3 ms·
That's not a fair reading; I don't assume that coercion is necessary to make money (nor do I believe PG assumes that). Excludability ≠ coercion. An advertisin
by gojomo 18y ago
That's not a fair reading; I don't assume that coercion is necessary to make money (nor do I believe PG assumes that).
Excludability ≠ coercion.
An advertising-supported site can exclude non-payers from using their advertising inventory. Money is made without coercion (and free/open-source software might be provided as an audience generator).
A consulting/services/support business can refuse to provide their service to non-clients. Money is made without coercion (and free/open-source software might be central to the delivery of services or expression of expertise).
A paid-subscription website can exclude non-subscribers. Money is made without coercion (and free/open-source software might be provided as a complement to the paise service).
The OP's proposal of angel-funding an open-source library presents a challenging case, unless some excludable complementary product can be offered. Only the dual-licensing strategy could vaguely be said to include coercion, if you believe enforcement of copyleft or copyright is coercive. And as I noted, that approach requires overcoming other market/sales/staying-power difficulties.
If you have other ideas for turning a open-source library into a money-making non-coercive business, please share -- especially if they somehow work without excludability. I'm very interested in this topic.
- inimino 18y agoI may have misread your post a bit, I was responding mainly to the dual-licensing suggestion (which read to me like a suggestion for getting around the right to fork; i.e. the "open source in name only" business model). Your points about service businesses are well-taken, though I think this is a hard and uncertain road to turning a profit. As for turning free software into a money-maker, I think not-for-profit is the stable state of a perfectly efficient software industry. That doesn't mean programmers couldn't be well paid, but it's likely nothing that would be terribly attractive to VC.