19 ms·
Figures: They Speak For Themselves (mildly NSFW)
- kevingadd 14y agoNot exactly 'mildly' by any united states standard... interesting post though.
- jlgreco 14y agoEh. You are probably correct, but were it "high" art (say.. "David"), not some sketches on tumblr, it would certainly be mild. Sussing out what is potentially offensive and how much so can be difficult.
- knowtheory 14y agodepends on the context and the standards. The nakedness in question here is not intended to titillate, but to illustrate (ha) a point. To anyone who's ever taken a drawing class w/ a nude model, this is scandalous in the least. If you're presenting to your board of directors, it might be (presuming that character design is not pertinent to your endeavor).
- enraged_camel 14y agoDude, I work at a fairly liberal software company in SoCal, and if I scrolled down to the bottom-most picture with the hand-drawn fully-naked chick and someone happened to glance at my screen, I would most likely be fired. As a rule of thumb, suggestive/sexy clothing is "mildly NSFW." Full nudity, regardless of context, is "very NSFW." (It may be different in Europe.)
- BrandonM 14y ago> I work at a fairly liberal software company in SoCal, and if I scrolled down to the bottom-most picture with the hand-drawn fully-naked chick and someone happened to glance at my screen, I would most likely be fired. If that would be grounds for firing, even after describing the context of the article, then you decidedly do not work at a fairly liberal software company.
- saalweachter 14y agoDefinitions of 'liberal' differ. It seems perfectly consistent to me to be 'liberal' and have a 'no (non work related) naked pictures at work' policy under the auspices of a zero-tolerance sexual harassment policy. No one needs to look at naked pictures at work, and they could plausibly make someone uncomfortable in a sexual way. Now, you could argue that the modern liberal hippie philosophy is that sex is natural and no one should be offended by it and it is just our Puritanical baggage which makes it otherwise, and maybe I'd agree with you. But you could also argue that in the context of our Puritanical baggage, our slut shaming, our last fifty-plus years of Madmen-esque workplace sexual discrimination, we need a period of overly desexualized workplaces before we can shed our Puritanical baggage.
- Millennium 14y agoThat depends on what makes it grounds for firing. Any sufficiently left-wing policy is indistinguishable from a right-wing policy, and the reverse is also true. Anti-pornography movements present one of the clearest modern illustrations of this phenomenon. The right-winger complains of personal morality, while the left-winger complains about demeaning and objectifying the subjects, but they wind up at basically the same conclusions. Alcohol prohibition showed something very similar around the turn of the century.
- falcolas 14y agoSomething similar - a hand drawn picture of a woman in a fantasy equivalent of a bikini (lots of skin, no nipples, no groin) - has actually gotten me fired from a very large internet company, so... It's basically considered a fireable offense under the sexual harassment policy.
- jessedhillon 14y agoI doubt that such a firing is defensible as a sexual harassment claim. If you are creating a hostile work environment, someone first has to complain about it and you have to be given a warning and instructions on how to remedy the situation. However, of course, you can always be fired for demonstrating questionable judgement.
- thaumasiotes 14y agoI work at a fairly staid software company in NorCal, and that would definitively not be grounds for firing.
- lowboy 14y agoI'd still classify it as mildly NSFW. Cartoons and other depictions are less NSFW than images. Or else the following would also be a fireable offense: (.|.)
- angersock 14y agoBut I don't understand why you need to match periods redundantly in your regex?
- dbaupp 14y agoThat's why it's a fireable offense.
- angersock 14y agoI should be fired too... '.' != '\.'. I'm put in mind of the old Zawinski quote: "Some people, when confronted with a problem, think \"I know, I'll use regular expressions.\" Now they have two problems. "
- innguest 14y agoObviously he meant [.|.], which is redundant on so many levels.
- jonnathanson 14y agoI don't disagree with you that "mildly" is a somewhat generous judgment call here. Most American workplaces wouldn't look kindly at your being caught with this on your screen. That said, I think we're missing the broader point. The broader point is that "NSFW" labels carry an implicit caveat emptor warning. Nobody's forcing you to click open a link, and if you believe that you work in an environment with a low tolerance for anything that could be construed as "NSFW," then don't click on a link marked "NSFW" -- even if it's qualified by "mildly," "moderately," "slightly," "possibly," and so forth. If you see the abbreviation "NSFW," you need to take stock of the risks involved in proceeding, and proceed (or not proceed) accordingly. A corollary: given that one person's definition of NSFW will always differ from another's, it's often best to err on the side of caution. Personally speaking, I'm thankful I work at the sort of company that wouldn't fire me for viewing this material. And I'm grateful because it's genuinely fascinating material, and the nudity is used for illustrative purposes (and also, conveniently, tucked at the bottom). Of course, if I worked at a bigger or more conservative company, there's no way in hell I would have taken a chance on anything with an NSFW label.
- SteveGerencser 14y agoI used to work at a place where part of my job was to find great porn for the boss so he could spend more time doing boss stuff. And I got paid to find, and rate, porn. Win/ win.
- balloot 14y ago1) You clearly don't work at a fairly liberal company. 2) I disagree with the "regardless of context". Let's say someone did see you reading this. You would say "this is the top ranked item on Hacker News. Didn't realize one of the drawings was naked." And that would be that, at least everywhere I've ever worked.
- datalus 14y agoNewsflash: SoCal isn't as liberal as you may think.
- psionides 14y agoWow, are you serious? I knew the US approach to these things is weird but this is shocking. How can you fire someone for briefly looking at something they happened to find on the web? You never know what you can find on the web and not everything is labeled, so you can always find something by accident. There's a big difference between spending hours at work looking through porn and reading one article which happens to have one nude drawing at the bottom. I find it hard to believe that someone leading a big company in the US can not realize that.
- podperson 14y agoDoes anyone know of any case where someone has been fired for looking at a hand drawn non-pornographic depiction of a nude in the western world? Really? I see stories about teachers being fired for working as strippers on the side, or there's a teacher fired for http://www.parentdish.com/2006/10/02/texas-school-teacher-fired-because-child-saw-nude-art-in-museum/exposing http://www.parentdish.com/2006/10/02/texas-school-teacher-fi... a child to nude pictures in an Art museum (Texas -- ) but I think this is fanciful. And note that the teacher concerned was no, technically, fired over the art. Prudishness in the US is pretty ridiculous but the only thing which would be job-threatening here is that you're surfing the web on company time AND the thing you're looking at offends someone.
- falcolas 14y agoYes, me. And the hand drawn character was not nude. Fell under the "sexual harassment" clause, because the co-worker who saw it was female and offended.
- ComputerGuru 14y agoHeck, the author of TFA has it tagged as nsfw himself! I disagree that the drawings were not meant to titillate. The, ahem, anatomic detail they go into was unnecessary to prove his point.
- astrodust 14y agoIt's nothing an art school graduate hasn't seen a million times over.
- misnome 14y ago> The, ahem, anatomic detail they go into I'm curious what exactly you mean here? It's a naked body, it's not posed in a "Pornographic" way, and by definition a naked drawing is a drawing of anatomy, and even then it's not as though anything has been gone into in detail. I'm not sure why the artist would have to deliberately remove elements to 'satisfy' the whims of insanely prude readers? Besides, without the anatomical details, there probably wouldn't be the visual clues to identify the characters as 'Naked', which is necessary for the point in question.
- kevingadd 14y agoI guess this is what I get for trying to be informative by pointing out that the post's content is in fact definitely, most very not-safe-for work: downvotes and ranting from the HN hivemind about how I'm oppressing art with my puritan American worldview, or something. Let's enumerate the things I didn't do here: - Say this post shouldn't be on HN - Say the post is inappropriate for viewing by anyone - Say the post was porn or smut - Say anything is wrong with the post I know tons of people who read HN at work, but screw those people, right?
- gojomo 14y agoIt's your broad claim "by any United States standard" that's likely the cause of the downvotes. Lots of US people here work in places where these two non-pruriently-posed cartoon nudes, used for a valid illustrative purpose, present no 'safety' problem. Please don't make the US work environment seem more prude or homogenous than it actually is. This is not "definitely, most very not-safe-for-work". It depends on where you work. That makes "mildly NSFW" a fair description - it's enough of a warning for those in very sensitive environments, while allowing that in other places it'd be considered harmless.
- kevingadd 14y agoI've never encountered a work environment where viewing those drawings at work would be defensible unless you were actually an artist. Note that I'm not saying that this would be a firable offense, but that someone could easily complain to HR about it and it could be considered creating a hostile work environment if it makes them feel unwelcome. These things matter!
- yason 14y agoConversely, I was wondering what was it that was NSFW at all in the pictures? In a culture where all nakedness is banned and considered an absolute filter might be the explanation. But this is hardly the case even in the USA that is infamous for how inconsistently and arbitrarily such things are labelled as "ok" and "no-no".
- solistice 14y agoFirst sentence of your comment was ok, rest was no-no. First sentence of your comment was no-no, rest was ok.
- BoppreH 14y agoAaron Diaz is amazing. The time travel/transhumanism comic Hob is greatly recommended ( http://dresdencodak.com/2007/02/08/pom/ http://dresdencodak.com/2007/02/08/pom/ ).
- astrodust 14y agoAbsolutely fantastic stuff. The Kurzweil and FM-2030 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FM-2030 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FM-2030) nod in the third strip (http://dresdencodak.com/2007/04/07/rule-110/ http://dresdencodak.com/2007/04/07/rule-110/) is hardly subtle, but amusing.
- angersock 14y agoThere are many webcomics out there that are strictly better from both a plotting and dialog standpoint--however, for simply having delightful art and interesting character design, Dresden Codak is wonderful. I'm a bit skeptical of the current Kickstarter, but here's hoping, you know?
- SomeCallMeTim 14y agoOK, confused. "Current" Kickstarter? Is there more than one? Because the one that he finished seemed to fund quite well. Skeptical that it will be late? Well, given the normal DC schedule, that wouldn't surprise me a lot. But I don't fund projects on Kickstarter expecting a particular delivery date like it's a store. So if it arrives in November I'll still be happy.
- angersock 14y agoIt's funded, to the tune of a half million--I'm curious if he'll actually be able to deliver. I hope so.
- covingkj 14y agoDresden Codak has been a fully sustainable job for Aaron Diaz for years now - this is his profession. He has also participated in at least one collaborative Kickstarter that has already delivered. Given that the professionals that have been doing the Kickstarter thing this year have largely done very well, and he already has a track record of delivering, why are you so skeptical?
- throwaway1980 14y agoStrange, I've never heard the term "figure drawing" used in the context of comics or animation. Maybe it's common within the field, but the artists I know generally associate it with drawing human models. Wikipedia doesn't mention it either. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Figure_drawing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Figure_drawing Interesting post though. I liked seeing the Cowboy Bebop characters again, and the point about the need for the body to be identifiable without clothes makes a lot of sense.
- donutdan4114 14y agoI like to over-analyze too.
- RBerenguel 14y agoThere's a book by Walt Stanchfield (former head of animation at Disney) named "Figure drawing for animation" Although the name may have changed, it used to be a photocopied book passing from hand to hand, but I read it was about to be properly published. Edit: memory failure (just woke up, I guess it counts as an excuse) The book is /Gesture/ drawing for animation, not figure drawing. I mentally mixed the article content with your reference :) The book is great, though.
- throwaway1980 14y agoSounds neat, thanks!
- egypturnash 14y agoEx-animator, now doing comics, here. My experience has always been that "figure drawing" refers to sitting down in front of a live model, probably a naked one, and drawing them. You'll see people referring to drawing from pictures of naked people as figure drawing as well. Diaz only uses the term once, at the beginning of this article: "Figure drawing is a pivotal tool to any artist, but being able to effectively render humans and creatures is only part of the equation. Even if your draftsmanship is solid, you won’t get far if your designs are uninteresting." By this, I think he is saying "it is very very important to be able to draw models from life and to know a ton of anatomy - but that's not what I'm here to talk about. I'm here to talk about character design." Which he then proceeds to do for the remainder of the article. (And I will strongly agree that a good foundation in life drawing will serve any cartoonist well, no matter how stylized their work is!) In my experience, the most common usage of the term "figure drawing" in the fields of comics and animation is "man I'm getting rusty, I really should get some figure drawing in again but I am so BUSY."
- alex_c 14y agoAnother great example is Team Fortress 2. All the characters are carefully designed to be distinguishable at a glance - I remember seeing a great explanation of this a few years back, but can only find this pdf right now: http://www.valvesoftware.com/publications/2007/NPAR07_IllustrativeRenderingInTeamFortress2.pdf http://www.valvesoftware.com/publications/2007/NPAR07_Illust...
- rictic 14y agoThe in-game developer commentary goes over this in some detail. It's quite good.
- lifeformed 14y agoThey kind of threw this out the window after all the hats and costumes, though.
- teamonkey 14y agoIt's all about the distinctive silhouettes of the character classes and how they move. Even with clothes you can quickly recognise a heavy, a pyro, a medic at a distance.
- lifeformed 14y agoIt's a lot harder though. The larger hats breaks up the silhouette quite a bit. At least you can still identify based on posture, which is done pretty well.
- anateus 14y agoThe Israeli military uses these: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitznefet_(Israeli_military) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitznefet_(Israeli_military) They're big floppy hats that go on top of the helmet to prevent the classic helmet silhouette look. Works better because human bodies aren't quite as distinctive as TF2 classes :)
- 14y ago
- roryokane 14y agoIf you’re interested in reading more tips about cartoon drawing technique, there’s a relevant book I’ve read some of, How to Make Webcomics: http://www.amazon.com/How-Make-Webcomics-Scott-Kurtz/dp/158240870X http://www.amazon.com/How-Make-Webcomics-Scott-Kurtz/dp/1582.... I sampled a few chapters in a bookstore and remember that the author of PVP gave very similar advice, which I found interesting reading. I’m not skilled enough to evaluate the book’s drawing advice, but it looked like the authors knew what they were talking about. Though I’d caution that their advice seemed skewed to comics that update often and have a relatively simple drawing style, as opposed to the kind of comic that releases a detailed full-color page once a week.
- jholman 14y agoDid you just point out that Scott Kurtz (one of the authors of that book) gave some advice similar to that given by Scott Kurtz (author of PvP)? (hopefully the humour/snark part of that comment doesn't overwhelm the information part)
- eterpstra 14y agoThis reminds me a bit of the DOTA 2 Character Art guide. Valve takes it a step further and states that a character must be identifiable by only its silhouette - including orientation and carried weapons. It's a pretty good read, even with just a passing interest in game & character art. http://media.steampowered.com/apps/dota2/workshop/Dota2CharacterArtGuide.pdf http://media.steampowered.com/apps/dota2/workshop/Dota2Chara...
- StavrosK 14y agoThey really have succeeded. I can tell which each of those heroes is by just the silhouette. Interesting read, thanks.
- groundCode 14y ago"using hair alone to distinguish heads is cheating" xkcd might disagree :)
- dasil003 14y agoOn the contrary, I think he might agree with the characterization. It is a hacker's comic after all.
- LeonidasXIV 14y agoHe explicitly mentions stick figures that can be better than photorealistic painting as readers of xkcd might agree. But take the Scott Pilgrim stories, everybody looks mostly the same except for hairstyles. I remember there is also a joke by one of the characters that everybody looks the same anyway. I'd say, these are suggestions and not hard rules. You might get away disregarding some of these.
- sp332 14y agoThe rest of the "comic theory" series: http://dresdencodak.tumblr.com/tagged/design http://dresdencodak.tumblr.com/tagged/design I think my favorite is "Primary and Secondary: A Tale of Two Focal Points". (Note the "Drawing Hands" one has a nude girl, but she's curled up and doesn't show anything. And of course the "Figures" one from OP is in there too.)
- mogrim 14y agoWhat a surprise: the only naked figures are a) women and b) cute.
- steven2012 14y agoI am an avid fan of the Walking Dead comic books, but this is the #1 problem I have with the art: I can't tell the difference between the characters. Many of the characters look the same, especially the female characters, so the story gets confusing, especially when you only buy the trade paperback every few months.