6 ms·
The most striking thing about the Gaza photo is that it looks fake or staged. It's weird that this won a competition because it looks like someone set the whole
by jgrahamc 14y ago
The most striking thing about the Gaza photo is that it looks fake or staged. It's weird that this won a competition because it looks like someone set the whole thing up and positioned lighting to get the effect they wanted. This is particularly true of the guy on the left who looks artificially lit.
- tommoor 14y agoIt looks like a digital render to me, it does seem bizarre that it would win.
- Anderkent 14y agoContext is everything. When presented on a webpage in the context of debunking fake photos, it's strikingly artificial. Whether we'd have the same impression for a printed photo submitted to a competition among many other photos is much harder to tell. One is likely to conclude it's just a very well taken photo that was aiming for a surreal feel.
- virtualwhys 14y ago"The most striking thing about the Gaza photo is that it" is real, those are in fact dead children, digital editing notwithstanding.
- swombat 14y agoThere are dead children all over the world, and plenty of pictures of them. A photograph is notable not because it shows dead children, but because it shows an emotionally poignant scene that reverberates with its audience. If the photo's made up, it's no better than a poster. It can be drawn with skill and make the same point, but it is not a photograph and so does not deserve a photography award.
- capex 14y agoThe emotionally poignant scene draws its weight from the fact that its showing dead children, not the photographer's technique.
- gbog 14y agoThe dead children just make it worse ethically. There are thousands ways to make a political point, the ones using dead bodies or suffering kids should be out of question. It is despicable.
- jellicle 14y agoYou seem to have things backwards. It is despicable to kill children. It is not despicable to point out that they are dead.
- blots 14y agoWhat's more despicable about killing children than about killing people of other ages? Yet it's the children that are frequently used for political arguments. And that is disgusting. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_interests_%28rhetoric%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_interests_%28rheto...
- danmaz74 14y agoWhat's more despicable about killing children than about killing people of other ages? Perhaps the fact that they can't defend themselves? Or that you can't say that you just made the world better eliminating some dangerous terrorists? Or the fact that they had their whole life to live? You only have to choose.
- bjterry 14y agoMedical (and other) interventions that are effective on children are judged as more valuable than those that are effective on the extremely elderly due to the concept of "quality adjusted life years" (QALYs)[1]. Of course, people's emotional reaction to children being killed is merely based on evolutionary adaptedness, and has nothing to do with whether its morally justified for them to feel a particular level of outrage. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year
- waps 14y agoFrankly, looking at the other fotos I find it quite hard to believe those children are even dead. Firstly, muslims would never show images of dead people, but brushing that aside (and that would require explaining why hamas would have no problem with showing a few palestinian atheists world-wide. Also would those people behaving against islam's principles be in a large angry mob on the streets of Gaza ? I mean, that is avoided by most pious muslims in Gaza I hear). Where are the wounds ? A bombardment kills by using shrapnel - lots of it - as bullets, or by crushing. Obviously these children haven't been crushed. The right child's face is full of sand, but the white burial clots is immaculate. They are lying flat ... euhm ... how did that happen ? (In case you don't know there's a reason they call a corpse "a stiff"). If they died through bombardment they wouldn't have been lying, they would have been curled up. Since nobody collects dead bodies immediately after a bombardment (would have to be in 2 hours or less), they would experience rigor mortis in the curled up position. At that point the only way to get them into a lying position would be to break all of their bones, which takes time and a lot of effort. The bodies in the picture are obviously not experiencing rigor mortis, they are flexible and move with the arms of those men ... so what is it ? Either these kids died in the last 60 minutes before the picture was taken (where's the blood ? I hear even muslims have blood. And ahem, all muscles relax, which would color such an immaculate burial cloth yellow and brown for reasons I won't go into, again where are those discolorations ?). Furthermore the eyes wouldn't stay closed. Or they're past rigor mortis, dead for at least 3 days ... so why is there skin wet ? Why is there no loss of skin tone ? And frankly a corpse 3 days old smells to the point that no emotion will allow you to ignore that, and the smell is easily detected from 10 meters away in open air (no matter how exiting a medical student tells you it is, never open a drawer with a corpse, just don't, you'll still smell it constantly a week later). The easy explanation for all of this is very, very simple : those kids are alive (they even look like they're holding their eyes closed, although that could be an impression). Lying about it would be perfectly in line with islamic practice (probably important for large angry mobs in gaze, don't you think ?), it would explain the lack of wounds, lack of blood/other bodily fluids, the eyes, the skin tone, the flexibility of the children, everything. That would of course mean that it is a complete lie, and the photographer is very likely complicit.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 14y ago>This is particularly true of the guy on the left who looks artificially lit. Ever heard of dodge and burn, in Photoshop? Also try "staging" an angry group of people, protesting and lamenting their dead children and lost relatives after yet another raid. Would anybody have the gal to say the same things for the Boston victims?
- spuz 14y agoI think you missed the point. jgc is not saying he believes the photograph has been staged, but that it looks like it has been. In other words, how did a photo that is so obviously fake win a photography contest?
- DanBC 14y agoIs there a site to compare the other entrants? A bunch of photographs today "look faked" - sometimes that's great (and lucky) lighting, or gentle tweaking of levels, or outright fakery. And the fakey look is what makes it a remarkable photo. Those faces really pop out. I'm surprised it won if they didn't get to see the RAW image. But maybe I misread the article.
- coldtea 14y ago>I think you missed the point. jgc is not saying he believes the photograph has been staged, but that it looks like it has been. In other words, how did a photo that is so obviously fake win a photography contest? I'm confused. Your "in other words" conflict with your previous statement. (1) "jgc is not saying he believes the photograph has been staged, but that it looks like it has been". (2) "In other words, how did a photo that is so obviously fake win a photography contest?" So, is he saying that it is fake (and "obviously" so), or that it merely "looks fake"? And, may I ask, what is that "obviously fake" about it, besides color adjustments? Now, it's true that color adjustment is frowned upon in certain news circles, but it's used a lot in magazine reporting, and it's not that different than what you could achieve with your choice of camera (or film in a previous era). That kind of alteration might, or might not, be acceptable for a photo competition. As for "obviously fake" as in "he staged it by putting the people in a specific position", "had lights" etc, I don't see any signs about that -- or even find it that possible given the circumstances. Those are not some "damn arabs, doing PR work and pretending to be sad and enraged". Those are parents, neighbors and friends, holding their dead children. The way some people commented here, they might as well been subhumans in the picture. For the composition part, if a photographer is half competent, he can get a very good composition out of such as scene without even trying. And he's not some tourist with his point and shoot. (Disclaimer: I've done some professional photography back in the day, but mostly travel work and interviews / portraits, not news).
- amasad 14y agoCongrats, you've done what most top HN comments do, contribute nothing but uninformed speculations and hearsay. I think you misunderstood the point of te article, it's not trying to prove that the scene was fake nor staged, but the photo was digitally edited and not worthy of the award. Digital editing aside, the scene seems to be quite real as it was covered by multiple news outlets and with different photos. Here is the link from the article to the time's photo (by the Reuters) : http://world.time.com/2012/11/15/a-new-gaza-war-israel-and-palestinian-militants-trade-fire/photo/palestinian-carry-the-bodies-of-two-boys-during-their-funeral-in-beit-lahiya-in-the-northern-gaza/ http://world.time.com/2012/11/15/a-new-gaza-war-israel-and-p...
- jgrahamc 14y agoYou are reading things I didn't say (but thank you for replying otherwise I might not have realized that people would read my comment as me implying the event was faked). I'm not in any way claiming that the scene was fake or staged. I was expressing an opinion about how it 'looked to me'. i.e. when I look at this photograph the colours and lighting remind me of pictures that have been taken in a studio or with artificial lighting. I was making that point in the context of this winning a competition for press photography where you would not expect a photo to have the look of something seen in a studio. That is all I was saying. If I wanted to make the claim that something was faked I would say so. I am claiming nothing about the event, just the look of this individual photograph and its merits independent of the event it depicts.
- gbog 14y agoI also feel this photo (not the event) do not seem natural. I don't see why this opinion should be shameful in any way. It has nothing to do with the event itself or the poor people in the scene, it has everything to do with a photographer, his tools and his deontology (work ethic).
- jjoonathan 14y agoThe implication that the methods of analysis used in the article have similar or less predictive power than your intuition is dismissive, trivializes the hard work of others, and is probably false to boot (look for false positives by google image searching "HDR"). You did not make this implication but the parent post we are discussing certainly did. To be fair, the implication was probably not made maliciously, and a more appropriate response would have been "This got past the pros because such lighting is possible to achieve in outdoor photography, although it requires a level of skill, equipment, luck, post-processing, and aesthetic risk that make it uncommon outside studio settings."
- namdnay 14y agoYeah that's the Dave Hill HDR effect, it was fashionable a few years ago. Normally it's done by composing several photos with different lighting settings, and then spending a few hours cleaning textures and saturating the hell out of everything in Photoshop