4 ms·
Title appears inaccurate, according to the article itself: > on technology giants like Apple and Google > taxes on sales of smart-phones and tablets > The pr
by crazygringo 14y ago
Title appears inaccurate, according to the article itself:
> on technology giants like Apple and Google
> taxes on sales of smart-phones and tablets
> The proposed tax would mirror fees already paid by television users, TV and radio broadcasters and Internet service providers
So it's nothing specific towards Apple or Google, or "anti-American", as far as I can tell from the article. It's just a device tax. So, seems a bit sensationalist.
- ekianjo 14y agoThe government is desperately out of cash, they will be looking for new taxes everywhere possible (instead of cutting their expenses, as usual), especially on what's popular. It's a wonder they have not touched at Smartphones and similar devices yet.
- carlob 14y agoMaybe the French government is out of money, and they might be even desperate, but first of all this money will be earmarked for the production of independent movies and the like. Secondly and more importantly when the French elected a socialist president they where expecting more actions like this one and many commentators think the government is not doing enough and is still too enterprise-friendly.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoIndeed, and it's not like the tech giants will pay for the tax anyway. It will be the french citizenry who pay in the form of higher prices on goods (to some extent, depending on elasticity, YMMV, no purchase necessary, etc.).
- ekianjo 14y agoWell they can earmark it where they like, it does not change the fact the country's first budget (even before Education) is dedicated to debt repayment. And things will only get worse as the confidence in the Eurozone erodes, sending future debt rates to the roof. They won't be solving much by raising taxes, and at one point raising taxes will definitely have a negative effect (i.e. significantly hurt consumption and therefore reduce the government revenues - we may already be at that point).
- loup-vaillant 14y agoOn the other hand, cutting expenses (as you seemed to be suggesting in another comment) is not the solution either. Remember how we got in this mess in the first place: (1) Stop creating money directly, but borrow from private parties instead. They will effectively create the money –fractional reserve banking and such. (2) Keep a slight deficit on your budget every year. If I recall correctly, the current French debt is 80% interests fees. If we had borrowed from our central bank instead of Rothschild&co, our current debt would have been only 20% of what it is now –well, assuming we didn't borrow even more. So, now, mainstream politics is all about the raise taxes / cut expenses false dichotomy. Our governance doesn't seem to see the obvious third alternative: stop borrowing from the market, start borrowing from the central banks at nearly 0% instead. (It can be done indirectly, despite the current EU constitution/setting: let some public agency borrow from the central bank, then let the states borrow from this agency. Of course, it requires some impossible coordination from all states)
- TheAnimus 14y ago>On the other hand, cutting expenses (as you seemed to be suggesting in another comment) is not the solution either. Remember how we got in this mess in the first place: Depends what you mean by 'this mess' if this mess is a high level of debt without the productive economic activities to service it, I'd suggest that it was by spending too much on things that didn't provide a return on investment. >They will effectively create the money –fractional reserve banking and such. No, that is not fractional reserve banking, in fact what would happen if they did just print more money? Lets pretend they could do it without breaking away from the euro. Inflation would rise sharply? Would that lead to a better economic situation? Some people say it does, hence the UKs policy on QE. >If we had borrowed from our central bank instead of Rothschild&co, our current debt would have been only 20% of what it is now –well, assuming we didn't borrow even more. That is just a gross oversimplification, and really Rothschild&co? What are we, angry I learnt economics from youtube socialists? >start borrowing from the central banks at nearly 0% instead. Historically, this action hasn't worked well. Ultimately they have debt obligations as is, they need to settle that with something, where would that something come from? They could deflate the debt, which would be the effect of creating a synthetic entity which would loan at 0%. To deflate this much debt would seriously hurt people. They could potentially try and bond default, Russia kinda got away with it (some people say it was a good idea), but then Argentina really showed the problems that can happen doing this. This is why people come down to taxation and spending, ultimately they are the only options, because any kind of inflationary policy is a cruel tax, as it is often felt more by the poorest, due to the commodities which tend to rise. Meanwhile the super rich can make money of the back of it and even increase their worth leveraged thanks to the inflation bonds and the like.
- wazoox 14y agoThey've cut expenses enormously, and the amplifying effect on growth is 1.6 (that means that the government saved 17 billions and it cost us 30 billions in lost GDP). Cutting expenses in a recession is stupid.
- varjag 14y agoJust curious, how causality between government savings and GDP losses is established? Since there was recession in the first place?
- wazoox 14y agoWell, I don't know the ins and outs, but that's what came from the ministry of Finance, IMF and OECD economists. I suppose they know what they're talking about. IIRC France state spendings represent more than 40% of GDP.
- ekianjo 14y ago> Cutting expenses in a recession is stupid. First, they are not cutting expenses "enormously" (enormously would be halving the yearly deficit, they haven't even started to stop its growth! So they are still digging further into debt every year), and then you need to spend less when your budget goes to debt repayment, if not you are going right in the wall while accelerating. Having a huge debt means the population / the whole country is living on credit, and therefore ABOVE their means. It's natural a recession would take place, whether you like it or not. Take it as a reality check.
- loup-vaillant 14y ago> Having a huge debt means the population / the whole country is living on credit, and therefore ABOVE their means. A country is not a household. The difference is not merely of scale. A country can create the freaking money. Well, except since they decided to stop that around the seventies, and borrow at a hefty interest rate instead. (By the way, thanks to things such as Fractional Reserve Banking, the money is created out of thin air anyway.) Did you know that about 80% of our (French) debt is made up of interests we paid in the past? It's hardly about a whole country living above its means. More likely, it's about a government playing Robin Hood, only in reverse –taking from the people to give to a few rich entities. Even the 20 remaining percent may not represent 20 percent too much. A part of it arguably represents actual wealth that has been created, such as transports or schools. Now I agree that we are in deep. I disagree however with the suggestion that it could be the people's fault. It's the government's fault, which is not the same thing at all. Because, we don't live in a democracy. Instead, we elect representatives based on what mass media tell us, and once elected, they hardly listen to the people. (Take the European Constitution, for instance: the people once voted "no" by referendum at about 60%. No matter, they reordered the paragraphs, and made the parliament vote instead. Basically, the government acted against the will of the people —maybe for its own good, but that's not the point.)