4 ms·
Your eyes suck at blue (neat image compression trick)
- ilamont 18y agoThe page is not loading some images, and loads others very slowly, which makes it difficult to see the phenomenon described in the post. Might want to bookmark this and check it out later, after the HN traffic surge has died down.
- thamer 18y agoCached version: http://nfg.2y.net.nyud.net:8090/games/ntsc/visual.shtm http://nfg.2y.net.nyud.net:8090/games/ntsc/visual.shtm
- rfurmani 18y agoThat makes a lot of sense. When we lived in the wild discerning different shades of green would have been crucial. It is also known that women can see more shades of red, probably in order to be able to more effectively gather edible berries. Now blue, who needs it? ;-)
- zain 18y agoBlueberries?
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- a-priori 18y agoBlueberries are native only to North America, so our hominid ancestors would not have encountered them. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blueberry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blueberry
- asmosoinio 18y agoBut bilberry looks quite the same to me -- didn't know the difference until now -- and grows in a lot more places. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bilberry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bilberry Not that this has anything to do with the original topic...
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- Avshalom 18y agoNo, sorry that's just nonsense. We're less sensitive to blue light because there is less blue light. The black body spectrum of the sun peaks at green (which is why plants are green) and tails of into red. Blue light is not only a proportionately small section of the energy output but blue photons have more energy per particle and so there are even fewer photons necessary to make up that section. That said while I've heard the women have better red resolution that doesn't necessarily mean they're more sensitive to the color number one. and number two explanations like "so they could gather berries" tend to come from a desire to see women barefoot and pregnant rather than solid science.
- tesseract 18y ago> The black body spectrum of the sun peaks at green (which is why plants are green) Plants are green because they reflect green light, i.e. they do not absorb it and use it to facilitate photosynthesis. Chlorophylls tend to have absorption peaks in the red and blue, which are (in the grand scheme of the electromagnetic spectrum) near the sun's blackbody peak but do not coincide with it.
- jballanc 18y agoTo prevent overheating and excessive evaporation, of course...
- teuobk 18y agoAlthough the black-body spectrum of the sun does peak at green, that's not why plants are green. Consider this: they appear green to us because they are not absorbing the green light. So, then, why green? For that matter, why not black? Apparently, there's some speculation that early microbes were purple, which meant that they absorbed the green light. Chlorophyll might have appeared only in later microbes, so it would have needed to absorb what was left; namely, red and blue light.
- wlievens 18y agoThis begs the question: why were the microbes purple?
- indiv 18y agoIn more detail: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chroma_subsampling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chroma_subsampling
- lbrandy 18y agoThe inherent assumption on which chroma sub-sampling is founded is that luminance information is far more important than chromanance information. This is backed up by empirical evidence. From there, the effect follows directly from the equation for luminance: Y = 0.2126 R + 0.7152 G + 0.0722 B From here you can see that green is by far the most important color, followed by red, and then finally, way down there, blue.
- ijnuhv 18y agoWow - green, the middle of the visual spectrum matters most. If only they had discovered this years ago there could have been some really good systems for sending color information by just doing intensity-red and intensity-blue. Or Y-U + Y-V = YUV if you prefer.
- davepeck 18y agoInteresting. Until reading this, I never stopped to wonder why OpenGL, for example, has GL_UNSIGNED_SHORT_5_6_5 (5 bits for red and blue; six for green) as opposed to some other allocation of 16 bits.
- jobenjo 18y agoUmm... I feel like there's a huge flaw in this. He's looking at the different _channels_ in this image, but couldn't that mean there's just less blue data in that particular image? I believe that humans may be worse at seeing blue, but this test seems bogus. By looking at the channels, he's actually cutting out different subsections of data, so it's apples to oranges, right? What if there's just much less blue in this particular photo? Or am I mistaken?
- tel 18y agoIt could, but you can verify that our eyes cannot detect loss of blue information even in the parts of the image that are rather blue (her wristwatch, the car in the background, the edge of the windshield, the stripe on the towel). In each of those cases fidelity is more damaged by loss of quality in the other
- mdd 18y agoNo, You're spot on. The author states that this is "an unmodified picture, straight off the digicam". Unfortunately for his test, this means the light passed through a Bayer filter, which uses a pattern of "50% green, 25% red and 25% blue": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayer_filter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayer_filter
- Aron 18y agoI would have started by reducing the bit depth of blue, rather than pixel width.
- Daniel_Newby 18y agoAh, but the blue receptors in your eye are as accurate as the green ones, just less tightly packed. Spatial filtering therefore preserves more-visible color accuracy at the expense of less-visible blue location. Not that that stops all those standards that use reduced bit depth for red and blue.