3 ms·
> The reasons are pretty clear, its a superior way to build power trains if you can get the performance, range, and refueling issues solved. Don't want to nitp
by paganel 14y ago
> The reasons are pretty clear, its a superior way to build power trains if you can get the performance, range, and refueling issues solved.
Don't want to nitpick, but I think we're still a long way from "refueling issues" being solved world-wide in the near-term (15 to 25 years), only because electric power transmission is a damn-hard problem to solve at a global scale.
I remember reading an article linked from here a couple of months ago about how one big UK power company was handling the almost instantaneous switching on of millions of tea kettles after some BBC show had ended (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5018560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5018560). Now imagine the same scenario in a country like Nigeria (population approaching 200 million), or Brazil, or Indonesia, but with cars instead of mundane tea kettles and with a not so top-notch electrical infrastructure instead of the mature UK power grid.
I do hope though that Tesla will end up being a $100+ billion company, if only to demonstrate that true innovation can still bring big financial gains in this day and age.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoNitpicking is good, it helps to clarify the conversation. So my reference to refueling was around the time issue the GP mentioned, typical electric vehicles take a lot of time to transfer the same number of joules of energy that a gasoline car can transfer in a couple of minutes. That said, lets look a bit more at your concern. You wrote : "only because electric power transmission is a damn-hard problem to solve at a global scale." You are absolutely correct that a generalized solution for global power distribution of electricity is an unsolved problem. However you must be careful applying the general problem to a more specific case. Car charging has some nice features, one you can start and stop the electricity to it over the course of a charge and it won't notice (it will just take longer), its a constant load vs a varying load. These two aspects of it combine to make some creative solutions possible. One of them is fuel cell recharging. Fuel cells can generate energy reliably from hydrocarbons but they really don't like rapid changes in load, they are most efficient when they can deliver a steady stream of current. So from an engineering perspective you could build a fuel cell based 'supercharger' type station, where you pour in 10 - 20 gallons of gasoline and plug in. Finesses both the long distance transmission of power and the availability. But its just one of a number of creative ways to fuel cars which want electricity rather than gasoline. One of my favorite nuclear power 'hacks' was to build a 10GW nuclear plant in the middle of the desert, and next to it build a solar panel plant. Using using power (and heat) from the nuclear plant you melt silicon, refine it into crystals, smelt aluminum and build solar panels which you then truck off to places that need power. You are essentially putting the scary nuclear plant far from humans in a place they don't want to live anyway, and making a way to generate power which you then transport to places where you want power. If you put enough solar panels in your village in Nairobi to charge up your Tesla truck over the course of a week then once a week used your truck to carry goods from the village into the city, I still think that would be a benefit to the village, but I cannot prove that.
- kiba 14y agoAnd where would you find water for the nuclear power plant?
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThat is an excellent question! In the ideal case you would tap into a sub-surface aquifer, in the worst case you would initially import it (creating an artificial sub-surface aquifer :-)) Presumably for safety and economics reasons the system would run closed loop which would minimize losses. The challenge would be heat dump on the turbine supply, however given how cold it gets a night in the desert one might be able to finesse that with surface radiators connected thermally to the reservoirs. In full disclosure, when the conversation originally came up (when discussing nuclear vs solar a while ago) we just did the basic math/materials analysis and did not do a full operational analysis on the idea.