3 ms·
Yes, they have their own fab, but I looked up what I could a while back on that fab ( http://www.gwern.net/Slowing%20Moore%27s%20Law#fn23 http://www.gwern.net/S
by gwern 14y ago
Yes, they have their own fab, but I looked up what I could a while back on that fab ( http://www.gwern.net/Slowing%20Moore%27s%20Law#fn23 http://www.gwern.net/Slowing%20Moore%27s%20Law#fn23 ), and everything indicates the NSA chipfab is outdated, using very large-size features, and essentially meant for legacy system support - making old hard to replace chips, perhaps. If they're doing anything fancy, it'll be at partner chip fabs... but so many chip fabs have already left the USA that one wonders.
- michaelt 14y agoI'd imagine the economics of variable / nonrecurring engineering costs are different at that scale. Their tech might only let them make 200MHz chips instead of 2GHz, but couldn't they just make ten times as many of them? It's been a long time since CPUs have seen much of a bump in clock rates, after all - nowerdays it's all about smaller features allowing more cores/cache in the same space. If you don't care much about space as your process costs are dominated by setup rather than wafer costs, wouldn't you just use more space?
- iso8859-1 14y agoHeat dissipation is a limiting factor and larger chips require higher voltages. Which would require a even lower clock rate.
- michaelt 14y agoLet's say the NSA's chip fab is 10 years out of date - the same technologies as an Athlon XP "3000+" 2.1 GHz CPU with a 70 watt TDP. Worked just fine in a lot of consumer desktop PCs. If they needed a lower TDP, couldn't they just drop the clock rate and use wider features for lower gate leakage?
- DannyBee 14y agoAgreed. It's also likely the case that in practice, their TDP doesn't matter. Yes, they have a budget, but somehow i think their main problem is more finding sources of electricity and cooling, not paying for it.