noone follows.
In the end, it is really sad to see them burying their heads in the sand next to the music industry.
- marcusbooster 18y agoThis is absurd. I also frequent typophile and these are not the sentiments or the characteristics I've seen. Technically clueless? The entire disciple is technical by nature. People use and create their own tools as a matter of course, Python being the more popular language because of the RoboFab library. No one has a problem with "losing control" of the work they created, they just want to be compensated for it like a reasonable human being.
- huhtenberg 18y ago> Technically clueless? The entire disciple is technical by nature. People use and create there own tools.. Sure, there are some people who do that, but they are hardly a majority. But that's beside the point. Most importantly - they are conservative as hell and unwilling to experiment with licensing. Here's a very interesting thread on the subject, and do tell me you are not getting the vibe I am describing: http://typophile.com/node/54558 http://typophile.com/node/54558
- thwarted 18y agoNo one has a problem with "losing control" of the work they created, they just want to be compensated for it like a reasonable human being. This would seem to be contradicting itself. If you accept that control will be lost, then how can you accept that you'll be able to control that people will compensate you? And I'd venture to say that if you're unable to recognize that piracy is a social problem that does not have a technical solution, then you may qualify for being technically clueless in the context huhtenberg is talking about. There needs to be "Final Ultimate Solution to the Spam Problem Response" document for DRM implementation attempts.
- tptacek 18y agoYou're way outside the debate here. Commercial typeface vendors are going to get compensated one way or the other. There's no DRM on a JPG from Getty or Corbis, but you'd be made of stupid to steal a commercial stock photo for your promotional material.
- thwarted 18y agoYes, and commercial vendors get compensated one way or another because they use social tools, the law, to enforce their law-provided control over their product. Typeface vendors are welcome to do that too, using the law and not putting their trust in DRM, which is breakable, to enforce their control. However, complaining that people who make their own product freely available, for whatever reason (be it for demo, ideological, political, etc purposes), is taking away compensation from those who don't make their product freely available doesn't help the cause to get people to pay for things, or their equivalents, they can otherwise get for free. Adobe charges high prices for their tools because they can, and people will pay because it is considered there are no better tools, free or otherwise. People pay for stock photos because it's actually easier and often cheaper to do so rather than risk having to deal with being caught not paying. Trying to convince the engineers who control the format to add DRM bits, which is what the OP was responding to, is exactly the wrong way to go about maintaining control and is a losing battle.
- zcrar70 18y ago
- chris11 18y agoYeah I agree with you about the nature of the discipline. I have no idea about its practitioners, but the craft can be very technichal. Metamagical Themas (by Douglas Hofstadter) has several interesting problems concerning font and typography. For example, scale can be a problem. It would be relatively easy to design a good letter in a large font size. It gets more difficult when you are trying to scale that letter down to the tiny font sizes.
- GavinB 18y agoOnline font use is extremely public. Wouldn't it be easy to just license fonts per domain and then crawl to see who's using it without a license? Dynamic web fonts are the most enforceable copyright there is. With a reasonable fee structure this could be a huge new source of revenue for font designers, and a big new tool for web designers.
- JulianMorrison 18y agoRight. "Hide the font" and "use the font" exclude each other, when the name of the font has to be right there in the style-sheet!
- IsaacSchlueter 18y agothe name of the font has to be right there in the style-sheet With @font-face declarations, actually, you can name a font whatever you want, and point it at a file on your server that is named whatever you want.
- wmeredith 18y agoIs there anywhere else online that font designers gather? I'm interested, but I just spent about 30 minutes on Typophile.com and I'm going to need a site that's a little less, erm, Flash-tastic.
- m_eiman 18y agoMaybe http://ilovetypography.com/ http://ilovetypography.com/ ?
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]