4 ms·
Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 and $0 with prob 1/2?
Given that people are often irrational (e.g., they buy lottery tickets), would you make more money this way?
- modoc 18y agoNo. Buying a product/paying for a service isn't the same as gambling, and without a potential high payoff (3 million dollars or whatever) you aren't triggering the same neurochemicals.
- Rod 18y agoThe expected value is the same: (0.5 * 2X) + (0.5 * 0) = X = (X * 1.0) but perhaps you would be able to attract more customers. I doubt it. While it's certainly true that everybody loves a freebie, no one likes to pay twice for something. Why not charge X with probability (1-p) and charge zero with probability p? The expected value would be reduced to (1-p) but perhaps you would attract people looking for freebies. More customers is always a good thing, right?
- patio11 18y agoPeople will "irrationally" learn that your product is valueless (after all, you give it away for free) and you will attract pathological customers (the kind who would put up with this pricing model, which screams scam).
- nopassrecover 18y agoA clever idea but I worry what happens to the people that miss out. They are either aware they've paid $2X (if you tell them) or they are aware that they've been "ripped off" (you are prepared to give it away for $0 so you must have at least 50% markup. Kind of like jewellery stores putting half price sales on $10-20k diamond rings). Either way you are associating negative feelings immediately and a sense of buyer's regret. On a practical note, what stops them getting a refund and repurchasing until they get it for free.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoOn a practical note, what stops them getting a refund and repurchasing until they get it for free. Your other observation is good, too, but I think this sentence gets to the heart of the problem. The double-or-nothing transaction is irreversible, which is what makes it a bad one. People like commercial transactions that can be reversed. Ideally, both parties should walk away feeling like they got a fine deal, but that if the deal goes sour at any point in the near future (because a part was broken; because the customer had second thoughts) they would be both be willing to "undo" it without much harm done.
- harshavr 18y agomaybe you can make it reversible by refunding it on the same terms, i.e the buyer has the right to return the good to the seller, and the seller pays 2X or 0 with prob 1/2 to the buyer.
- nopassrecover 18y agoMaybe, but a) there may be statutory rights issue, b) this just seems likely to annoy people and c) you might run the risk of actually having to comply with gambling laws if you take money from people and offer them a chance of doubling it.
- omegazero 18y agoTo sell your good a consumer must be both willing and able to pay. Under this system that would be the 2X price since he doesn't know which price he will actually get (if he knew ahead of time, or could back out of the deal after learning the price, you'd always be giving them away). There's always going to be less people you can afford 2X than X.
- chaosmachine 18y agoA more common variation of this idea is "Win your purchase free!", with the odds of winning being fairly low, but the price remaining the same. Car dealerships seem to like this one, and Visa ran a similar contest here in Canada recently (called "Win What You Buy"). The success of this kind of promotion is most likely proportional to the price of your product.
- hugs 18y agoSounds like the Neo-Futurists' pricing scheme: """Tickets are $9 + the roll of a single six-sided die ($10 - $15, depending on your luck!)""" http://www.neofuturists.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=20&Itemid=45 http://www.neofuturists.org/index.php?option=com_content&...
- nostrademons 18y agoI think you're interpreting people's irrationality in the wrong way. People are often irrationally risk averse: most people would much rather pay $X with probability 1 than $2X with probability 1/2 and $0 elsewhere. The reason lottery tickets sell is because utility functions are nonlinear. After buying a $1 lotto ticket, they're still poor; they don't miss the dollar. But if they win, suddenly they are rich, which is qualitatively different from being poor. Thus, the calculation is a small but nonzero chance of being rich, vs. the certainty of being poor. Most people don't do the math to figure out just how small. There's a reason why people indulge "If I won the lottery..." fantasies.
- nsrivast 18y agoActually people are thought to be risk seeking when it comes to losses instead of gains. http://www.jstor.org/pss/1914185 http://www.jstor.org/pss/1914185 Unlike most people in this discussion, I like the idea and think it might work under certain circumstances (probably goods with low prices and high price inelasticity).
- amichail 18y agoIf they don't like this scheme, you could allow them to pay $X with prob 1. More generally, you could let them specify the pay probability p or price $Y >= $X. Given p, have them pay $X/p. Given $Y, make them pay with probability $X/$Y.
- azbob 18y agoActually, people play the lottery because they can't do math.
- cubicle67 18y agoQ: How do you increase your odds of winning Lotto by 0.0000001%? A: Buy a ticket
- anigbrowl 18y agoI'm not so sure about that. In California (and in several other places I've lived) the odds of winning are written out on the back of the ticket. Sure, a lot of people believe in not-systems like studying past numbers or drawing numbers from their dreams or casting spells; but deep down I think most people understand 'odds of winning = 1 in 57 million'. Lottery addicts certainly can't do math since they waste a lot of money on tickets. But a good many other people just buy one a week or just occasionally, eg when there's a particularly large jackpot on offer. This isn't so irrational; a regular player will make a few bucks back over the year on small prizes, and the risk/reward ratio improves for a big jackpot even though the odds don't. It's worth recalling that while the odds on any individual ticket are awful, enough people are playing that people do win big prizes on a semi-regular basis. For small-spend players who can afford it, and may think of it as semi-charitable given the uses to which lottery profits are put, is it really any more irrational than certain kinds of insurance?
- lunchbox 18y agoAs omegazero pointed out, there might be a selection bias if you don't do it right -- people will back out if they see they are in the unlucky group of folks who will get charged $2X. If you make people commit before revealing the amount, the issue is trust: how do customers know that the odds are actually 1/2 that they'll pay $0? How do they know you aren't just charging everyone $2X? You'd have to use some verifiably random bit, which gets complicated. People will smell a scam. (Speaking of which: are there any commonly used publicly verifiable random numbers, like a die roll, but outside of any party's control? I presume there must be a need for them in a number of situations.)
- gmazzola 18y agoI'm sorry if this response is off-topic, but your last question piqued my curiosity so I would like to answer it. There is an authoritative source of random numbers. In 1955, The RAND Corporation (a Cold War-era think tank) published a wonderful book entitled "A Million Random Digits with 100,000 Normal Deviates". Amazon.com has a copy of it, including some amusing reviews: http://www.amazon.com/Million-Random-Digits-Normal-Deviates/dp/0833030477 http://www.amazon.com/Million-Random-Digits-Normal-Deviates/... . For a good source of truly random numbers accessible from an API, I personally use http://random.org http://random.org . They use atmospheric noise to create random numbers, which ultimately boils down to the true randomness that is Quantum Mechanics. It's not suitable for high-security applications -- I could do some network trickery and redirect your API request to my server that always returns 1.0 -- but it's better than the PRNGs on modern computers.
- russell 18y agoYou are right. The reviews are worth the trip over to Amazon. I suspect some Amazon programmers are having a little fun with randomness.
- lunchbox 18y agoThanks for the informative reply, gmazzola. Could someone who doesn't trust random.org verify that the numbers are indeed random and impossible to rig? What I have in mind is a number that (1) nobody has influence over, (2) can be measured objectively, (3) is observable to everybody, and (4) is impossible to predict. For example, I could tell my friend that I'll do his laundry for a month if Barack Obama's speech tomorrow contains an even number of words, and he'll do my laundry otherwise. This would appear to be truly random, but what if I secretly am friends with Barack Obama and can rig it in advance? Is there some easy, practical way of producing a number whose randomness a large number of mutually distrustful parties can agree on? (I am thinking of something like asking each party to produce a number, and then publicly summing everyone's numbers together.)
- dxjones 18y agoI like the lottery ticket analogy some people have made, but here is my twist. My service costs $X per month. So if you like it, you'll want to pay $X. ... But for a just this month, there is a 1/10 chance your $X will get you the service for the entire year!! ... and if you don't "win", you still get what you paid for. I think this might encourage people who are on the edge to sign up now, and still feel good no matter what the outcome, plus they might tell their friends about it. -- David Jones
- nostrademons 18y agoThat version's been done, eg. Jordan's Furniture's "If the Red Sox win the pennant, all furniture is free!" promotion. And it works pretty well. I'd imagine that the publicity Jordan's got from that was well worth the money their insurance company paid out.
- sachinag 18y agoJust a note: we don't sign our posts/comments here. Your username does that for you. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=198817 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=198817
- rokhayakebe 18y agoThis may just be me having a bad day, but I do sense a little arrogance in your response. It does not hurt anyone if you add your name at the end of a comment.
- chuffwaffle 18y agoIt hurts everyone. It uses up screen space and reading time and has absolutely zero value.
- cubicle67 18y agoFor it to be a lottery ticket analogy, you'd pay half the cost for a 50% change of actually getting the goods
- byrneseyeview 18y agoNo. A lottery ticket is a way to buy a fantasy: if you're a housekeeper who doesn't speak much English and already has two kids, you know you'll never be rich -- but for $1, you can spend a couple hours thinking it's a possibility. To take advantage of this, you might charge 1.1X with a 10% chance of getting 10X worth of similar goods. But that wouldn't be too exciting, either.
- ajkirwin 18y agoThere is a way that you can do this. You charge $X and simply state that every Yth customer gets it free. Problem solved.
- known 18y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Gillette http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Gillette does it, right?
- schmoo 18y agoFrom experience in running various marketing campaigns, the magic 'number' is 1 in 10. Charging $X with the option of paying $1.1X (or just over, even) for a 0.1 probability of getting the money straight back will get the most people buying into the scheme. That'll be around 1 in 10 people too. Force the extra payment and around half of them will walk away there and then(1). Bump the price up to $1.1X without mentioning it, only that there's a 1 in 10 chance of getting it free and you'll see the overall take-up go up anywhere from 25% to 100%. Long story short: Make your new price $1.1X without fanfare, offer a 1 in 10 chance of getting it for free and you all win. They get their chance at a freebie at a cost they don't notice, you get your promotion vibe bumping up sales. (1)I know that that's obvious, and it was dumb to run it - but we ran it anyway for the sake of completeness.