4 ms·
If you don't like the examples I gave above, use some Google fu - I chose among a bunch of alternatives. I didn't want to just list a pile of URLs. Any particu
by bediger4000 14y ago
If you don't like the examples I gave above, use some Google fu - I chose among a bunch of alternatives. I didn't want to just list a pile of URLs.
Any particular instance of DMCA-based speech suppression is probably arguable. "Oh, that's just some crank getting riled up." You have to look at the DMCA as a system. The DMCA encourages notice and takedown, not notice and notice. The bias in copyright law as a whole is towards the rightsholder, so copyright law becomes an easy tool for abuse.
- SEMW 14y ago> You have to look at the DMCA as a system. I do? I was approaching this thread as being about the correctness of IP rights as a concept. Again, I'm not disputing the defects of the DMCA, only the use of DMCA abuse to imply that the whole concept of copyright is inherently flawed. (As it happens, I don't even live in the US, so the DMCA doesn't apply to me). > The bias in copyright law as a whole is towards the rightsholder In its current US (and EU) implementations, sure. But unless you're saying the existence of copyright as a property right itself is the bias (in which case 'unbiased copyright law' would be an oxymoron), that's an implementation issue.