3 ms·
(Depressing news: in spite of the "economic miracle" that college is supposed to work, but hasn't for a long time, the #1 predictor of whether someone will be w
by jseliger 14y ago
(Depressing news: in spite of the "economic miracle" that college is supposed to work, but hasn't for a long time, the #1 predictor of whether someone will be wealthy is having wealthy parents.)
That might be "the #1 predictor," but out of how many predictors? What "percentage" is it, if that term is even meaningful here? How do we decide what counts as "wealthy?" Is it income or assets? If income, what happens to people making $300,000 a year but spending it all (I have met these people). What happens to the Millionaires Next Door (http://www.amazon.com/The-Millionaire-Next-Door-Surprising/dp/1589795474 http://www.amazon.com/The-Millionaire-Next-Door-Surprising/d... ; it has done more to shape my thinking about wealth than any other book. One surprising fact: most millionaires don't have extraordinary incomes but do consistently live below their means and save their extra money)?
If having "wealthy" parents is the #1 predictor and accounts for, say, 20% of the likelihood of the next generation's wealth, and, say, education accounts for another 10%, what happens if 40% is noise / randomness? Then noise accounts for twice as much as wealth! Most of the actual peer-reviewed studies I've read about this topic come to the conclusions they do through some dubious data decisions.
I'm not trying to pick a pointless, semantic fight here, but I see a lot of statements that try to compress a complex set of issues and questions into a single metric. As usually happens with this sort of thing, there's also an element of anecdote here: I have seen kids from wealthy families piss it all away and kids from poor families do the opposite. My own grandparents had virtually nothing and didn't speak English.
- 1337biz 14y agobut I see a lot of statements that try to compress a complex set of issues and questions into a single metric This needs to be posted over and over again under each posting pretending to know how "things" work. Social life is incredibly complex, and anyone pretending to have found the single, all explaining causality is flat out dishonest.
- saraid216 14y agoThere are, in fact, metrics that show social mobility by comparing generational incomes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socio-economic_mobility_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socio-economic_mobility_in_the_...
- specialist 14y agoThe repeated "citation needed" refrain is exhausting. As though declining social mobility is news. Your link is the third hit my quick search. https://www.google.com/search?q=declining+social+mobility+in+america https://www.google.com/search?q=declining+social+mobility+in... Took less time to do a quick fact check than to comment. It's ALMOST as if geeks would rather go full pedant on tangental points rather than face uncomfortable worldviews.
- saraid216 14y ago> It's ALMOST as if geeks would rather go full pedant on tangental points rather than face uncomfortable worldviews. I hesitate to say this aloud, but I... I think geeks might be human. o.O
- bconway 14y agoSorry, down-voted by accident. Agree 100%.