3 ms·
Nope. I think girls should be allowed to be tomboys if they want to. Or be girly girls if they want to. I read the article as saying that it is immoral to port
by im3w1l 14y ago
Nope. I think girls should be allowed to be tomboys if they want to. Or be girly girls if they want to.
I read the article as saying that it is immoral to portray girly girls. Instead we must always show tomboys, to give girls the right role models.
I am against that.
- gknoy 14y agoI don't think that was the intent of the article. Rather, here was a potential _alternative_ role model which has been rolled back into the "princess" fold. The whole point of Merida, and the reason our family has loved her, is that she's a tomboy. She plays with bows and horses because she finds it _fun_. The message of her character isn't that it's bad to be a girly-girl, but rather that it's OK not to be. Apparently, many families felt similarly about her character -- that she's a positive role model to have in addition to (not, IMO, in lieu of) the other Disney princesses. Disney changing that seems like a "missed the point" sort of issue -- I definitely had a "what the heck?" moment when I saw the Merida dolls that didn't have a bow, for example. However, I also see the merits of an older Merida as a princess figure. Perhaps she finds she likes dress-up more, in addition to wild rides with mud and bow, as she becomes a teen.
- chc 14y agoThe point of the article is not at all that it's immoral to portray girly-girls, but that it's immoral to set that archetype up as a universal ideal and try to force all female characters into that mold. I don't know how on earth you got the former interpretation.
- silencio 14y agoI'm positively sure there are enough "girly girls" among the eleven Disney Princesses (read: ten Princesses) that one tomboy should not be a big deal. The only Princess that comes close to Merida in this regard is probably the one I grew up with: Mulan. But Mulan is portrayed as being so beautiful that it almost doesn't matter that she's clumsy and headstrong because her beauty alone would carry her a far way. To a very plain (then) girl this was still a pretty awful message and instead I resorted to reading books that didn't tell me that I had to fit a specific mold I wanted no part of. Now I get to watch Merida and watch my friends' kids watch Merida and I'm glad they have a mainstream choice that tells them it's okay not to be one of the other ten Princesses. There is nothing wrong with giving kids a choice. If anything, changing Merida to fit the usual Princess mold is pushing girls to believe that "girly girl" is the norm and tomboys are unacceptable.
- deathcakes 14y agoSorry, as opposed to we must always show them princesses to give the girls the right role models? You are for this?
- mieses 14y agoGirls should be discouraged from being too feminine (princesses) just as boys should be discouraged from being too masculine (fighting, guns). Both are debilitating to children and childhood.
- illuminate 14y agoAre you arguing against strict gender roles or for them?
- illuminate 14y ago"I read the article as saying that it is immoral to portray girly girls" You should try reading the article when you claim you read something.