3 ms·
Whereas guitars are tuned by setting the dominant frequency of each string to a fixed reference, which can be easily automated, this is not the case for a piano
by pianopiano 14y ago
Whereas guitars are tuned by setting the dominant frequency of each string to a fixed reference, which can be easily automated, this is not the case for a piano.
This is because each piano string is governed by a non-linear differential equation describing its motion. The overtones therefore are not simple multiples of the fundamental frequency but instead appear displaced from where they would naively be expected. Although there is a strong systematic variation to these displacements, there is also a random component, rooted in difficult-to-characterize variations in the manufacture of each string.
Thus, each string unto itself has a unique Fourier spectra, and not only do the fundamentals need to be matched in frequency so as to minimize dissonance, but the higher modes as well.
Thus, ach piano has its own tuning, unique its constituent parts. (And, there may be multiple tunings for a single piano.)
Further, we do not have an adequate mathematical characterization of the sensation of 'dissonance' and thus the job of a professional piano tuner is to minimize this sensation when a pair of strings is played.
Though there are electronic systems for selecting the proper piano string fundamental, they can differ by as much as ten cents (10% of the distance between one note and the next) from a professional tuning.
Therefore, we can put a man on the moon, but we do not know how to tune a piano!