3 ms·
That app shows Youtube videos without ads. That seems like a clear violation of Youtube's TOS and I don't blame Google for being upset about it. Edit: I woulnd'
by sp332 14y ago
That app shows Youtube videos without ads. That seems like a clear violation of Youtube's TOS and I don't blame Google for being upset about it. Edit: I woulnd't flag the story though.
- kvb 14y agoIs there a YouTube API that provides the ads, or is Microsoft's only alternative to embed a YouTube web page?
- cooldeal 14y agoThe issue is that Google has refusing to give Microsoft access to the Youtube API for close to three years See my comment in the other post. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5714520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5714520
- ricardobeat 14y agoThe AppleTV YT app doesn't show ads either.
- Shank 14y agoGoogle negotiated a contract with Apple in that instance. This is the way the old iOS app worked too - Apple licensed the API in exchange for them building it. The main issue is that partners that use revenue sharing couldn't restrict their videos from playing on WP devices that wouldn't generate ad revenue. Normally, you can block devices from having content if revenue sharing is unavailable, something Microsoft circumvented.
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>That app shows Youtube videos without ads. That seems like a clear violation of Youtube's TOS and I don't blame Google for being upset about it So, for years, Google's stated reason for lack of a Youtube client was that Windows Phone didn't have enough marketshare, and now suddenly it has so many users that it loses so many ad impressions because Microsoft's Youtube that the content creators are suffering because all the millions of freeloaders using Windows Phone? i.e It doesn't care enough for the ad impressions on Windows Phone to itself make an app , but when MS does, the loss of the same revenue is the reason for sending the lawyers in and pulling the app?
- cooldeal 14y agoGoogle's "lack of marketshare" reason seems to be a bit lacking to me. Windows 8 sold 100 million and they still don't make any apps for it. In contrast, Yahoo Mail which is barely making any money by manages to make a nice one. http://apps.microsoft.com/windows/en-us/app/yahoo-mail/f90f38b5-101d-4efd-ab04-9d89cf0784dd http://apps.microsoft.com/windows/en-us/app/yahoo-mail/f90f3... And Vimeo has apps for both WP and Win8. http://www.windowsphone.com/en-us/store/app/vimeo/ff8dadc8-8efd-42c7-a0f4-de7a48dd186b http://www.windowsphone.com/en-us/store/app/vimeo/ff8dadc8-8... http://apps.microsoft.com/windows/en-us/app/vimeo/6608d199-07c0-42b8-9906-bbaace6d0a44/m/ROW http://apps.microsoft.com/windows/en-us/app/vimeo/6608d199-0...
- nivla 14y agoI think it has more to do with not having access to the API to display those ads. I have strayed from Google ever since I got a windows phone. Found decent replacements for most of their services, however Youtube is one thing that has and may never have a real replacement! Had it been a Google startup, it may not have bothered me so much. I was using it way before Google brought it and now I am punished with a second class service for my choice of phone? That is just sad. :( Just hope the same won't follow when Ubuntu and Firefox launch their phones.
- makomk 14y agoApparently it also has a button to download videos from YouTube. Google's been C&Ding anyone that does that for years.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- WayneDB 14y agoI wonder how Google would react if the websites that fuel it's search database started having TOS terms for search engines like "In your search results, you must also display the advertisements on the pages that you scrape". A few sites doing that wouldn't have any effect. Google would probably just remove them. How many websites it would take for Google to actually pay attention though? 20%? 30%? 50%?
- magicalist 14y agoThat wouldn't work. Search and display snippets of search results have been ruled as fair use in multiple cases for their transformative value. You wouldn't have a copyright claim and robots.txt has been upheld as an industry standard/easily implementable escape hatch to make it known that the crawler should not index the specified sites/pages. You could certainly say, "I'll keep you blocked in robots.txt (or block by IP or whatever) until you show my ads", but you are unlikely to succeed in that, and then there are still the downsides of not being listed in search results to consider.
- xordon 14y agoThe point of a search engine is to drive traffic to the pages that contain advertisements. MS was putting "eye's" on the content without the ads.