4 ms·
"Second amendment's been gone for a while." Not even close. True if you live in one of 10 very bad states, two of which oddly are shall issue concealed carry
by hga 14y ago
"Second amendment's been gone for a while."
Not even close. True if you live in one of 10 very bad states, two of which oddly are shall issue concealed carry ones that just went very bad (Connecticut and Colorado), but continuing that concealed carry theme, i.e. the "bear" in "the right to keep and bear arms" (RKBA), there's been a nationwide sweep of shall issue, starting in Florida in 1987 and ending with Iowa and Wisconsin in 2011. And Illinois has a Federal court deadline to go shall issue by June 9th. So that's ~42 states and ~2/3rds of the population.
And other good things have happened, and in general the political RKBA Zeitgeist has drastically changed. So there's hope here ... which is important, since it's the ultimate check on an out of control government.
- sneak 14y agoI frequent NYC, Chicago, and SF. Try again. What I'm pointing out is that when you have people like Bloomberg and Emanuel individually violating double-digit millions of individuals' constitutional rights on their whims, you don't have a free society. Whether it's RKBA this month or the right to peaceably assemble during a political convention in an election year, they get to pick and choose which rights you are allowed, with no repercussions. That's tyranny.
- hga 14y agoThose are in the 10 of the worst states, and they're the worst cities in each of the states, all but SF with their own, special, even worse laws (California has preemption, which means SF gun law is a constant of wack-a-mole, although of course they issue concealed carry licenses just about never, e.g. exactly 1 last year, to a jewler). I was born, raised, and have retired to Missouri, which once it shook off its "KKK" post-Civil War anti-gun laws in the last decade has ... well, kept up with the rest of the "good" states. When I lived in Arlington, Virginia it was also good. Massachusetts for college and work for a dozen years ... not good at all, much worse today. So due to the wonders of Federalism I believe I've lived in a free society since 1991; you, obviously not so much. And it's not a month to month thing, e.g. NY's Sullivan Act comes from 1911, when the Irish NYC Tammany Hall machine wanted to keep newer immigrants in their place. But I agree its a very big problem, about 1/3 of our nation's population are by definition subjects, not citizens, and this makes me think about Lincoln's "'A house divided against itself cannot stand.' I believe this government cannot endure, permanently half slave and half free." As for the political convention, I suspect you and I have different definitions of "peaceably assemble", plus I see no inherent issues with suppressing protests at a political convention. That's not what I understand that part of the 1st Amendment to be protecting, rather, it e.g. protects each of the conventions, where people are peaceably assembling as part of politics. I submit to you that it is at least a debatable point.
- rayiner 14y agoWhy do people love states rights except when it comes to gun laws?
- MartinCron 14y agoPeople's love for states rights is a direct response to their love for what the states choose to do with those rights.
- hga 14y agoOr, say, slavery? Another enumerated (anti-)right in the Constitution.
- mpyne 14y agoExcept that one is no longer a "right", which you can't say about the 10th Amendment.
- gyardley 14y agoBecause we're not talking about something like your ability to smoke weed here - the right to bear arms is a constitutional one. You might as well ask 'why do people love states rights except when it comes to free speech?' Same thing in my book.
- rayiner 14y agoFun fact: none of the Bill of Rights originally applied to the states. In 1795, Illinois, California, and New York could have banned all guns totally Constitutionally. It wasn't until the 1900's that the Bill of Rights was interpreted to apply to the states via the 14th amendment.
- gyardley 14y agoHell, I'm not sure the Second Amendment was fully incorporated against the states until McDonald v. Chicago in 2010. Doesn't matter a bit to me, though - it's incorporated now.
- beedogs 14y ago> since it's the ultimate check on an out of control government. Realistically, a bunch of pea-shooters stand no chance against the US military. This holds true whether it's Americans or hired sub-Saharan mercenaries driving the tanks.
- hga 14y ago"Amateurs discuss tactics, professionals discuss logistics." Forgot to add: a "pea shooter" would be a lot better description of the US rifle/carbine that's been issued since the '60s, especially with its FMJ ammo.
- DamnYuppie 14y agoRealistically our army isn't sporting the greatest record against "pea-shooters" the world over. They do good for quick and dirty but they have not held out for a prolong period of time. Add to that they will be fighting where their family and home will be in the line of fire.
- sneak 14y ago> Realistically, a bunch of pea-shooters stand no chance against the US military. This holds true whether it's Americans or hired sub-Saharan mercenaries driving the tanks. The people bearing arms isn't to shoot at the government. That's a common misconception. It's a deterrent - enough people armed and willing to shoot at the government means that the government doesn't come knocking to create the situation wherein everyone loses. It's basically p2p/distributed mutually assured destruction. Eric Blair once wrote: "That rifle hanging on the wall of the working-class flat or laborer’s cottage is the symbol of democracy. It is our job to see that it stays there." "Stays there" both in the RKBA sense, and "stays there" in the "above the mantel and not taken down out of necessity" sense.