3 ms·

This exactly why I think Bitcoin has no future. Soon or later it will be regulated and we will go back to the same thing.

by nazka 13y ago

camus 13y ago
it will not be regulated , it will be shut down , plain and simple , unless everybusiness out there accept bitcoins , one needs to convert it to a sound currency in order to use it.
- mrb 13y ago
  It cannot be shut down for the same reason that Bittorrent cannot be shut down: it is a peer-to-peer decentralized protocol. You need to learn about the basics... http://blog.zorinaq.com/?e=66 http://blog.zorinaq.com/?e=66
  - junto 13y ago
    I think the basic principal is that it will be unusable within the USA, because you'll have no way to convert US dollars into Bitcoin. A similar attack was made against Wikileaks. If you can't transfer your cash to Bitcoin, or your Bitcoin to cash, then the decentralized nature of Bitcoin itself is immaterial.
    - hisabness 13y ago
      people buy bitcoins for cash in person today. if anything, preventing financial institutions from accepting bitcoins makes the transactions harder to track.
    - discountgenius 13y ago
      > If you can't transfer your cash to Bitcoin, or your Bitcoin to cash, then the decentralized nature of Bitcoin itself is immaterial. Unless you can turn your bitcoins into goods and services.
    - runeks 13y ago
      > I think the basic principal is that it will be unusable within the USA, because you'll have no way to convert US dollars into Bitcoin. You'll have no way to convert electronic dollars into bitcoin. Saying that the government can prevent the conversion of cash into bitcoins is like saying it can prevent the conversion of cash into drugs.
    - mrb 13y ago
      There are plenty of ways to convert US dollars into Bitcoin, without exchanges. For one, an often overlooked and dead simple way: you can sell goods/services and tell your customers you accept Bitcoin. You can buy bitcoins for cash from sellers you meet face to face: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Category:Directories https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Category:Directories You can mine. Etc.
sneak 13y ago
I realized yesterday that the number one non-speculative use of Bitcoin (to be specific: buying stuff on SR) is already a felony in the US today. Even if it's regulated, it can't possibly be more illegal than it is now. I doubt the regulatory environment in the US will have much effect on Bitcoin adoption curves.
deleted 13y ago
[deleted]

This exactly why I think Bitcoin has no future. Soon or later it will be regulated and we will go back to the same thing.

by nazka 13y ago

This exactly why I think Bitcoin has no future. Soon or later it will be regulated and we will go back to the same thing.

camus 13y ago

it will not be regulated , it will be shut down , plain and simple , unless everybusiness out there accept bitcoins , one needs to convert it to a sound currency in order to use it.

mrb 13y ago
It cannot be shut down for the same reason that Bittorrent cannot be shut down: it is a peer-to-peer decentralized protocol. You need to learn about the basics... http://blog.zorinaq.com/?e=66 http://blog.zorinaq.com/?e=66
- junto 13y ago
  I think the basic principal is that it will be unusable within the USA, because you'll have no way to convert US dollars into Bitcoin. A similar attack was made against Wikileaks. If you can't transfer your cash to Bitcoin, or your Bitcoin to cash, then the decentralized nature of Bitcoin itself is immaterial.
  - hisabness 13y ago
    people buy bitcoins for cash in person today. if anything, preventing financial institutions from accepting bitcoins makes the transactions harder to track.
  - discountgenius 13y ago
    > If you can't transfer your cash to Bitcoin, or your Bitcoin to cash, then the decentralized nature of Bitcoin itself is immaterial. Unless you can turn your bitcoins into goods and services.
  - runeks 13y ago
    > I think the basic principal is that it will be unusable within the USA, because you'll have no way to convert US dollars into Bitcoin. You'll have no way to convert electronic dollars into bitcoin. Saying that the government can prevent the conversion of cash into bitcoins is like saying it can prevent the conversion of cash into drugs.
  - mrb 13y ago
    There are plenty of ways to convert US dollars into Bitcoin, without exchanges. For one, an often overlooked and dead simple way: you can sell goods/services and tell your customers you accept Bitcoin. You can buy bitcoins for cash from sellers you meet face to face: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Category:Directories https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Category:Directories You can mine. Etc.

sneak 13y ago

I realized yesterday that the number one non-speculative use of Bitcoin (to be specific: buying stuff on SR) is already a felony in the US today. Even if it's regulated, it can't possibly be more illegal than it is now. I doubt the regulatory environment in the US will have much effect on Bitcoin adoption curves.

deleted 13y ago

[deleted]