3 ms·
There's a fuzzy line as to who should have to get a license for this. For instance, the person that sold me Roman denarii for U.S. dollars on EBay might
by mikeyouse 14y ago
There's a fuzzy line as to who should have to get a
license for this. For instance, the person that sold me
Roman denarii for U.S. dollars on EBay might have to get
a Money Service Business license with a strict
interpretation of the law.
No offense, but the slightest bit of research will remove any 'fuzziness' in most laws, especially in easily quantifiable fields like financial services.
From the FinCEN[1]:
"An activity threshold of greater than $1,000 per person per day in one or more transactions applies to the definitions of: currency dealer or exchanger; check casher; issuer of traveler's checks, money orders or stored value; and seller or redeemer of travelers' checks, money orders or stored value. The threshold applies separately to each activity -- if the threshold is not met for the specific activity, the person engaged in that activity is not an MSB on the basis of that activity."
Literally two years ago in May of 2011 when Mt Gox filled out the
forms, Bitcoin was not considered by most people to be a "currency".
The legal distinction has nothing to do with a 'currency', only a 'store of value'. It was fairly obvious from the beginning they were ignoring Federal statutes. You can't avoid taxes by claiming to be a sovereign individual and you can't use cleverly disguised money to avoid taxes and regulations, this has all been tried before.
[1] - http://www.fincen.gov/financial_institutions/msb/definitions/msb.html http://www.fincen.gov/financial_institutions/msb/definitions...
- viggity 14y agoSo does a corn broker considered a money exchanger/transmitter? Corn be a "store of value". What about gold? Or oil? Or a Cryptographic chunk of data?
- mikeyouse 14y agoI'll start with the second part of your question; [Can] Corn be a "store of value". What about gold? Or oil? It doesn't matter. The whole point of the 'Money Services Business' designation which Bitcoin just ran into is to enforce standard regulations for all 'Financial Institutions'. The definition of 'Financial Institutions' already includes brokers, broker-dealers, exchanges, etc.[1] So [is] a corn broker considered a money exchanger/transmitter? No. They are considered brokers. Brokers and commodities exchanges are regulated separately by FINRA and the CFTC/NFA and therefore are not considered MSBs. From the regulation: The term “money services business” shall not include: .... A person registered with, and ... regulated by, the SEC or the CFTC. [2] It's all there. The concept of a 'bitcoin' isn't actually very original, people have invented dozens of currencies and other schemes to launder money and avoid taxes. Whether or not that was Bitcoin's intent, it's going to have to play by the rules as if it were. [1] - http://www.fincen.gov/financial_institutions/msb/definitions/fin_ins.html http://www.fincen.gov/financial_institutions/msb/definitions... [2] - http://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?c=ecfr&SID=b49834e109380edefdffa135472c6b6f&rgn=div8&view=text&node=31:3.1.6.1.2.1.3.1&idno=31 http://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?c=ecfr&SID=b49834e1...
- 300bps 14y agoSo which of the 6 roles is Mt Gox fulfilling? They're not a currency dealer or exchanger. They don't cash checks. They don't issue traveler's checks, money orders or stored value. They don't sell or redeem traveler's checks, money orders or stored value. This isn't even close to as cut and dry as you are trying to make it sound.