4 ms·
Can someone explain the appeal of electric cars to me? (Hear me out) Currently, we power our vehicle fleet using gasoline. The stated appeal of electric cars,
by graeme 14y ago
Can someone explain the appeal of electric cars to me? (Hear me out)
Currently, we power our vehicle fleet using gasoline. The stated appeal of electric cars, as I understand it, is less reliance on gasoline.
However, electric cars still require electricity. Currently, most of our electricity is powered by coal and other fossil fuels. While solar and renewables are increasing, they are not increasing very fast.
So it seems likely that any massive switch from gasoline to electric would entail a major increase in baseline electricity consumption. This would be powered either by more fossil fuels, or nuclear. Though the latter seems off the table in the West.
Possible advantages for electric:
1. Lower consumption of energy relative to gasoline (not sure if this is true)
2. More versatile, as electricity can come from multiple sources.
I'm not sure if #1 is true. #2 seems like a fairly small advantage, though it would be useful if oil became scarcer relative to coal.
Tesla has generated a lot of positive press. Am I missing something?
My intuition is that the electric car simply moves our consumption of energy, but does little to address our issue of mainly relying on non-renewables for energy.
(I wouldn't put much stock in any answer that emphasizes renewables, at least in the short term. They have not made a dent in our baseline power consumption, so I fail to see how adding electric cars would change much. In the long run, of course, electric cars offer the potential to power our vehicle fleet via renewables, assuming we can actually deploy them at scale [I'm skeptical on this point])
- adaml_623 14y agoCars stink. And put out pollution all through our urban space. They utilise a compact energy source but cannot utilise wind/solar power. The performance of a Tesla is comparable to a Ferrari!
- brc 14y ago>the performance of a Tesla is comparable to a Ferrari! reply No it is not. It's not even close, not even for the cheapest Ferrari. Teslas seem to be a fine car, but there is no need for this type of exaggeration.
- adaml_623 14y agoYou didn't google that at all did you. http://wot.motortrend.com/teslas-musk-says-roadster-kicks-ferraris-ass-is-he-right-8070.html#axzz2TAZED2Cy http://wot.motortrend.com/teslas-musk-says-roadster-kicks-fe... Tesla's are slower than most Ferraris but they are in the same league. When you are asking the question of why Tesla's are getting this hype the simple answer is because they are being compared to all sorts of other high performance cars.
- lobster_johnson 14y ago> ... the electric car simply moves our consumption of energy That's right. The nice thing about shifting the burden of energy production over to the electrical grid is that the energy becomes, in CS terms, an implementation detail: You can upgrade the environment impact of all the cars in an entire geographical area just by switching the underlying source of energy from, say, coal to wind or water. That is already happening in many places. Many countries are already energy-sufficient based on renewables. Norway and Sweden get most of their power from hydro, for example, Denmark gets a lot from wind. Many countries (including Germany and Australia) are gearing up to become self-sufficient within 10-20 years. Germany was at 18% in 2010, planning to be at 66% in 2020. As EVs increase in numbers and in mainstream acceptability, this will push companies to focus on the grid and on new energy sources. Right now, if everyone in the world switched to EVs, the grids would collapse. Second point: The grid (or rather, its tributaries) is simply a better place to convert raw materials into electricity. The internal combustion engine is pretty efficient, but not particularly efficient compared to, say, a coal plant. Lastly: EVs eliminate local emissions. That's a good thing.
- graeme 14y agoInteresting, thanks. So it sounds like it will be somewhat useful if we fail to deploy renewable massively, and very useful if we do.
- hellgas00 14y agoI think one of the greatest and least talked about advantages of the electric car can be illustrated by the following graphs http://media.cns-snc.ca/ontarioelectricity/ontarioelectricity.html http://media.cns-snc.ca/ontarioelectricity/ontarioelectricit... The website displays Ontario's (Province in Canada) hourly electricity output and the source of the electricity. Daily electricity demand fluctuates in Ontario by thousands of MW, so much so that houses in Ontario are now fitted with time of use meters, which charge variable rates depending on the time of the day. These meters are going to be installed in your neighborhood if they aren't already. Now where do electric cars come into the mix? During the day, electricity consumption reaches a peak, and consumer prices are doubled from ~6c/KWh to ~12c/KWh. This isn't a cash grab, different facilities charge different rates for electricity generation depending on a bunch of different factors. With millions of electric cars, and with the aid of a "smart grid" that could learn to supply power to cars during the night and drain a small portion of power during the day, the massive fluctuations of electricity production through-out the day could be flattened out, and "dirty" backup plants could be taken offline. As a car owner, you could possibly be paid for you're car's storage capacity when electricity prices spike. Another benefit of going electric, the ICE (Internal Combustion Engine) is wasteful. ICEs work most efficiently at a specific rpm, which is hard to maintain when your car demands that torque to be dynamic, energy is lost at the transmission stage. ICEs need to be cooled down, the vast majority of energy is lost to heat. Take that same fuel but instead use it to power a steam turbine, and you capture much more thermal energy from the fuel. Electric motors also boast efficiency values upwards of 90% And finally, electric engines when at a stop don't use electricity. I don't know the stats on this one but I would have to bet that billions of liters of gas are burned each year at stop lights, traffic, and at warm up. You can also regenerate energy through breaking in an electric car, instead of turning it straight to heat at the break pad. Sure there are other points to be made, and sure my comment was probably disjointed, but as a mech eng, I lose sleep at how inefficient the ICE is. I dream of the day when battery density, and cost come down significantly and make it more affordable for a middle class family to own one of these cars.
- graeme 14y agoThat's a very good point about energy utilisation at off-peak times. I hadn't considered that. There's huge potential there even if the existing grid composition stays the same. Thanks.
- hristov 14y agoThere is a huge difference between energy production at an internal combustion engine and that at a power plant. Power plants are far far more efficient. Even if they do use fossil fuels. An ice wastes most of the fuel energy into heat. At the large scale of a power plant you can capture and use most heat and can perform much better exhaust cleaning. Furthermore, most of the new power generation in the US is expected to be natural gas and solar and both of these are cleaner than gasoline.