3 ms·
One of the things I would consider a basic criterion for being able to call yourself an "independent thinker" is coming to the realization that when people thin
by jerf 18y ago
One of the things I would consider a basic criterion for being able to call yourself an "independent thinker" is coming to the realization that when people think for themselves, they come to different conclusions. Which leads to a number of obvious conclusions, including: While "the sheeple" may not have the truth, by necessity the majority of the "independent thinkers" can't either, and you can't measure how independently someone is thinking by looking at what they believe.
There is no single monolithic "the sheeple", and it is possible that low-carbers are simple a sheeple that were told to buy a book instead of watch a show like Oprah.
I say this as someone who at least intellectually is very sympathetic to the "low carb" nutritional picture; I don't think it entirely corresponds to reality, but the old-school "low-fat" diet seems outright wrong. (By "old school", I mean the old dietary standards that treat fat as a single monolithic entity. Newer stuff is getting more nuanced and, I believe, more correct, at the cost of being very difficult to describe to people in detail.)
But going back to my main point, if you still measure the "independence" of somebody's thought by what they believe, you are not your own thinker; you've simply chosen a different crowd of sheeple to run with. Nobody's really immune to this, and by this standard I have seen precious few truly independent thinkers. (Even some people who have dedicate great time to an "independent thinker" shtick almost invariable slip in some belief touchstones into their definition of independent thought, whether or not they realize it. I am not thinking of anybody in particular here; I've seen this from many such people. (I'm not quite a hypocrite on this point; the first sentence of this post is more of a definition of what I consider an independent thinker than a touchstone belief, and I freely acknowledge the existence of other useful definitions... but I'm certainly slicing things awfully fine here... but I realize it.))
This may not be directly related to the original article, but it is certainly indirectly related.