4 ms·
My insight: it's the degree of integration of society. No disenfranchised sections. Besides Iceland, two other countries stand up: Japan an Switzerland. In the
by visarga 14y ago
My insight: it's the degree of integration of society. No disenfranchised sections.
Besides Iceland, two other countries stand up: Japan an Switzerland. In the former, not even police or yakuza bear fire arms, things are solved mainly on reputation. In the latter, every citizen has to know how to operate a firearm, on account of not having an army.
So it's not the availability or lack of thereof of guns. It's the "social tension" (what exists between people) that binds people together. A society of strangers and cvasi-anonymous people leads to higher violence. When people are separated, they don't prevent each other from falling into a life of crime.
A society where whole swaths of people are in poverty believing they have no chance to succeed leads to the worst cases of violence. Even the slight idea that there is a path from poverty to success, even if it is an illusion, keeps the violence down.
But when people are convinced that the system is stacked against them no matter what they do, then they dissociate from the large society, form a new attitude - that they don't need to play by the rules, they don't need to have compassion, because the rich have all the power and resources anyway and they actively block the poor from raising up. That's basically whet the shit hits the fan.
Remember the French arab revolt from a few years back, in Paris? Same thing. Arabs emigrated in France after WWII for work. They remained in France and had children. Now french people don't need them any more, but the kids are born in France, they have no idea of the countries their parents came from. They don't want to leave, but they are not welcome in France either. They are without a place of their own. Thus, feeling of racial discrimination and violent protest.
- snogglethorpe 14y agoRegular Japanese police do carry firearms.
- visarga 14y agoEven the guys who stay at the local booth in the corner of the street?
- snogglethorpe 14y agoYes.
- gaius 14y agoI think you'll find the Swiss do have a standing army. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_Switzerland#Structure http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_Switzerland#Structu... As for the extreme social cohesion of Iceland, that's not without its own set of issues http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/apr/18/iceland-anti-incest-app http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/apr/18/iceland-...
- 13b9f227ecf0 14y agoThe Japanese criminal justice system is brutal by world standards. This usually goes unmentioned when people bring up Japanese crime rates.
- snogglethorpe 14y agoOnce you're in prison I dunno, but the Japanese police in general are pretty low-key and community oriented, and seem to try hard to resolve problems without officially involving "the justice system." They're quite palpably less threatening than American police in my experience. It's not just violent crime (something which might be affected by harsh penalties for such) which is rare in Japan, but petty crime as well. As far as I can figure, it's because of strong societal bonds and low income disparities, and that there's less of the sort of sense of disenfranchisement/alienation which seems so common in e.g. the U.S.
- 13b9f227ecf0 14y ago> Japanese police in general are pretty low-key Ha! There are loads of accounts of the falsely accused getting locked up with zero due process. You can find yourself in an unheated cell and forced to kneel on the floor face against the wall for hours a day under threat of beatings before things are sorted out weeks later. Read about the death penalty in Japan for a taste of how they operate. You get killed in secret and your execution is announced months after the fact. None of this years of appeals stuff.
- snogglethorpe 14y agoThe basic point is that people in Japan aren't scared of the police, and in fact the police are often thought of as being kind of wimpy and ineffective; most people consider them "those guys you ask for directions when you're lost." Their relationship with the general public is hugely different than that of American police. So while the Japanese justice system may have some bad habits, that is not an explanation for very low Japanese crime rates.
- 14y ago
- louhike 14y agoFrench arab revolt? As a french I'm quite shocked to see it named like that. There has been a lot of violence, it's true, but it wasn't closed at all to a revolt. I knew some medias as Fox News exagerated the facts but I was hoping most people would be better informed.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoHmm, adding background information here would be more helpful than expressing surprise at one's choice of words.