12 ms·
FOIA release: Completely Redacted Document About Text Snooping
- jstalin 14y agoWhat would that even mean? The title is "Guidance for the Minimization of Text Messages over Dual-Function Cellular Telephones." Any idea what minimization it is referring to? EDIT -- Found the answer to my question: http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2010/02/minimization-a-term-you-need-to-know/35403/ http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2010/02/minimiza...
- 3JPLW 14y agoVery informative link, thank you. I was likewise unaware. TLDR: minimization is the act of removing non-relevant personal data from foreign intelligence information. From the article: "Minimiaztion [sic], in essence, is the legal term for the constraints placed upon the government's ability to retain non-relevant private information collected legally. Here is the technical definition of "minimization," as supplied by 50 U.S.C. 1806 (A): Information acquired from an electronic surveillance conducted pursuant to this subchapter concerning any United States person may be used and disclosed by Federal officers and employees without the consent of the United States person only in accordance with the minimization procedures required by this subchapter. No otherwise privileged communication obtained in accordance with, or in violation of, the provisions of this subchapter shall lose its privileged character. No information acquired from an electronic surveillance pursuant to this subchapter may be used or disclosed by Federal officers or employees except for lawful purposes. "So -- the saving grace for civil liberties is the requirement that the government get rid of the information it accidentally or incidentally collects on people that isn't considered foreign intelligence information."
- D9u 14y agoThe best way to beat the censors is for multiple parties to request the same data at different times. Oftentimes the resulting FOIA documents will be redacted in differing ways, allowing the various parties to "compare notes" and hopefully piece together the complete picture.
- dm2 14y agoEveryone should assume that text messages are analyzed by a computer and flagged as necessary. Only select people under investigation would have their entire text message conversations read by a human. Does the NSA store all text messages? Yes, more than likely. Do their employees snoop on US citizens? Nope. Can other agencies have access to this data? Yes, Patriot Act. There is a very easy way to test their capabilities. Send a text message with keywords involving bombs and political figures and see what happens. I'm not going to do it, but it would be an interesting experiment. Information is critical in the world we live in. It's troubling that any secretive organizations would be able to have this much power over citizens, but the alternative is much scarier. The US has to maintain information dominance on the internet. Allowing other countries to dominate the internet could tip the scales of power. The US carries the big stick right now, if China gets the upper hand (and they are trying unimaginably hard) then what? What will the sleeping dragon do? I have nothing against China at all, but the unknown is scary and I simply would rather the US maintain indisputable dominance.
- defilade 14y agoI believe the issue is what happens to all the other data that's not related to the intent of the surveillance. For example, if you're talking to your spouse about a health issue, your sex life, etc. If that's not the target of the surveillance, the government shouldn't be retaining it.
- dm2 14y agoMore than likely they are. It is never read by humans though unless flagged. And hopefully there are checks-and-balances in place to alert others if a government employee is accessing data about someone that he personally knows. It's not as easy as "only save texts with the words bomb and weed in them". It's all saved, then analyzed, then retained a few years, then eventually deleted. Is that acceptable for the US government to do?
- jlarocco 14y agoNo, it's not. If a person isn't suspected of a crime the government shouldn't be searching or collecting any of their information. This isn't China or North Korea, we're supposed to be a free country. It's also amusing how sure you seem about some things, while also adding in a few "hopefully"-s here and there. The truth is, you don't have any idea what they're doing because they don't tell anybody.
- defilade 14y agoI'm not sure that the handling of a single document, especially one that happens to be about intelligence gathering procedures, should be THE standard by which we judge transparency.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- yew 14y agoThe entire point of FOIA requests is to allow access to previously undisclosed documents that aren't legally considered secret. The notably weird thing here is that they released a completely redacted document rather than just declining the request. Is there some minimum amount of text required to be considered a response? Politics aside, this is certainly one of the strangest things I've seen in a while.
- defilade 14y agoJust saying that a single example doesn't prove a pattern. Yeah it's a little weird, but out of the context of other FOIA requests it doesn't make much of a point.
- dangrossman 14y agoIt's a pattern. This is the same kind of response the EFF got to its FOIA requests about NSLs (national security letters). They were sent back a pack of blank pages as all the text had been redacted. When the ACLU issued a request to the FBI on GPS tracking activity, they were sent back 111 blank pages.
- defilade 14y agoYou have three instances...that meets your hurdle for statistical significance?
- deleted 14y ago
- stfu 14y agoSo we are reaching a stage where government is not just dancing around hot issues but by now they apparently don't even pretend to give a crap anymore. Unfortunately there are still enough people around whos' reaction to this is "let's start and online petition and beg the administration to declassify all the "and"s in the text".
- meritt 14y agoWe quickly need to reach a point where we encrypt everything we do on the client-side, during transmission and only readable by intended recipients.
- moxie 14y agoWe're working on this for text messages with TextSecure (http://www.whispersystems.org http://www.whispersystems.org). If you've got the time and interest to help contribute, please check it out.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 300bps 14y agoThe FBI is already whining that default use of HTTPS by Google and Facebook is ruining their snooping: http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/proposal-seeks-to-fine-tech-companies-for-noncompliance-with-wiretap-orders/2013/04/28/29e7d9d8-a83c-11e2-b029-8fb7e977ef71_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/propos...
- sneak 14y agoiMessage does this now. The problem is that the UI gives no control over the list of keys it encrypts to, so you can still be wiretapped.
- moxie 14y agoDo you have further documentation of this? There doesn't seem to be anything other than hearsay which demonstrates that they do end-to-end encryption, and some anecdotal evidence that they don't (a new device brought online will receive messages from before it was initialized, for instance).
- lvxn0va 14y agoThey must think that's funny.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoHo ho ho, the gov't discovers blackfaxing! What a merry bunch of pranksters they are. So funny! Seriously though, I'm sure there's nothing to see. Whatever the gov't does they do for our safety, and I feel foolish for suspecting otherwise.
- neeee 14y agoIs there a direct link to the PDF available?
- Scryptonite 14y agoHere you go: http://www.scribd.com/doc/141222327/Totally-Redacted-FOIA-response http://www.scribd.com/doc/141222327/Totally-Redacted-FOIA-re...