7 ms·
'Brave' creator blasts Disney for 'blatant sexism' in princess makeover
- jcnnghm 14y agoConsidering they grossed $550 million on this, it's kind of hard to justify not doing it, if it tests better.
- herbig 14y agoBut didn't the movie gross $550 million with the original look?
- djKianoosh 14y agoethics, maybe?
- jcnnghm 14y agoIt's unethical to give people what they say they want?
- jlgreco 14y agoIn many possible cases: Yes.
- kunai 14y agoWho wanted this, though? All I see is backlash, not praise.
- jcnnghm 14y agoChapman fumed. "When little girls say they like it because it's more sparkly, that's all fine and good but, subconsciously, they are soaking in the sexy 'come hither' look and the skinny aspect of the new version. It's horrible! Merida was created to break that mold — to give young girls a better, stronger role model, a more attainable role model, something of substance, not just a pretty face that waits around for romance." That seems to indicate they tested it, and it performs better. The pushback seems to be from people whose agendas aren't being served.
- kunai 14y agoThe pushback doesn't come from "agendas," it comes from heated debate about the righteousness and morality of Disney's actions. The notion that you would attribute the backlash to some sort of hidden agenda is preposterous.
- function_seven 14y agoNothing hidden about Chapman's agenda. Nothing nefarious about it, either. It's an agenda I agree with. But the pushback definitely is coming from people whose agendas aren't being served.
- jcnnghm 14y agoWhere did I say there's a hidden agenda? It's not hidden, it's front and center. subconsciously, they are soaking in the sexy 'come hither' look and the skinny aspect of the new version. It's horrible! Merida was created to break that mold — to give young girls a better, stronger role model, a more attainable role model, something of substance, not just a pretty face that waits around for romance."
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lmm 14y agoThe silent majority who paid for the movie and didn't complain about it on the internet afterwards.
- jlgreco 14y agoThe depiction of the character in the movie is not what is upsetting people...
- raganwald 14y agoThe whole point of ethics is to know when to say "no" to giving people what they say they want. It's kind of like a "constitutional democracy." The constitution exists to limit the things a people can say they want.
- homosaur 14y agoI assume by "people" you mean "marketing weasels" because everyone I've talked to about this either finds somewhere between incredibly tasteless and a sexist attack on women.
- rmc 14y agoSometimes, yes.
- Supermighty 14y agoThis is the thing I always wonder. Did they change it because it test better, or does it test better because there is already a girl culture of cute pinkness. Nature vs nurture sort of thing.
- logjam 14y ago$550 million. Gross And downthread you're all exercised about agenda while completely giving Disney a pass on pushing an agenda? We get it. The "ethics" you're advocating argues for giving kids plates of sparkly sugar for dinner because it will "test better" and gross more.
- jcnnghm 14y agoDisney's agenda is to make money.
- kunai 14y agoI agree completely with the creator. The movie's ethos, its own theme lambasts this sort of behavior. The last thing we need are role models that pride appearance over substance. We have too many victims of that pseudo-culture already in the present day.
- slantyyz 14y agoWhile I agree with the creator's point... Taking a step back from this, you have to ask "how could this have happened?" Chances are that her original contract lets Disney do this. I wouldn't be surprised if she signed away the rights (for sequels and merchandise) to the movie's characters to Disney/Pixar in her contract. Several years ago, Disney dangled the fact that they could release crappy Toy Story sequels over Pixar when they were renegotiating the renewal of their deal. In fact, I doubt this movie would have been made had she not signed away those rights, and I assume her lawyer let her know what the real-world implications of that would have been. In other words, I don't know how she couldn't have seen this coming. While she might have assumed the best in Disney, she had a small part in letting this happen.
- kunai 14y agoPoint taken, however, would you say the same if your client, who has some programming experience, takes your code, mucks it up and deviates from the original vision? I don't think so. Especially when this is a moral issue more than it is a visionary issue. While legalities are always complex, you can't push the blame on her for not expecting Disney to screw it up.
- slantyyz 14y ago>> Point taken, however, would you say the same if your client, who has some programming experience, takes your code, mucks it up and deviates from the original vision? If my contract with them allows them to do that, then I don't really care. I do make sure that client contracts prevent them from touching code until it has been officially handed off, however. I only said she had a small part in allowing it to happen. Corporate behaviour changes with executive turnover. The next CEO of a company may not honor promises made by previous CEOs. I consider it naive to put any amount of trust in a corporation to rise above the wording in the contracts when it comes to "doing the right thing".
- im3w1l 14y agoSo if you don't try to manipulate girls into being tomboys, then you are a sexist.
- EliRivers 14y agoYou (deliberately contrarian for the sake of it?)dickhead. The character already was a tomboy (or rather, a female wanting to control her own outcomes in life). Normally I try not to insult people, and just attack their argument, but sometimes it's just really justified. Edited: To insert "deliberately contrarian", to specify the behaviour prompting the insult. It's not the person, it's the action. All happy now? :)
- phaus 14y agoIt's actually not justified. There's always a way to let someone know that they are wrong without resorting to childish name-calling. Hell, I'm autistic and even I know that.
- EliRivers 14y agoAh, I suspect you have learned a set of social rules that allow you to function in society despite your autism, and one such rule is "don't insult people". I applaud your efforts and I nonetheless disagree. Sometimes, it's justified.
- scott_s 14y agoIt makes good discussion less likely. Please don't do it.
- illuminate 14y agoThe initial poster made "good discussion" impossible with that post.
- 14y ago
- rubinelli 14y agoDisney pasteurizes another princess before adding her to its roster. How is that news?
- rz2k 14y agoSo they pastoralized the archetype for the movie, then pasteurized the iteration for later marketing?
- king_jester 14y agoIs anyone surprised? Disney isn't exactly known for representations of women that don't fall into standard sexist tropes: tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Franchise/DisneyPrincess
- tptacek 14y agoThe worst part about the makeover is that Merida's hair was a huge technical achievement for Pixar (watch a clip carefully to see why), and Disney airbrushed it out.
- tiredofcareer 14y agoTheir movies are great as a computer person and moviegoer, since each usually contains at least one "wow, that must be really hard with computers" moment. Like the fur simulation in Monsters, Inc. or the crowd physics(ish) simulation in WALL-E, or Merida's hair as you mention. Not to mention the incredible render quality progression from Toy Story to Toy Story 3.
- macspoofing 14y agoWho cares if it was a huge technical achievement? Why should that make a difference to Disney or kids who love Brave?
- tptacek 14y agoI can see it now: "Girl With The Pearl Earring: Bratz Doll Edition".
- itsybitsycoder 14y agoI watched the movie awhile ago, but I remember that you could really see how much effort and character they put into her hair. That and the bow are the most distinctive parts of her character design.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoIt's a cartoon rendering--a different canvas if you will. It wouldn't make sense to have 3d hair with inertia strapped to a painting. (Though there was some success in Treasure Planet).
- revelation 14y agoI'm having a hard time to even see the difference. That is, they both seem impractical. If you want your character to be a "strong role-model", maybe try communicating that through actions, not clothes and hair styles? I thought that kind of obsession is what we were trying to fix?
- dasil003 14y agoWell there is a movie in which actions take place that actually involve the clothes, so there is a legitimate context for the whole discussion.
- nsxwolf 14y agoHair is not as good as original. Dress is more ornate. So what? That's offensive? That the girl might sometimes wear a more expensive dress? Maybe it's a special occasion.
- Jtsummers 14y agoWhat the creator and others are finding offensive is that a character largely defined by her resistance to such things and a desire to be independent (in many senses) is being primarily presented by Disney in a typical stereotyped, dolled up fashion entirely contrary to that intent.
- mcherm 14y agoDo you remember that one movie where Richard Stallman gets up and makes a speech about how once in a while people need to set aside their ideals so we can actually make a real profit? If they DID make such a movie, would it bother you? It would bother me, because the while POINT of Richard Stallman (as far as I can tell) is to be stridently opposed to ever bending on these principles. I don't have a problem with people who put profits above principle, it's that I have a problem with Richard Stallman doing it -- it suggests that EVERYONE should put profits above principle.
- nsxwolf 14y agoI see a couple minor stylistic changes made to what a character is wearing. I guess I need to see the movie, and the part where it's made obvious that "this girl would never wear anything other than a black burlap sack, ever, ever in her life, even in the future after the story ends. Ever." But I still don't think it would constitute some offensive sexist outrage. It would just be an inconsistent portrayal.
- itsybitsycoder 14y agoEr, her original dress is a floor-length green velvet one. You're exaggerating more than a bit. And maybe you do need to see the movie, since there are multiple scenes about how much she hates wearing dresses like this.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bsimpson 14y agoBoth the Disney store and her Disneyland costume portray Merida as depicted in the film: - http://princess.disney.com/merida http://princess.disney.com/merida - http://blog.disneystore.com/blog/2013/05/merida-officially-becomes-disneys-11th-princess-with-royal-celebration.html http://blog.disneystore.com/blog/2013/05/merida-officially-b... Though I take issue with the Disney Princesses brand for many other reasons, I can't find evidence of the allegations in this article.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ajanuary 14y agoApparently they've changed it back and apologised, but I can't find a source for it. Anyone have any better luck finding it?
- mixmastamyk 14y agoI'm not a fan of Disney princess line and cringe when friends get our daughter gifts from it. However, the kids seem to like it and I don't worry much otherwise, as we keep contact limited. So I tend to understand the aggravation of the author. But, it feels like an over-reaction here (though it may be the article's tone). I didn't feel outraged despite the article and comments here expecting/demanding me to be. I had to look hard at the picture. Looks like they threw Merida in the bathtub, and put her in a nice dress and eye-color for the "ball." But, when the Princesses get together that's how they get dressed up, for a party, no? Evening wear is expected and appropriate in that situation. Is Merida supposed to show up for the Oscars in riding-chaps and bow? If this is the only representation of Merida from now on, I'd agree with the anger. But, even tomboys would dress up for a ball, even if they felt a bit itchy. They would get a lot of compliments too. That's how the world works, folks. Men have to fit into expectations too--the suit/tuxedo is ridiculous at < 35 degrees latitude. So, I feel no outrage for her to have a bit of range. From the fox-hunt to the royal ball. Even if she'd be a bit uncomfortable, we all have obligations to society.
- sp332 14y agoI don't think the photo they show is very clear. The waist is now impossibly thin, the boobs are more up-front and perky. Also the dress is not just pretty but sultry, which seems inappropriate for a young girl (this character especially). I don't know if you've seen the movie, but the character specifically acts against conventions that don't suit her. Dressing her up this way implies that the style suits her, and her creator disagrees.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoI did a google search and found some other pictures. It's true, she's a touch more conventionally attractive, but the rendering seems pretty conservative to me. In the realm of having her fit in with the others, artistic license, etc. Teenage girls actually do have shoulders and breasts and the original seems to have neither.
- 14y ago
- blhack 14y agoSomething that has bothered me for a long time about this attitude: People don't realize that some girls, in fact lots of girls, in fact I would say most of the girls I know like stereotypical "girly" things. They would like to have a dress that is sparkly like the one in the photo. The idea that who they are is somehow shameful is disgusting, and it's disgusting to me that the third-wave feminists, or whatever the group is that is pushing this rhetoric, seems to get a free pass on it. I have five sisters. Do you know what most of them love? Baking, taking care of my nieces, dressing in sparkly clothes, the color pink, etc. etc. One of my sisters recently took up woodworking. She went to the store, she bought a table saw, and now she makes things for one of her kids. Know what she still loves? Know which version of this princess she would prefer? Should she be ashamed of herself for that? Is she not a real woman, is she weak? Is she submitting to the evil male patriarchy every time she puts on a pink t-shirt or does something sterotypically girly? Because THAT is what people like this are making them feel like. Like they're failures as women because of the things that they like. -- And as long as we're talking about gender roles, let's reverse it. I like being manly. I like wearing flannel, I like chopping wood, I like welding, I like using a band saw, I like having a beard, I like having a big knife strapped to my belt when I'm camping, and I like building things out of wood. Can you imagine if there was a large group of people labeling themselves as progressive intellectuals who went out of their way to decry this "manly" behavior as somehow shameful? Every time I fire up a welder, I'm failing the rest of my gender for it. Every time I light a camp fire, I'm pushing my gender back. I should get rid of my stereotypically mannish flannel, and get something more progressive. A beard? What, so that people can look at me as some sort of manly object? Shave it off! Don't let them hold you down! The most jarring thing about this entire subset of discussions is that it seems to happen in communities that otherwise consider themselves intellectual. Please help me understand why. Why is okay to tell my sisters that they should all be ashamed of themselves?
- sp332 14y agoIf a woman is "typically" girly, that's fine. But saying a girl can't be anything else is wrong. This particular character was designed differently, and Disney is saying: no, girls can only be this way.
- 14y ago