4 ms·
Not really. You should upvote if you think the comment provides value, even if you disagree. You should downvote if the comment is wrong/invalid/offensive (as I
by tomp 14y ago
Not really. You should upvote if you think the comment provides value, even if you disagree. You should downvote if the comment is wrong/invalid/offensive (as I did now, since I think your comment is wrong), not if you disagree.
- brudgers 14y agoIf downvoting keeps someone from posting an argumentative reply to express their disagreement, HN is better for it. If upvoting a snarky comment keeps someone from posting a mean reply HN is better for that, too. People can vote however they damn well please without anyone shoulding upon them. Votes are an expression of something, whatever that something is is properly in the hands of the voter.
- caf 14y agoI've always thought of it as "useful" / "not useful". (What's the difference between thinking a comment is "wrong" and disagreeing with it?)