3 ms·
It's not quite the same effect. The ancestor gene has the benefit of having been field tested over time. If we invent a new gene, the odds are higher that it h
by graeme 14y ago
It's not quite the same effect. The ancestor gene has the benefit of having been field tested over time.
If we invent a new gene, the odds are higher that it has visible benefits but hidden downsides.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoBy no stretch of the imagination is a cross 'field-tested'. There is an entire relationship between genes in an organism, all working together, even cooperating between generations to ensure the population survives. Cross-pollination can produce entirely unfit specimens, or strains that prosper in one clime but fail in another. This can all have wonderful yield/resistance benefits for farmers. But it has always brought risk too. My father had whole hybrid crops fail when an unsuspected fungus deformed every cob. Think of genetic modification (yes, even cross-pollination) as an accelerated, guided evolution. Except instead of trying millions of experiments, seed companies sell a dozen each year. Each stalk in each wild generation is a cross; only a few have to survive to ensure the population survives. Our vastly reduced commercial genetic diversity puts our food sources at risk. Yet we cannot use plain wild strains in the modern world; half of us would starve.
- gizmo686 14y agoIs their any reason we cannot bread in genetic diversity? For example, if we cross polinate are artifical strains with wild strains, and then use standard artificial selection for the most high yielding strain, we should return to genetic diversity. The only way I can see this not working is if the specific changes we made that yield improved output are the same ones that cause problems. However, my understanding is that this is extremely unlikely, and the likely problem is that in order to get those changes we were only working with a small number of strains, so we lack genetic diversity across the entire genome. There is still the economic problem that doing this is expensive, yet causes no benefit to anyone in particular. This seems to make it the perfect candidate for the government to step in and do it.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoYou evolved that idea very well; I could not be so articulate. The free market makes us all locally optimize our own outcome; who will choose possibly sub-optimal seed just to help out the community? A sucker, that's who. The govt can help; or some other way of marketing variable-genetic seed that makes sense to the farmer. I don't see any other way.
- gizmo686 14y agoActually, I'm not sure that it isn't in a farmers own interest to invest in genetically diverse seeds. A farmers lively hood depends on the success of his crops, so diversifying them would make him more resistant to unexpected crop failures. In this way, we could view diverse seeds as a type of insurance. However if a farmer takes this insurance, even if it is a net positive investment in the long term, he will not be able to sustain himself in the short term. You typically need large entities (be them public or private) to make this type of long term investment. If it is not innitiated by the government, we might see Monsanto (or other large GM companies) make the investment. Because if one of Monsanto's crops fails catastrophically, they loose alot, however they have the capital to invest in making their crop resistent to mass failure by introducing genetic diversity. Unfourtuantly companies also tend to focus short term. If we're lucky, we will see localized mono-culture failures which will incentives all involved to invest in geneticly diverse crops.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gizmo686 14y agoI'm not that experienced in the subject, but do we really invent new genes. My understanding is that we take take existing genes from unrelated organisms. This is still substantually different from cross breading, as when we do it, the organisms to not need to be sexually compatible (or sexual), and we may insert them in ways that nature does not.