4 ms·
> On a broader level, it's worth considering that something like 40-50% of tobacco sales in the US are made to mentally ill people, who find chemical relief the
by anamax 18y ago
> On a broader level, it's worth considering that something like 40-50% of tobacco sales in the US are made to mentally ill people, who find chemical relief therein, but aren't necessarily better off from doing so.
You say that like it's a bad thing.
Perfection is rarely an option. Instead, people get to choose between what's available to them and "chemical relief" beats their alternatives. It's not like someone is going to solve their mental problems if they'd quit smoking.
- anigbrowl 18y agoWell, I do feel it's a bad thing. Cigarettes are so far down the scale of drug delivery methods that I feel we have an obligation to do better. Surely something similar to an asthma inhaler that delivered a hit of nicotine or similar would not be too expensive to develop, and could provide mental relief without the same physical costs. Obviously, I have a chip on my shoulder about these issues; you're not wrong, I'd just like see a better ange of therapeutic options.
- menloparkbum 18y agoThere's been a nicotine inhaler available in the states since 1998. It requires a prescription and hasn't been very popular.
- anigbrowl 18y agoInteresting. It seems to have got stalled in the gray area between the right to sell cigarettes as a commodity and the argument to have tobacco regulated by the FDA: http://articles.latimes.com/2005/oct/30/business/fi-chrysalis30 http://articles.latimes.com/2005/oct/30/business/fi-chrysali...
- anamax 18y ago> Well, I do feel it's a bad thing. Cigarettes are so far down the scale of drug delivery methods that I feel we have an obligation to do better. Okay. I'll just point out that your failure to satisfy that obligation doesn't obligate them to behave differently. Of course, I don't think that you have an obligation. It doesn't actually matter. Whether or not you have an obligation that you're not satisfying, they don't have an obligation to forgo their best option because you think that it's bad. They're better off smoking than not. I fail to see the virtue in making a bad life worse.