4 ms·
So if you don't try to manipulate girls into being tomboys, then you are a sexist.
by im3w1l 14y ago
So if you don't try to manipulate girls into being tomboys, then you are a sexist.
- EliRivers 14y agoYou (deliberately contrarian for the sake of it?)dickhead. The character already was a tomboy (or rather, a female wanting to control her own outcomes in life). Normally I try not to insult people, and just attack their argument, but sometimes it's just really justified. Edited: To insert "deliberately contrarian", to specify the behaviour prompting the insult. It's not the person, it's the action. All happy now? :)
- phaus 14y agoIt's actually not justified. There's always a way to let someone know that they are wrong without resorting to childish name-calling. Hell, I'm autistic and even I know that.
- EliRivers 14y agoAh, I suspect you have learned a set of social rules that allow you to function in society despite your autism, and one such rule is "don't insult people". I applaud your efforts and I nonetheless disagree. Sometimes, it's justified.
- scott_s 14y agoIt makes good discussion less likely. Please don't do it.
- illuminate 14y agoThe initial poster made "good discussion" impossible with that post.
- scott_s 14y agoYes. But insulting him makes it worse. It's toxic, and adds to the noise.
- illuminate 14y agoAgreed. But where there's so little signal to the noise, there's generally not going to be much to debate, just heckling back and forth :p
- homosaur 14y agoI don't agree in this case, because OP is setting up a false premise: if you are opposed to corporate makeover, you're "manipulating girls to be tomboys" which is patently ridiculous. OP is in fact a dickhead this time.
- srumple 14y agoHuh. I read the parent comment significantly different then you did. I thought he was saying that people shouldn't try to get real, living and breathing girls to be tomboys. If they want to be tomboy, that's cool. If they want to be a princess, that's cool too. I don't think he was talking about manipulating the character, but rather manipulating the young, impressionable girls watching said character. Maybe I'm wrong, I don't know.
- MartinCron 14y agoI'm suspecting that the comment you replied to was trolling. Something so outrageous and contrarian-for-the-sake of it doesn't really need a response.
- purephase 14y agoWhile not a big fan of the movie, my impression was the character trait expressed was self-determination. I'm not even sure what you mean by "tomboy" as she was still a feminine character.
- im3w1l 14y ago'In an email to the Independent Journal on Saturday, she said she has given Bob Iger, president of Walt Disney International, "a piece of my mind" for the entertainment giant's decision to glamorize the tomboy character she envisioned.' '"There is an irresponsibility to this decision that is appalling for women and young girls," she said,' '"When little girls say they like it because it's more sparkly, that's all fine and good but, subconsciously, they are soaking in the sexy 'come hither' look and the skinny aspect of the new version. It's horrible! Merida was created to break that mold — to give young girls a better, stronger role model, a more attainable role model, something of substance, not just a pretty face that waits around for romance."' 'Signers variously described the new Merida as "vapid," "arm candy," "unrealistic" and "vacant looking."' From the article.
- shardling 14y agoAnd now I have no idea what you mean by tomboy, since it's definitely possible to be both a tomboy in some ways, but feminine in others. Anyway, the article characterizes her as a tomboy, and I think you'd find the word used often in reviews of the movie. Her enjoyment of archery and tramping through the outdoors over sewing and fancy dresses pretty clearly fits into any reasonable definition of the word.
- bitwize 14y agoShe was interested in traditionally masculine activities, such as shooting and fighting.
- chiph 14y agoIt's that Merida (the character) is fiercely independent and as-drawn, is closer in appearance to a real girl. The "new" look trashes all that and is a retread of all the current Disney princess tropes. In other words, she now looks like she was designed by a committee. "Need to lose the bow - we don't want to promote weapons." "Can we change her eyes to look more oriental? We need to appeal more to the Chinese market." "Why is her dress so dull? Can we liven it up with some sparkles & gold?"
- DanBC 14y agoNone of those changes are particularly bothersome. "Cinch in the waistline; cut that top a bit lower" are a bit more worrying. The new character looks deformed. All cartoon characters do, but this one more so.
- glhaynes 14y agoThe idea that a girl is a tomboy if she's not wearing a sparkly girdle and makeup is the problem.
- masklinn 14y agoIt's part of the problem. The other part is that "tomboy" 1. exists and 2. is an insult, as if girls are "doing it wrong" if they like to play in the woods or throw cow shit on the grumpy neighbor.
- deathcakes 14y agoOpinions like yours make me sad for all of humanity. Have you read the article? And are you willing to elaborate on your views any more? Are you actually arguing that eschewing the default generic social stereotypes that Disney seem determined to cram down everyone's throats is equal to manipulating girls into being 'tomboys'? Are you saying that girls shouldn't be allowed to choose anything other that 'girly' activities, opinions and clothes? Because if you are then yes, you are sexist.
- im3w1l 14y agoNope. I think girls should be allowed to be tomboys if they want to. Or be girly girls if they want to. I read the article as saying that it is immoral to portray girly girls. Instead we must always show tomboys, to give girls the right role models. I am against that.
- gknoy 14y agoI don't think that was the intent of the article. Rather, here was a potential _alternative_ role model which has been rolled back into the "princess" fold. The whole point of Merida, and the reason our family has loved her, is that she's a tomboy. She plays with bows and horses because she finds it _fun_. The message of her character isn't that it's bad to be a girly-girl, but rather that it's OK not to be. Apparently, many families felt similarly about her character -- that she's a positive role model to have in addition to (not, IMO, in lieu of) the other Disney princesses. Disney changing that seems like a "missed the point" sort of issue -- I definitely had a "what the heck?" moment when I saw the Merida dolls that didn't have a bow, for example. However, I also see the merits of an older Merida as a princess figure. Perhaps she finds she likes dress-up more, in addition to wild rides with mud and bow, as she becomes a teen.
- chc 14y agoThe point of the article is not at all that it's immoral to portray girly-girls, but that it's immoral to set that archetype up as a universal ideal and try to force all female characters into that mold. I don't know how on earth you got the former interpretation.
- mieses 14y agoManipulating girls into being princesses damages half of society. That's the only point.
- illuminate 14y agoThe process damages more than half of society, though.