4 ms·
Mostly off topic: is it just my filter bubble, or does this flavor of deep, hate-ridden flamewar only show up in OSS projects that touch end users? I mean, on
by skrebbel 14y ago
Mostly off topic: is it just my filter bubble, or does this flavor of deep, hate-ridden flamewar only show up in OSS projects that touch end users?
I mean, on the server side, the worst kind of flamewar I've seen is TJ Holowaychuk disagreeing with Rails defaulting to CoffeeScript. It got us some drama and pictures of cats.
But end-user OSS? That's been a pit of hate and anger ever since Torvalds posted a kernel to some newsgroup.
In fact, it's one of the things that keep me from trying out stuff like Linux for real. If a question like 'which audio driver do i best install?' can only be answered by reading through a multi-year flamewar, why would I bother?
Now, since i've never really tried (or well, not in the past 14 years), the above might be entirely untrue. Still, to me, 'end-user FOSS' and 'hate and anger' are somehow symbolically linked.
Does this make sense? Do people recognise this? Or am I simply a closed-minded fool too fast in his judgment?
- sgift 14y agoFrom my experience you are probably correct. Flamewars are a result of touched emotions. If parts of my identity depend on the color of a desktop (e.g. because I've used it for 10 years) a color change will infuriate me and I may start a flamewar. This usually doesn't happen with server technology (most people couldn't care less about the internal workings of a server. They will never see it). Additionally: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bikeshedding http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bikeshedding - server software looks far more complicated than desktop software, so many people will think they understand the topics at hand and will talk about changes in the desktop software. Greater participation increases the risk of flamewars.
- gluxon 14y agoIt happens everywhere. OSS just gives you the chance to see all this in the public. It also gives end-users a way to directly communicate their pain and annoyances to developers.
- Nursie 14y ago"In fact, it's one of the things that keep me from trying out stuff like Linux for real." If you're even remotely involved in technology as a profession, this is a deficiency in your skillset. Linux now runs much of the world and isn't really a novelty. "If a question like 'which audio driver do i best install?' can only be answered by reading through a multi-year flamewar, why would I bother?" Unless you have specialist needs it's not really a question that should pop up any more, your distro of choice ought to make that decision for you. "Still, to me, 'end-user FOSS' and 'hate and anger' are somehow symbolically linked." Kinda. This is a bit different as it's not a war over "A or B" but the direction A is taking. The problem, particularly with Gnome at present, is that the direction it's taking is not appreciated by most existing users. It's compounded by the fact that a lot of people liked Gnome 2, and the Gnome team basically canned that at short notice. Distributions then started to roll out Gnome 3 and remove Gnome 2. Gnome 3 forces them to work differently and takes away a lot of choice. So users were annoyed, the desktop environment they liked seemed to be being taken away from them and the new one seemed to be making a lot of stuff worse. From the developers' perspective (as far as I can tell) the thought was basically that Gnome 2 was finished, stable, unexciting and old fashioned. A drive took place to create a new, modern desktop with a consistent experience. Logically then, this would bring new users to Linux. Some resistance from techies was to be expected, people don't like change, but they'll thank us for it in the end. I'm not 100% sure why the distros ditched Gnome 2 quite so fast, but the announcement of support and development basically being dropped didn't help. The Gnome team also seem to have gone out of their way to make sure that the two could not easily reside on the same system. Anyway, these three things in confluence make people feel like the Gnome team have taken something from them (not really true) and the Gnome team think that naysayers are all entitled and change resistant (also not really true). So it's no wonder it's a rather heated area. If you want to watch FOSS at its constructive best I recommend the debian mailing lists. You'll still find disagreement on there, but you'll also see people helping each other and getting stuff done. I think part of the reason for your perception is probably that FOSS is done far more out in the open than something like MS Windows, and in a far less hierarchical way, so there's nobody to pull rank or to hush things up. Linus may well be in charge of the kernel, but only has a limited say over the user space (for example). (This has become quite a bit longer than it was meant to be!) Also, I'd be interested to know if you think the vitriol between FOSS advocates is any worse than, say, all the Mac/Windows shouting matches you see all over the net? Or Ps3/Xbox weenies? (BTW if you really want to see FOSS vitriol go observe a GPL vs BSD license freedom debate!) I think people on the net just like to argue. I know I do. Free/Open software is developed out in the open through mass collaboration, which gives so much wonderful, flamey opportunity.
- skrebbel 14y agoGood post, and I've little to add but the following: First, the world isn't running on Linux. Webservers are, but software techology is a lot more than stuff on web servers. For example, i work in embedded software, mostly for relatively large machines (ATMs, multifunctional copiers, industrial machines that turn stuff into other stuff), and Linux isn't that common there. The most common setup is some (micro)controller with RTOS for the nitty-gritty stuff, hooked up to a Windows box for the display panel and outside communication. There's plenty other examples of tech that mostly isn't Linux. Cars? Sliding doors? Second, to answer your question, i do think the FOSS flames are harder and nastier than the win/osx platform wars. I don't know about the consoles, since I don't game much.
- Nursie 14y ago>> "First, the world isn't running on Linux." A significant portion of it is now. Maybe not desktop linux with gnome/kde/xfce/whatever, but it is in a lot of places. It's on a lot of home networking gear (NAS, routers etc), it runs a lot of the server room and has even found a home on mainframes. It's also in supercomputers and in a lot of consumer electronics these days (Android phones, kindle touch and I assume paperwhite). I too have worked in embedded software recently and can tell you that some of the newer credit card processing terminals run a fairly standard linux-on-arm with framebuffer display setup. It may be a niche desktop OS at present, but it does a hell of a lot behind the scenes, webservers are no where near the extent of it. --edit-- I wouldn't be surprised if you were right on the arguments, as they are often quite ideological in nature. --edit2-- Smart TVs! Love 'em or hate 'em, Samsung Smart Tvs run Linux too... --edit3-- Also the most popular laptop on amazon US, and third most popular on amazon.co.uk. Sure it's a chromebook, but that's just a cut down, restricted linux too. --edit4--You mention cars, Jaguar Landrover, Nissan and Toyota have recently kicked off "Automotive Grade Linux" (I swear I'll stop editing in a minute but boring day is boring...)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- skrebbel 14y ago
- mpyne 14y agoWell, end-user support is hard, there's no way around it. KDE has encountered its share of flamewars and even banned developers as well, though we normally seem to default to near the opposite end of the spectrum where we string a problem along and let it fester until finally someone will make the decision to utilize le banhammer. This has negative effects on our developer pool. After the last major crisis a couple of years ago we formed a "Community Working Group", the team behind which seems to have done a good job of helping resolve issues behind-the-scenes before they become HN and /. headlines. But to answer your question it has nothing to do with FOSS in particular, and everything to do with customer support. I used to work retail and that was way worse, at least here I can add someone to my killfile.
- reinhardt 14y agoMaybe I'm too thick-skinned but calling this particular exchange a "deep, hate-ridden flamewar" is overly dramatic.
- skrebbel 14y agoFair enough!