3 ms·
I want to highlight a statistical quirk that biases the results of this poll: Whenever you have a self-selecting population, approval ratings are measures of t
by nostrademons 14y ago
I want to highlight a statistical quirk that biases the results of this poll:
Whenever you have a self-selecting population, approval ratings are measures of the liquidity of the population, not of how good a job the organization is doing.
If you're a Googler and you hate your job, you don't stay a Googler for very long. There are umpteen zillion companies that would love to hire you, or VCs willing to fund you if you choose to do your own thing. There are a number of such ex-Googlers on Hacker News. Google software is somewhat proprietary, but the core languages, skillsets, and architectures are common to a lot of firms who would just love to pick up accumulated ex-Google knowledge.
If you're a Microsoftie and you hate your job, there's a good chance that your skills are more specialized, or you've "drunk the Kool Aid" and can't imagine a life outside Microsoft. If you think things suck...well, you might not have any other options. Or you might not think you have options, having accumulated so much company-specific knowledge. And so you stay in a job that you hate even though you hate it.
It's the same with customers. The reason Facebook, Comcast, TWC, and Congress have such low approval ratings is because users are pretty much locked-in to those services: even if they hate them, they can't go elsewhere. Meanwhile, the reason Google has such a high approval rating is because it's pretty simple to leave most Google products (and ones that are easier to leave, like Search and Chrome, tend to rate more highly than ones with a large degree of lock-in, like Plus and GMail).
If you want to tease out companies that are actually doing things right, look for ones with both a high approval rating (indicating large liquidity) and a large & growing population (indicating that despite this liquidity, more people want to come in than go out).
- scholia 14y agoOddly enough, a lot of Microsoft staff got hired by Google....