8 ms·
I'll add that, if you've never been strong, you don't know what you're missing. You could try it, and decide it's not for you. But a lot of self-professed nerd
by graeme 14y ago
I'll add that, if you've never been strong, you don't know what you're missing.
You could try it, and decide it's not for you. But a lot of self-professed nerds disdain it, assuming it's something only stupid jocks do.
It's not. Getting strong has been one of the most fulfilling things I've ever done. It's also had lasting effects in pain reduction, how other perceive me, and my self-confidence.
- nikster 14y agoI'll admit that my quick and dirty work out doesn't give me huge body builder style muscles. I am merely athletic, not huge. If I wanted to be huge, I guess I'd have to put in the work, lots of literature on the science of body building.
- beachstartup 14y ago> huge body builder style muscles those are INCREDIBLY difficult to get. you're not going to get those just by lifting big with deadlift/squat/presses a couple of times a week. it's like when women say they don't want to lift because they don't "want to get bulky". 100% pure nonsense. it's VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY difficult to get big muscles. let me say that again... it's VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY DIFFICULT to get big muscles. it has to be nearly a full time job for YEARS and YEARS of your life.
- pvnick 14y ago"Crap, I was just doing a couple squats and all of a sudden I'm as big and scary-looking as Arnold Schwarzenegger!" - no one ever
- UweSchmidt 14y agoThe women you cite have a point though (while misusing the word "bulky" in front of a bodybuilder / fitness expert) When I stopped ballroom dancing and started working out more, I did not get bulky in any way, however it surely felt that way! Gone was my coordination, my elegance, my posture! Isolated, limited movement with weight is the exact opposite of rhytmic dance movement with lots of body tension. It annoyed me, but I can imagine that this matters a lot more to women. In dancing I've seen women who might have been a little overweight, moving around gracefully. Just wanted to point that out, because I have noticed several comments like yours around the 'net recently - maybe people getting a little touchy that the work they put into their body is not appreciated sufficiently?
- graeme 14y agoWhat kind of exercises were you doing? After I started barbells, I noticed I got MUCH better at yoga and any activity that requires balance. You cannot lift 250 pounds safely without some measure of balance and grace. When I look around the gym, I see a lot of people bouncing around when lifting lighter dumbbell weights or using weight machines. It's very possible to lift weights unbalanced, to a point. However, the most efficient weight training will also train balance. I'm guessing two things happened in your case: 1. Your form was off, and you unbalanced yourself 2. Your elegance stopped because you had stopped training elegance. It was lack of dance, rather than weight lifting. Proper weight training does not destroy grace, it augments it.
- UweSchmidt 14y agofully agree with you and the other reply: Lifting requires form and balance and all that, and is beautiful in itself, and for elegance you gotta keep training elegance. I do maintain that people look bulky and uncoordinated if they are only lift weights and doing nothing else (i.e. excluded people who do other sports, or women in the acrobatic bodybuilding categories etc.). This can be normal/cool for men, but is noticable in women in my opinion. While we're in a general fitness/workout thread, I want to recommend activities that require coordination and skill. If you are looking for an activity, see if you can find a broader challenge than just a weight - learning a skill in martial arts, experiencing progress more vividly in climbing, swimming and learning all 4 styles etc. The attitude of articles like this (7 minutes) often feels like "how little do I have to do this dreaded activity for my health conscience". Meh.
- Darmani 14y agoAre you using weight machines? Those are usually isolation exercises that neglect the stabilizer muscles. Most beginning lifting programs such as Starting Strength recommend the major, compound lifts. There's something quite beautiful in watching a skilled lifter. Lifting a 200 pound bar without the slightest wobble takes no small amount of coordination, as does merely doing a powerclean at all.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- zimbatm 14y agoEveryone's different. Some people can lift for years and just become more muscular, some lift for 3 months and double their volume.
- vidarh 14y agoYou don't "double your volume" in 3 months unless your starting point is ridiculously small and/or you're counting added fat. Contrary to what fitness magazines and supplement manufacturers like to pretend, the body's ability to synthesise protein to build muscle is fairly limited. "Double" your strength, sure, in the sense that beginner gains due to improved coordination and better understanding of your actual limits means it's not uncommon to double or triple the weight you can lift in the first few months (I tripled most of mine in the first month I exercised - these days I'm lucky if I can increase my max by 2.5kg per month from starting points ranging from 90kg to ca. 200kg depending on lift; often the increase takes longer than a month by now).
- gadders 14y agoLook at the difference between a natural and "regular" bodybuilder and see if you can work out what the difference is due to.
- vidarh 14y agoAnd it's worth pointing out a couple of other things most people don't realize: Almost all of the people you see pictures off with really huge muscles today are/were heavy steroid users. Arnie looks "normal" compared to modern bodybuilders, and he used lots of steroids and put in massive amount of effort (another thing a lot of non-lifters don't understand is that steroid users don't get it easy, what they get is much faster and better recovery, letting them work harder and keep improving beyond a point where non-steroid users plateau) year after year after year. He first won a competition in 1965 after many years of exercise, and got his last Mr Olympia's in 1975 and 1980. The entire competitive field moved massively in that period with Even more so, you usually see pictures of them that are nothing at all like what they normally look like. When training for Conan, Arnold decided to take one last shot at Mr. Olympia, and went on to win the 1980. Here's what he looked like: http://www.ironmanmagazine.com/blog/johnhansen/2011/12/27/the-1980-mr-olympia-controversy/ http://www.ironmanmagazine.com/blog/johnhansen/2011/12/27/th... But he looked like this, minutes to hours at a time at most, while covered in oil and dark colouring to bring out his definition. This is Arnold near or at his peak, after months of gruelling competition preparation, followed by making sure he is hydrated just right and his muscles are pumped for competition. Outside of competition or exercise situations most lifters will be much less lean (especially power lifters) and will ironically often look smaller as a result of less definition and for many a less V-shaped torso that masks some of the development. I even find myself impressed by guys at the gym that I know for a fact are less muscular than me when they happen to be leaner so their build is more noticeable. I just did heavy (for me) bench sets this morning. When I do, my chest and arms swell enough that my normally well fitting t-shifts stretch noticeably. I have to keep adjusting my polo shirts. This lasts for a couple of hours, and the swelling wears off. I'm roughly Arnie's height, and weigh as much as he did at his peak. My body volume is bigger than he was at his peak, but I look much smaller because I have about 15kg more fat than him and 15kg or so less muscle... (I can claim my volume is bigger because muscle is more dense than fat - his overall volume would have been smaller, but concentrated in more muscle on his arms, chest and legs rather than as more evenly spread fat; I believe his waist was 34" when he was competing; I'm 36" to 38"). This is after 8 years of "recreational" lifting, starting at 30. I'm consistently in the gym 3-5 times every week outside of perhaps 2-3 weeks a year. If I started younger, and lifted more seriously, I might have gotten closer in size, but without steroids and far more work I'd have no chance of getting close to that kind of muscle volume and development. I'm not even at competitive levels for regional competitions in either power lifting or body building. Yet I look more muscular than most guys who worry about getting bulky ever will, but I look tiny compared to well developed body builders much smaller than Arnold, despite a similar body volume. Another thing most people that worry about this don't realize is that they eat way too little to ever get to even my size no matter how much they exercise. Currently I'm gaining strength at a good rate without increasing my weight thanks to mostly following intermittent fasting with a very high protein diet. Most days I eat 180g-230g of protein... Most people will find they'll be so stuffed they can hardly push more food down if they try that, pretty much irrespective of total calorie intake - getting most of it via lean chicken to give me some flexibility for other meals, still means I have nearly a kilo of chicken for lunch... I'm sick of chicken... And I am not eating enough to get steroid-eating body-builder big, by far - I currently eat at roughly maintenance levels but varying up and down to get me in a slight deficit on non-exercise days and slightly above on exercise days.
- gb 14y agoLifting for strength and lifting for large muscles are actually quite different. It is likely a huge bodybuilder type will be strong relative to the average person, but that's not their primary goal, and correspondingly you can be strong without that look too.
- phaus 14y agoExactly, there was a Gold Medal Olympic sprinter that could bench press 450lbs at a bodyweight of 175. (Can't remember which one it was, but I read it in a book by decathlete Dan O'Brien when I was about 10.)
- graeme 14y agoAs beachstartup says, huge and strong don't always go together. Before I started barbells, I had a fair amount of muscle mass. My muscles got a bit bigger, but I got a lot stronger. I'd also like to clarify that I didn't really increase my gym time to do barbells. It takes about 3 hours per week. 1 hour, 3 days per week. The main difference is the type of exercise done, and making sure that I sleep and eat in such a way to promote muscle repair.
- rquantz 14y agomaking sure that I sleep and eat in such a way to promote muscle repair. This is the main time suck for me in weight training. Eating like a combination horse/tiger is pretty time consuming.
- phaus 14y agoWeightlifting is great, but there are other methods that work well for a lot of people. You can get strong enough to bench-press 400lbs simply by doing bodyweight exercises, so it's not like someone has to choose between lifting weights or being a weakling.
- pvnick 14y ago>You can get strong enough to bench-press 400lbs simply by doing bodyweight exercises I don't see how this would ever be possible - is there a specific method you're referring to? Coaches don't put football players in front of a p90x DVD, they stick them under a barbell add some heavy weight to it.
- phaus 14y agoIt's possible by using leverage to increase the difficulty of an exercise. For example, with the push up, you can start by doing normal push-ups, then elevate your feet to add resistance. Eventually, you should be able to do handstand push-ups. When you are strong enough, you can start working through the series of exercises that leads up to doing a planche. Example of a planche. http://www.crossfitgymnastics.com/uploads/gymnastics/image/Top-Planche-Fingers-Facing-Forward1.bmp http://www.crossfitgymnastics.com/uploads/gymnastics/image/T...
- TheCapn 14y agoExcept for the fact that is baseless and ridiculous. Pushups and Handstand pushups use different muscle groups. Me being capable of doing handstand pushups does not translate in any way to me pushing more on a bench press.
- phaus 14y agoAside from the fact that you only read half of my comment, the bench-press and handstand push ups don't completely overlap, but some of the same muscles are used for both of them.
- cema 14y agoI wonder if how others perceive you has anything to do with the pain reduction...