7 ms·
Publisher Threatens to Sue Blogger for $1 Billion
- Paul12345534 14y agoIt won't go unnoticed :) Ken over at Popehat picked it up... and it looks like OMICS Publishing Group's site is having some capacity problems. Enjoy the Streisand Effect. http://www.popehat.com/2013/05/15/omics-publishing-group-makes-a-billion-dollar-threat/ http://www.popehat.com/2013/05/15/omics-publishing-group-mak...
- jkldotio 14y agoJournal publishers are little more than "pdf middle men". They offer less value than scribd, which is saying something.
- mikeyouse 14y agoYou should really qualify that statement, many publishers (Nature, PNAS, etc.) are of very high quality and add significant value to the articles that they accept. Many publishers don't add any value at all but blanket statements aren't helpful.
- kanzure 14y agoAcademic phishing is real and often overlooked. Here are the articles in question: http://scholarlyoa.com/2012/05/05/omics-publishing-launches-new-brand-with-53-journal-titles/ http://scholarlyoa.com/2012/05/05/omics-publishing-launches-... http://scholarlyoa.com/2013/01/25/omics-predatory-meetings/ http://scholarlyoa.com/2013/01/25/omics-predatory-meetings/ http://scholarlyoa.com/2013/02/12/omics-ineptly-uses-social-media-to-promote-its-brands/ http://scholarlyoa.com/2013/02/12/omics-ineptly-uses-social-... That blog is hilarious, I often forward him tips from academic spam I receive. The niches just get weirder and stranger all the way down. What's really strange is that it seems to work.. someone might recognize this eventually, and nab some researchers as advisors on fake startups to boost "credibility".
- chris_wot 14y agoMaybe they meant 1 billion rupees?
- maeon3 14y agoCan India Extradite a US Citizen for violating webpage and internet data consumption/viewing related crimes defined in India and convict them and get some fraction of that billion dollars? Could the Taliban do the same thing if some Americans were found guilty of educating women against sharia law and be executed? How much do I need to be researching internet crimes defined by other countries so I don't get targeted by predators from other ecosystems?
- Paul12345534 14y agoFrom Popehat: First, if OMICS gets a civil judgment against him from India, they won't be able to enforce it here. The SPEECH Act prohibits any federal or state court in the United States from recognizing or enforcing a foreign judgment for defamation unless (1) the judgment creditor can prove that the foreign court offers equivalent protections for free speech as the defendant would have enjoyed in United States courts under the First Amendment, or (2) the judgment creditor can prove he or she would have prevailed even under the stricter standards in the United States. Second, if OMICS seeks criminal charges against Mr. Beall in India, they won't be able to extradite him there. Like most extradition treaties, the treaty between the United States and India requires dual criminality — that is, that the offense is a crime in both countries. Hurting fee-fees isn't a crime in the United States. Moreover, under these circumstances, the chance that the U.S. Departments of State or Justice would cooperate with extradition requests is effectively zero.
- mprovost 14y agoThe US govt is attempting to do a similar thing to Kim Dotcom. I assume though that it doesn't go both ways.
- Jun8 14y ago"The list now features more than 250 publishers that he considers to be "potential, possible, or probable predatory" companies, which take advantage of academics desperate to get their work published." Right there, the root cause of the problem: If you're "desperate" to get your research published, it most probably is not worth anything. These academics are not innocent victims, they usually know that these journals are not worth the paper they're printed on. But hey, it's another item in te resume.
- HarryHirsch 14y ago> These academics are not innocent victims, they usually know that these journals are not with the paper they're printed on. Are the poor sods publishing there supposed to live on air and light? They are publishing there because the rules of the game demand that they publish somewhere. Seriously, what alternative do you suggest? I do agree that there are many colleges and graduate schools that ought to be shut down today, but neither myself not anyone else has any suggestion how to go about it.
- rch 14y agoPart of the problem is that the bar for getting a terminal degree is set lower than it should be. Maybe we should be reforming the committee selection process, before taking on the publishing industry.
- Luyt 14y agoThey are publishing there because the rules of the game demand that they publish somewhere. If I were in such a situation, I would rally up my peers and create some brand new open-access publisher specifically for ourselves (and other people we like). And charge $0 ;-) And do Google searches to avoid plagiarism.
- gcr 14y agoHow is that not equivalent to just publishing on the authors' website? Everything hinges on reputation.
- 14y ago
- coldcode 14y agoI like the 20000 eminent scholars mentioned on their website. Perhaps the local cemetery?
- smoyer 14y agoI think it's funny that the lawyer includes "racial discrimination" ... but is there really anything wrong with discriminating against criminals, illogical lawyers (or anyone really) or even just stupid people? Just because I don't want to associate with someone or a class of people, doesn't mean I discriminate against them. You won't generally see me in a bar full of drunk people or a movie theatre full of people watching a chick-flick either - shouldn't we call this "preference" instead?
- eurleif 14y agoHuh? "Criminal" and "illogical lawyer" are racial groups?
- ig1 14y agoFlagged. The title on HN has been specifically changed from that on the original article "Publisher Threatens to Sue Blogger for $1-Billion" to make it seem like it's about open access when it's actually about vanity publishing. That's exactly the kind of change the "no editorializing in titles" rule is meant to cover.
- dangrossman 14y agoScholarly Open Access is the name of the blog. Scholarly Open Access Blogger is the person being sued.
- ig1 14y agoThat doesn't change the fact that it's misleading and not the original blog title. HN Policy is to keep original title unless there's a strong reason to change it.
- riazrizvi 14y agoIf this was a credible threat for the blogger, I suppose the case would have been brought to a domestic court. Though he probably should exclude India from his bucket list.
- 300bps 14y ago>If this was a credible threat for the blogger, I suppose the case would have been brought to a domestic court. Even in a domestic court, a billion dollar judgment doesn't hold much of a scare to anyone that doesn't have a billion dollars. In most states, anything you have in a retirement account (401k, IRA, Roth, etc) are partially or totally protected from creditors. Likewise 529 accounts are partially or completely protected in most states. Some states have generous homestead protections where you can protect some or all of the equity in your home. Some states don't allow wages to be garnished except for back taxes and child support. Suing individuals is not the road-to-riches that some people think it might be.
- Falling3 14y agoIs this reminding anyone else of the whole Oatmeal-FunnyJunk Debacle?
- rayiner 14y ago"In an interview with The Chronicle, Ashok Ram Kumar, a senior lawyer with IP Markets, repeatedly mentioned the criminality of Mr. Beall's blog posts. In India, Section 66A of the Information Technology Act makes it illegal to use a computer to publish 'any information that is grossly offensive or has menacing character' or to publish false information. The punishment can be as much as three years in prison." This is the flip side of the "global citizenship" bullshit people like to prattle on about--people with incompatible cultures in other countries trying to influence how you act in yours.
- lotharbot 14y ago> "This is the flip side of the "global citizenship" bullshit people like to prattle on about" Occasionally, there will be a poll of non-US citizens regarding who they would prefer to win a US political election. My response is always "you vote in your elections, I'll vote in mine. Your government can send ambassadors and diplomats to speak with mine." It doesn't even have to be other countries. Residents of Texas and California can have fairly different ideas of how to act.
- rayiner 14y agoIn that vein, people deride the U.S. for not participating in international criminal courts, and my response is a heartfelt: "thank god." For all its flaws, I'd rather only be subject to prosecution by the U.S. government, than some international entity influenced by all the countries (the vast majority of which are terrible.)
- valdiorn 14y agoThe funny (sad?) thing is that the rest of the world is terrified of the US government abducting them or extraditing them with political pressure for trumped up charges of terrorism or copyright infringement. Those people plea for help from the international courts you seem to hate. Examples: Julian Assange, Richard O'Dwyer, everyone in Guantanamo Bay. Edit: forgot Marc Emery, on drug charges.
- 14y ago
- nwzpaperman 14y agoHe should send OMICS a box of chocolates and a thank you for the free publicity. It's good to be an American in America!
- diminoten 14y ago> For example, just one hyphen separates OMICS's Entomology-2013 conference from the Entomological Society of America's Entomology 2013 conference. Sure, but what exactly are you going to call it? It's an Entomology conference in 2013, I hardly think the ESA has a "right" to the name.
- Cyranix 14y agoEntoCon 2013 International Conference on Entomology 2013 OMICS Entomology Symposium 2013 etc. At any rate I think you're interpreting the accusation quite narrowly; the assertion is that OMICS has repeatedly done this and/or performed other actions that wilfully intend to confuse and deceive (e.g. associating authors with their conference without permission). The battle isn't being fought over a hyphen in isolation.
- diminoten 14y agoI get the accusation, I'm saying it's an unfounded one amidst much more valid complaints. I'm attempting to say that there's no need for such a thing.
- akiselev 14y agoA legal "right" with respect to rights to a common English word and a number is very different from a "right" with respect to an industry that is supposed to be unbiased and thruthful. In science, the name of a publication, conference, or person means a lot. To run a "major" conference about entomology named almost exactly like the most recognizable event in the field smacks of nothing but dishonesty.
- jfb 14y ago"Good luck with that."