3 ms·
plant patents are a specific type of patent. I am not a fan of Monsanto, Kagan (Kagan implied that the monsanto opinion would not necessarily apply to other se
by dnautics 14y ago
plant patents are a specific type of patent. I am not a fan of Monsanto, Kagan (Kagan implied that the monsanto opinion would not necessarily apply to other self-replicating entities - also correct), or patents in general, but I think this judgement is correct. Congress has broad authority to define and determine what constitutes intellectual property, and it's fairly clear exactly what is protected, and why, in plant patents.
Myriad genetics is attempting to use a "molecule" patent to protect a "technique". In the strictest sense, under the current patent regime, they should be allowed to restrict other people from running analysis to detect the allele USING THE PCR PRODUCT. Since the patent is not a method patent, other people should be allowed to run tests on the same allele, for example using an Affymetrix chip, which is what 23andMe uses and does not create the molecule that Myriad's PCR method creates.
The irony is that Myriad chose the molecule patent because it's more watertight than method patents to break, but coming up with "related" PCR products to break the molecule patent would be trivial.