3 ms·
that's a very US-centric analysis. In general, you could make a different analysis: Governments should licence monopolies over pieces of the earth to prevent t
by dnautics 14y ago
that's a very US-centric analysis.
In general, you could make a different analysis: Governments should licence monopolies over pieces of the earth to prevent the Tragedy of the Commons. And Because intellectual property does not have the economic property of rivalrousness (and may even be anti-rivalrous), the tragedy of the commons does not apply, and so the moral justification for monopoly licence does not trump the government's obligation to protect the freedom to do what you want with what you have.
- rayiner 14y agoIntellectual property is not rival, but it is subject to the free rider effect. Why ignore one economic phenomenon while justifying property with a different one.
- dnautics 14y agolabelling someone who uses your intellectual effort as a "free rider" as an argument is circular logic, because that term itself is incumbent on the idea that someone who puts effort into something is a priori entitled to get something back out of it.