5 ms·
Georgia Tech to Offer $7000 Online CS Master's Degree
- leishulang 14y agolet the online phd begin....
- michael_miller 14y agoAn online PhD would be much harder to do in a large scale. The first part of a PhD is (essentially) a masters degree. That part, as evidenced by the article, could be provided in a MOOC-style format. The second part of a PhD is doing research with an advisor. You meet with your advisor every week, and he guides you through a research project. Unfortunately, this type of 1-1 interaction doesn't scale, so doing an online version of a PhD would offer comparatively few benefits compared to doing it in-person.
- michaelochurch 14y agoI have a different take on that. Some PhD students meet their advisors once a week. Some see them once a year. What's different about a PhD vs MS is the expectation of a unique, individual contribution to the field: something that's never been done before. Many people can learn existing material on their own, but very few people can get to the frontier and deliver something the field considers important (noting that what's considered important is often subject to fads and political trends that one needs social access to know where things stand) on their own. It will be interesting (and exciting) to see whether we can democratize education up to the MS level. Here's the real question, though: once we train people up to be strong computer scientists, what are they going to do in a world where priorities are set and work is defined by mediocrities? Is just knowing more going to give us the power to outperform them, or is it just one of many steps?
- thrill 14y agohttp://www.uxvuniversity.com/doctorate-degree/ http://www.uxvuniversity.com/doctorate-degree/
- vyrotek 14y agoYesterday's thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5709445 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5709445
- tych0 14y agoTo be honest, this doesn't seem like a great deal, unless you're the sort who wants that piece of paper validating your existence. Classes for an MS (at least in my experience at a top-10 US university) are not particularly more valuable than classes in undergrad. Where you really learn a lot is from your peers, which you wouldn't be able to do in an online course. Debates at lunch, in reading groups, and at the bar all made me a much better CS geek and programmer than any course I took. In fact, I'd go so far as to say I didn't learn much at all in the classes. This is nothing against the classes, the profs did a good job and prepared well (for the most part), it's just that the sheer volume of knowledge inflicted on my by my peers couldn't have been in a lecture 3-5 hours a week + some homeworks.
- gtCameron 14y agoThe piece of paper isn't to validate your self worth, its to validate to your prospective employers that you are worth more money. My quick Google search pegs the increase in starting salary going from BS to MS at $18,200 a year [1]. Being able to make that leap for $7k seems like a pretty good deal to me. [1] http://www.naceweb.org/Press/Releases/Payoff_for_Master_s_Degree_Evident_in_Starting_Salaries.aspx http://www.naceweb.org/Press/Releases/Payoff_for_Master_s_De...
- michaelochurch 14y agoI don't disagree with you. I have no idea how the market will react. However... PhD admissions are highly selective, and terminal MS programs are highly expensive. The Master's degree means you were either a top student (able to pass PhD admissions) or independently wealthy and probably packing serious connections. When it no longer means that, is it still going to provide the salary bump? Quite possibly, yes. I wouldn't call it guaranteed, though.
- gtCameron 14y agoOne of the most interesting things about how they are handling this is that they claim they are not lowering admission standards, they are just allowing people who meet those standards but can't participate in the regular program due to having a full time job, inability to move to Atlanta for 3 years, or whatever the reason is. It will be interesting to see how the market reacts to this degree. Will it be regarded as a masters degree from a top 10 program, or will it be seen as a cheap online degree that doesn't hold the same esteem?
- datalus 14y agoIf wonder if the degree will note that it was online vs on-campus.