4 ms·
I fully understand that, and support the tax raises anyways because if that is the only way to get them, then we can get them that way. The problem is that the
by btilly 14y ago
I fully understand that, and support the tax raises anyways because if that is the only way to get them, then we can get them that way.
The problem is that the state constitution and politics makes it easy to get rid of revenue, but really hard to get it back. For instance consider Arnold Schwarzenegger, one of whose original goals was to drop the vehicle licensing fee from 2% of a car's worth to 0.65%. He got in office when times were good, he reduced that tax. Then times turned bad, and it was impossible to reverse that even though the state really couldn't afford it any more. This is about a $6 billion/year hole in our budget. That's on par with the recent tax increases.
Except that the vehicle licensing fee was part of our budget for decades. It was stable and reliable. Our recent tax increases are temporary. What do we do in the long run?
- thatswrong0 14y ago> The problem is that the state constitution and politics makes it easy to get rid of revenue, but really hard to get it back. As it is quite easy to start spending but not stop. > What do we do in the long run? Cut spending. Deal with the actual issue: pensions. The vehicle licensing fee 'problem' is just a red herring.
- jbooth 14y agoIf pensions are the issue, then the solution is probably a little more detailed than "cut spending". You show me someone with a 2 word fiscal solution and ill Sheila you a fool.
- btilly 14y agoThe bigger issue is that California's tax revenue is hugely cyclic, since it depends on income taxes on people whose incomes depend on the performance of investments. Thus during a boom, California gets lots of money, during a crash, the government is strapped. But yeah, pensions need to be reformed. However even if you did so, the state would still regularly run out of money.
- throwaway420 14y agoYou could find a way to give just about any government billions more in "revenue" (my, what a polite euphemism for theft) and they'll still find ways to spend more money than they take in. The problem isn't finding enough "revenue", it's simply spending within their means.
- the_rosentotter 14y ago> vehicle licensing fee from 2% of a car's worth to 0.65% In Denmark the fee is 180% of the car's worth... (sorry for OT)
- cpeterso 14y agoHow can poor people afford to buy a car? Public transportation isn't available in all places and at all times of day.
- the_rosentotter 14y agoNote that we hardly have poor people (by American standards) because of the welfare state, which is partly funded by these extremely high taxes, but it is difficult for low income people to afford a car (gasoline is heavily taxed too). If they really need it they will buy an old beater and drive it a couple of years until it dies, then repeat (which somewhat nullifies the rationale of car registration fees helping the environment).
- ams6110 14y ago"old beaters" also differ from American standards. I doubt the typical American "beater" car would be considered roadworthy in Denmark.
- bhickey 14y agoIt depends on where you are. Public transit in London, for example, is amazing. The longest wait for a train at my local station (Zone 2) was around 12 minutes off peak. Night buses take over for the tube late at night. They'll take you where you need to go, albeit a little slowly. A yearly pass costs £1216 (Zone 1-2). Good luck getting insurance and petrol for much less than that. There's an argument to be made that public transportation isn't available because poor and middle class people can afford cars.
- dfc 14y agoThe fee for me to license a car I bring to denmark is 1/3rd the figure you cited.[1] Do you know why there is such a disparity? Would you mind explaining the rationale for such a high fee? (I realize its not your personal policy, I am just curious about what the government says about the fee. As an American it sounds strange but I imagine such a low % here in the states is equally as strange to you. Thanks for indulging my curiosity.) [1] https://www.workindenmark.dk/en/Find_information/Information_for_job_seekers/Life_in_Denmark/Transport/Car_in_Denmark https://www.workindenmark.dk/en/Find_information/Information...